RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 05 SEP S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Mathematics question — Venn diagrams and cardinality of sets

A survey shows that 73% of the persons working in an office like coffee, whereas 65% like tea. If xx denotes the percentage of them, who like both coffee and tea, then xx cannot be:

SOLUTION

We are told that out of all employees in an office, 73%73\% like coffee and 65%65\% like tea. Let us denote by x%x\% the employees who like both coffee and tea.

To connect these three percentages, we recall the Principle of Inclusion-Exclusion for two sets. For any two sets AA and BB, it states

∣A∪B∣=∣A∣+∣B∣−∣A∩B∣.|A\cup B|=|A|+|B|-|A\cap B|.

In our context,

∣A∣=73%,∣B∣=65%,∣A∩B∣=x%.|A|=73\%, \qquad |B|=65\%, \qquad |A\cap B|=x\%.$

Hence the percentage of employees who like at least one of the two beverages is

∣A∪B∣=73+65−x=138−x  (%).|A\cup B| = 73 + 65 - x = 138 - x\;(\%).$

This quantity obviously cannot exceed the total population, which is 100%.100\%. Therefore, we must have

138−x≤100.138 - x \le 100.

Solving this simple linear inequality step by step, we move all the terms involving xx to one side:

138−x≤100⇒−x≤100−138⇒−x≤−38.138 - x \le 100 \\ \Rightarrow -x \le 100 - 138 \\ \Rightarrow -x \le -38.$

Now dividing both sides by −1-1 (and remembering to reverse the inequality sign), we get

x≥38.x \ge 38.

This is our lower bound: the overlap x%x\% must be at least 38%.38\%.

Next, the overlap cannot exceed either of the individual percentages, because the intersection of two sets can never be larger than each set alone. Thus we have two more inequalities:

x≤73andx≤65.x \le 73 \quad\text{and}\quad x \le 65.

The tighter of these two upper bounds is 65%,65\%, so altogether we have the admissible range

38≤x≤65.38 \le x \le 65.

Now we examine the four candidate values:

Option A: 63lies between 38 and 65 (allowed),Option B: 36is <38 (not allowed),Option C: 54lies between 38 and 65 (allowed),Option D: 38equals the lower bound 38 (allowed).\begin{aligned} \text{Option A: }&63 &&\text{lies between }38\text{ and }65\ (\text{allowed}),\\ \text{Option B: }&36 &&\text{is }<38\ (\text{not allowed}),\\ \text{Option C: }&54 &&\text{lies between }38\text{ and }65\ (\text{allowed}),\\ \text{Option D: }&38 &&\text{equals the lower bound }38\ (\text{allowed}).\\ \end{aligned}$

Thus the only percentage that violates the necessary condition is 36%.36\%.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Venn diagrams and cardinality of sets. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicVenn diagrams and cardinality of sets
TypeMultiple choice