RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 08 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Mathematics question — Sets, subsets, power sets and set operations

Two sets A and B are as under: A={(a,b)∈R×R:∣a−5∣<1A = \{(a, b) \in R \times R : |a - 5| < 1 and ∣b−5∣<1}|b - 5| < 1\}; B={(a,b)∈R×R:4(a−6)2+9(b−5)2≤36}B = \{(a, b) \in R \times R : 4(a - 6)^2 + 9(b - 5)^2 \leq 36\}. Then:

SOLUTION

We have two subsets of the plane R×R\mathbb R \times \mathbb R defined as 

A={(a,b):∣a−5∣<1 and ∣b−5∣<1}A=\{(a,b):|a-5|<1 \text{ and } |b-5|<1\} and B={(a,b):4(a−6)2+9(b−5)2≤36}.B=\{(a,b):4(a-6)^2+9(b-5)^2\le 36\}.

First we rewrite the description of each set in a form that is easier to interpret.

For set AA, the inequalities ∣a−5∣<1|a-5|<1 and ∣b−5∣<1|b-5|<1 mean

4<a<6and4<b<6.4<a<6 \quad\text{and}\quad 4<b<6.

Thus AA is the open square whose centre is the point (5,5)(5,5) and whose side length is 22.

For set BB we begin by recalling the standard form of an ellipse. The general formula

(x−h)2p2+(y−k)2q2≤1\frac{(x-h)^2}{p^2}+\frac{(y-k)^2}{q^2}\le 1

represents an ellipse centred at (h,k)(h,k) with semi-axes pp (along the xx-direction) and qq (along the yy-direction).

We rewrite the defining inequality of BB in this standard form. Starting from

4(a−6)2+9(b−5)2≤36,4(a-6)^2+9(b-5)^2\le 36,

we divide every term by 3636:

4(a−6)236+9(b−5)236≤1.\frac{4(a-6)^2}{36}+\frac{9(b-5)^2}{36}\le 1.

Simplifying the fractions, we obtain

(a−6)29+(b−5)24≤1.\frac{(a-6)^2}{9}+\frac{(b-5)^2}{4}\le 1.

Hence BB is an ellipse with centre (6,5),(6,5), semi-major axis 33 along the aa-direction and semi-minor axis 22 along the bb-direction.

Now we test whether every point of AA also lies in BB. So let us take an arbitrary point (a,b)∈A(a,b)\in A. By membership in AA we know

∣a−5∣<1  ⟹  4<a<6,|a-5|<1 \; \Longrightarrow \; 4<a<6,

∣b−5∣<1  ⟹  4<b<6.|b-5|<1 \; \Longrightarrow \; 4<b<6.

We next estimate the two squared distances that appear in the ellipse inequality.

Because 4<a<6,4<a<6, we have

∣a−6∣=6−a<6−4=2,|a-6|=6-a<6-4=2,

so

(a−6)2<22=4.(a-6)^2<2^2=4.

Similarly, since 4<b<6,4<b<6, we get

∣b−5∣<1  ⟹  (b−5)2<1.|b-5|<1 \;\Longrightarrow\; (b-5)^2<1.

We substitute these upper bounds into the left-hand side of the ellipse condition:

(a−6)29+(b−5)24  <  49+14.\frac{(a-6)^2}{9}+\frac{(b-5)^2}{4}\;<\;\frac{4}{9}+\frac{1}{4}.

To compare this sum with 1,1, we find a common denominator 3636:

49+14=1636+936=2536.\frac{4}{9}+\frac{1}{4}=\frac{16}{36}+\frac{9}{36}=\frac{25}{36}.

Because 2536<1,\frac{25}{36}<1, we have

(a−6)29+(b−5)24<1.\frac{(a-6)^2}{9}+\frac{(b-5)^2}{4}<1.

This strict inequality certainly implies the weak inequality

(a−6)29+(b−5)24≤1,\frac{(a-6)^2}{9}+\frac{(b-5)^2}{4}\le 1,

which is exactly the condition for (a,b)(a,b) to belong to BB. Therefore every point of AA lies inside the ellipse BB; symbolically, A⊂B.A\subset B.

It remains to see that the reverse inclusion does not hold. Consider, for instance, the centre of the ellipse, the point P=(6,5).P=(6,5). Substituting into the ellipse equation gives

4(6−6)2+9(5−5)2=0≤36,4(6-6)^2+9(5-5)^2=0\le 36,

so P∈B.P\in B. However, for this point we have ∣a−5∣=∣6−5∣=1,|a-5|=|6-5|=1, which is not strictly less than 1,1, hence P∉A.P\notin A. Thus B⊄A.B\not\subset A.

Combining these results we conclude

A⊂BbutB⊄A.A\subset B \quad\text{but}\quad B\not\subset A.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Sets, subsets, power sets and set operations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicSets, subsets, power sets and set operations
TypeMultiple choice