RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 11 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Line and plane: intersection, coplanarity and projection

The plane containing the line x−32=y+2−1=z−13\frac{x-3}{2} = \frac{y+2}{-1} = \frac{z-1}{3} and also containing its projection on the plane 2x+3y−z=52x + 3y - z = 5, contains which one of the following points?

SOLUTION

We have the given straight line in symmetric form

x−32  =  y+2−1  =  z−13\frac{x-3}{2}\;=\;\frac{y+2}{-1}\;=\;\frac{z-1}{3}

To change it into the parametric form, let the common ratio be tt. Thus

x=3+2t,y=−2−t,z=1+3t.x = 3 + 2t,\qquad y = -2 - t,\qquad z = 1 + 3t.

Accordingly, a fixed point on the line is

P0(3,−2,1)P_0(3,-2,1)

and its direction vector is

d⃗=⟨2, −1, 3⟩.\vec d = \langle 2,\,-1,\,3\rangle.

The other surface mentioned is the plane

2x+3y−z=5,2x + 3y - z = 5,

whose normal vector is

n⃗=⟨2, 3, −1⟩.\vec n = \langle 2,\,3,\,-1\rangle.

The required plane must contain the original line and also the projection of that line on the plane 2x+3y−z=5.2x+3y-z=5. To construct the projection, we need a direction vector that lies entirely inside the plane. The well-known formula for projecting a vector d⃗\vec d onto a plane with normal n⃗\vec n is

d⃗proj=d⃗  −  d⃗⋅n⃗∣n⃗∣2  n⃗.\vec d_{\text{proj}} = \vec d \;-\;\frac{\vec d\cdot\vec n}{|\vec n|^{2}}\;\vec n.

First compute the dot product:

d⃗⋅n⃗=2(2)+(−1)(3)+3(−1)=4−3−3=−2.\vec d\cdot\vec n = 2(2) + (-1)(3) + 3(-1) = 4 - 3 - 3 = -2.

The squared length of the normal is

∣n⃗∣2=22+32+(−1)2=4+9+1=14.|\vec n|^{2} = 2^{2} + 3^{2} + (-1)^{2} = 4 + 9 + 1 = 14.

Hence

d⃗⋅n⃗∣n⃗∣2=−214=−17.\frac{\vec d\cdot\vec n}{|\vec n|^{2}} = \frac{-2}{14} = -\frac{1}{7}.

Substituting into the projection formula,

d⃗proj=d⃗− ⁣(−17)n⃗=d⃗+17 n⃗.\vec d_{\text{proj}} = \vec d -\!\left(-\frac{1}{7}\right)\vec n = \vec d + \frac{1}{7}\,\vec n.

That is,

d⃗proj=⟨2, −1, 3⟩+17⟨2, 3, −1⟩=⟨2+27, −1+37, 3−17⟩=⟨167, −47, 207⟩.\vec d_{\text{proj}} = \Big\langle 2,\,-1,\,3\Big\rangle + \frac{1}{7}\Big\langle 2,\,3,\,-1\Big\rangle = \Big\langle 2+\tfrac{2}{7},\,-1+\tfrac{3}{7},\,3-\tfrac{1}{7}\Big\rangle = \Big\langle \tfrac{16}{7},\,-\tfrac{4}{7},\,\tfrac{20}{7}\Big\rangle.

Multiplying by the common denominator 7 we may take the simpler, parallel vector

v⃗=⟨16, −4, 20⟩=4⟨4, −1, 5⟩.\vec v = \langle 16,\,-4,\,20\rangle = 4\langle 4,\,-1,\,5\rangle.

Thus we adopt

v⃗=⟨4, −1, 5⟩\vec v = \langle 4,\,-1,\,5\rangle

as the direction vector of the projected line.

Next we need a specific point on the projection itself. The projection of the point P0(3,−2,1)P_0(3,-2,1) onto the plane is obtained by dropping a perpendicular along n⃗\vec n. A standard result is

Projplane(A)=A−λ n⃗,\text{Proj}_{\text{plane}}(A) = A - \lambda\,\vec n,

where

λ=n⃗⋅A−5∣n⃗∣2,\lambda = \frac{\vec n\cdot A - 5}{|\vec n|^{2}},

because the plane equation is n⃗⋅r⃗=5.\vec n\cdot\vec r = 5.

