RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 03 SEP S2+4 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Mathematics question — Reflexive, symmetric and transitive relations

Let R1R_1 and R2R_2 be two relations defined as follows:
R1={(a,b)∈R2:a2+b2∈Q}R_1 = \{(a, b) \in R^2 : a^2 + b^2 \in Q\} and R2={(a,b)∈R2:a2+b2∉Q}R_2 = \{(a, b) \in R^2 : a^2 + b^2 \notin Q\}, where Q is the set of all rational numbers, then

SOLUTION

We have two relations on the set of real numbers R\mathbb R.

R1={(a,b)∈R2:a2+b2∈Q}R_1=\{(a,b)\in\mathbb R^2 : a^2+b^2\in\mathbb Q\}

R2={(a,b)∈R2:a2+b2∉Q}R_2=\{(a,b)\in\mathbb R^2 : a^2+b^2\notin\mathbb Q\}

To decide which of the two relations is transitive, recall the definition of transitivity:

A relation RR on a set is transitive if and only if

(a,b)∈R  and  (b,c)∈R  ⟹  (a,c)∈Rfor every  a,b,c.(a,b)\in R \;\text{and}\; (b,c)\in R \;\Longrightarrow\; (a,c)\in R \quad\text{for every}\; a,b,c.

First we check R1R_1. Assume (a,b)∈R1(a,b)\in R_1 and (b,c)∈R1.(b,c)\in R_1. So

a2+b2∈Qandb2+c2∈Q.a^2+b^2\in\mathbb Q\quad\text{and}\quad b^2+c^2\in\mathbb Q.

It does not automatically follow that a2+c2a^2+c^2 is rational. Indeed we exhibit three concrete numbers that break the implication.

Select

b2=2,a2=5−2,c2=5−2.b^2=\sqrt2,\qquad a^2=5-\sqrt2,\qquad c^2=5-\sqrt2.

Because 5−2>0,5-\sqrt2>0, the square-roots exist in R\mathbb R, so put

a= 5−2 ,b=2 4,c= 5−2 .a=\sqrt{\,5-\sqrt2\,},\quad b=\sqrt[\,4]2,\quad c=\sqrt{\,5-\sqrt2\,}.

Now compute the three sums of squares:

a2+b2=(5−2)+2=5∈Q,a^2+b^2=(5-\sqrt2)+\sqrt2=5\in\mathbb Q,

b2+c2=2+(5−2)=5∈Q,b^2+c^2=\sqrt2+(5-\sqrt2)=5\in\mathbb Q,

a2+c2=(5−2)+(5−2)=10−22∉Q.a^2+c^2=(5-\sqrt2)+(5-\sqrt2)=10-2\sqrt2\notin\mathbb Q.

Thus (a,b)∈R1,  (b,c)∈R1(a,b)\in R_1,\;(b,c)\in R_1 but (a,c)∉R1.(a,c)\notin R_1. Therefore R1R_1 is not transitive.

Next we examine R2R_2. Again start with two pairs in the relation and see whether the third one must follow. Choose

a=1,b=π,c=2.a=1,\qquad b=\sqrt\pi,\qquad c=2.

We have

a2=1∈Q,b2=π∉Q,c2=4∈Q.a^2=1\in\mathbb Q,\qquad b^2=\pi\notin\mathbb Q,\qquad c^2=4\in\mathbb Q.

Calculate the relevant sums:

a2+b2=1+π∉Q  ⟹  (a,b)∈R2,a^2+b^2=1+\pi\notin\mathbb Q\;\Longrightarrow\;(a,b)\in R_2,

b2+c2=π+4∉Q  ⟹  (b,c)∈R2,b^2+c^2=\pi+4\notin\mathbb Q\;\Longrightarrow\;(b,c)\in R_2,

a2+c2=1+4=5∈Q  ⟹  (a,c)∉R2.a^2+c^2=1+4=5\in\mathbb Q\;\Longrightarrow\;(a,c)\notin R_2.

Hence (a,b)∈R2(a,b)\in R_2 and (b,c)∈R2(b,c)\in R_2 do not force (a,c)∈R2(a,c)\in R_2. So R2R_2 also fails to be transitive.

We have shown that neither of the two relations satisfies the transitivity condition. Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Reflexive, symmetric and transitive relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicReflexive, symmetric and transitive relations
TypeMultiple choice