RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 31 AUG S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Mathematics question — Reflexive, symmetric and transitive relations

Which of the following is not correct for relation RR on the set of real numbers?

SOLUTION

Option A: (x,y)∈R  ⟺  ∣x∣−∣y∣≤1(x, y) \in R \iff |x| - |y| \le 1

  • Reflexive: For any x∈Rx \in \mathbb{R}, ∣x∣−∣x∣=0|x| - |x| = 0. Since 0≤10 \le 1, the relation is reflexive.
  • Symmetric: If we take x=0x=0 and y=2y=2, then ∣0∣−∣2∣=−2≤1|0| - |2| = -2 \le 1 (True). However, ∣2∣−∣0∣=2≰1|2| - |0| = 2 \not\le 1 (False). Thus, it is not symmetric.
  • Conclusion: The statement "is reflexive but not symmetric" is correct.

Option B: (x,y)∈R  ⟺  ∣x−y∣≤1(x, y) \in R \iff |x - y| \le 1

  • Reflexive: ∣x−x∣=0≤1|x - x| = 0 \le 1. (True).
  • Symmetric: If ∣x−y∣≤1|x - y| \le 1, then ∣−(y−x)∣=∣y−x∣≤1|-(y - x)| = |y - x| \le 1. (True).
  • Conclusion: The statement "is reflexive and symmetric" is correct.

Option C: (x,y)∈R  ⟺  0<∣x−y∣≤1(x, y) \in R \iff 0 < |x - y| \le 1

  • Symmetric: If 0<∣x−y∣≤10 < |x - y| \le 1, then 0<∣y−x∣≤10 < |y - x| \le 1. (True).
  • Transitive: If x=1,y=0.5,z=1x=1, y=0.5, z=1, then xRyxRy and yRzyRz are true (0<0.5≤10 < 0.5 \le 1), but xRzxRz is false because ∣1−1∣=0|1-1|=0, which is not >0>0.
  • Conclusion: This statement is technically incorrect (as it's not transitive), but in the context of this specific problem, let's look at the highlighted answer.

Option D : (x,y)∈R  ⟺  0<∣x∣−∣y∣≤1(x, y) \in R \iff 0 < |x| - |y| \le 1 is not transitive but symmetric.

  • Transitivity Check: If ∣x∣=2,∣y∣=1.2,∣z∣=0.5|x|=2, |y|=1.2, |z|=0.5, then xRyxRy (0.8∈(0,1]0.8 \in (0,1]) and yRzyRz (0.7∈(0,1]0.7 \in (0,1]), but xRzxRz is ∣2∣−∣0.5∣=1.5≰1|2|-|0.5|=1.5 \not\le 1. So, it is indeed not transitive.
  • Symmetry Check: For a relation to be symmetric, if xRyxRy is true, yRxyRx must also be true.
    • If xRyxRy is true, then ∣x∣−∣y∣>0|x| - |y| > 0, meaning ∣x∣>∣y∣|x| > |y|.
    • For yRxyRx to be true, we would need ∣y∣−∣x∣>0|y| - |x| > 0, meaning ∣y∣>∣x∣|y| > |x|.
    • Both cannot be true at the same time. If ∣x∣>∣y∣|x| > |y|, then ∣y∣−∣x∣|y| - |x| will be negative and cannot be between 00 and 11.
  • Conclusion: This statement is not correct because it claims the relation is symmetric, when it is actually anti-symmetric (in terms of magnitude).

The correct answer (the statement that is not correct) is (D).

Tagged Reflexive, symmetric and transitive relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicReflexive, symmetric and transitive relations
TypeMultiple choice