Compute the numerator:

n⃗⋅P0−5=[2(3)+3(−2)+(−1)(1)]−5=(6−6−1)−5=−1−5=−6.\vec n\cdot P_0 - 5 = [2(3) + 3(-2) + (-1)(1)] - 5 = (6 - 6 - 1) - 5 = -1 - 5 = -6.

Therefore

λ=−614=−37.\lambda = \frac{-6}{14} = -\frac{3}{7}.

So the projected point is

P′=P0−(−37)n⃗=(3,−2,1)+37⟨2, 3, −1⟩=(3+67, −2+97, 1−37)=(277, −57, 47).P' = P_0 - \left(-\frac{3}{7}\right)\vec n = (3,-2,1) + \frac{3}{7}\langle 2,\,3,\,-1\rangle = \Big(3+\tfrac{6}{7},\,-2+\tfrac{9}{7},\,1-\tfrac{3}{7}\Big) = \Big(\tfrac{27}{7},\,-\tfrac{5}{7},\,\tfrac{4}{7}\Big).

We now possess two non-parallel direction vectors contained in the desired plane, namely

d⃗=⟨2, −1, 3⟩\vec d = \langle 2,\,-1,\,3\rangle

and

v⃗=⟨4, −1, 5⟩,\vec v = \langle 4,\,-1,\,5\rangle,

and a point P0(3,−2,1)P_0(3,-2,1) on that plane. The normal to the required plane is provided by their cross product:

n⃗plane=d⃗×v⃗.\vec n_{\text{plane}} = \vec d \times \vec v.

Carrying out the determinant expansion,

n⃗plane=∣ijk2−134−15∣=i((−1)(5)−3(−1))  −  j(2⋅5−3⋅4)  +  k(2(−1)−(−1)4)\vec n_{\text{plane}} = \begin{vmatrix} \mathbf i & \mathbf j & \mathbf k\\ 2 & -1 & 3\\ 4 & -1 & 5 \end{vmatrix} = \mathbf i\big((-1)(5) - 3(-1)\big)\;-\; \mathbf j\big(2\cdot5 - 3\cdot4\big)\;+\; \mathbf k\big(2(-1) - (-1)4\big) =i(−5+3)−j(10−12)+k(−2+4)= \mathbf i(-5 + 3) - \mathbf j(10 - 12) + \mathbf k(-2 + 4) =−2 i+2 j+2 k.= -2\,\mathbf i + 2\,\mathbf j + 2\,\mathbf k.

A convenient proportional form is

n⃗plane=⟨−2, 2, 2⟩=−2⟨1, −1, −1⟩,\vec n_{\text{plane}} = \langle -2,\,2,\,2\rangle = -2\langle 1,\,-1,\,-1\rangle,

so we may take the simpler normal

⟨1, −1, −1⟩.\langle 1,\,-1,\,-1\rangle.

The scalar equation of a plane through P0(3,−2,1)P_0(3,-2,1) with this normal is

(x−3)⋅1+(y+2)(−1)+(z−1)(−1)=0.(x-3)\cdot1 + (y+2)(-1) + (z-1)(-1) = 0.

Simplifying term by term,

x−3−y−2−z+1=0,x - 3 - y - 2 - z + 1 = 0,

which yields

x−y−z−4=0,x - y - z - 4 = 0,

or more neatly,

x−y−z=4.x - y - z = 4.

All points contained in the required plane must satisfy this linear equation. We now test each option:

A. For (2, 2, 0): 2−2−0=0≠4.2 - 2 - 0 = 0\neq 4.(False)

B. For (−2, 2, 2): −2−2−2=−6≠4.-2 - 2 - 2 = -6\neq 4.(False)

C. For (0, −2, 2): 0−(−2)−2=0≠4.0 - (-2) - 2 = 0\neq 4.(False)

D. For (2, 0, −2): 2−0−(−2)=2+2=4 ,2 - 0 - (-2) = 2 + 2 = 4\,, which indeed satisfies the equation. (True)

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Line and plane: intersection, coplanarity and projection. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicLine and plane: intersection, coplanarity and projection
TypeMultiple choice