RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 03 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Mathematics question — Sets, subsets, power sets and set operations

Consider the two sets:
A={m∈R:both the roots of x2−(m+1)x+m+4=0 are real}A = \{m \in R : \text{both the roots of } x^2 - (m+1)x + m + 4 = 0 \text{ are real}\} and B=[−3,5)B = [-3, 5)
Which of the following is not true?

SOLUTION

We are given the quadratic equation x2−(m+1)x+m+4=0x^{2}-(m+1)x+m+4=0 and we must find all real numbers mm for which both its roots are real.

For any quadratic equation ax2+bx+c=0,ax^{2}+bx+c=0, the condition for real roots is that its discriminant is non-negative.

So we state the formula: If ax2+bx+c=0,  then real roots⟺b2−4ac≥0.\text{If } ax^{2}+bx+c=0,\; \text{then real roots} \Longleftrightarrow b^{2}-4ac\ge 0.

Here, by comparison, we have a=1,  b=−(m+1),  c=m+4.a=1,\; b=-(m+1),\; c=m+4.

Now we compute the discriminant:

D=b2−4ac=(−(m+1))2−4(1)(m+4)=(m+1)2−4m−16.\begin{aligned} D &= b^{2}-4ac \\ &= (-(m+1))^{2}-4(1)(m+4) \\ &= (m+1)^{2}-4m-16. \end{aligned}

Next, we expand (m+1)2:(m+1)^{2}:

(m+1)2=m2+2m+1,∴D=(m2+2m+1)−4m−16=m2+2m+1−4m−16=m2−2m−15.\begin{aligned} (m+1)^{2} &= m^{2}+2m+1, \\ \therefore D &= (m^{2}+2m+1)-4m-16 \\ &= m^{2}+2m+1-4m-16 \\ &= m^{2}-2m-15. \end{aligned}

For real roots we require D≥0,D\ge 0, so

m2−2m−15≥0.m^{2}-2m-15\ge 0.

We factor the left side completely:

m2−2m−15=(m−5)(m+3).m^{2}-2m-15=(m-5)(m+3).

Thus,

(m−5)(m+3)≥0.(m-5)(m+3)\ge 0.

For a product of two linear factors, the inequality PQ≥0PQ\ge 0 holds when both factors are non-negative or both are non-positive. Analysis of the critical points m=−3m=-3 and m=5m=5 gives:

m≤−3orm≥5.m\le -3 \quad \text{or} \quad m\ge 5.

Therefore

A=(−∞, −3]  ∪  [5,∞).A = (-\infty,\,-3]\;\cup\;[5,\infty).

We are also given

B=[−3, 5).B=[-3,\,5).

Now we examine each option one by one.

Option A: A−B=(−∞,−3)∪(5,∞)A-B = (-\infty,-3)\cup(5,\infty)

We calculate A−BA-B carefully.

  • On the left of −3,-3, the interval (−∞,−3](-\infty,-3] is in AA; removing the point −3-3 (because −3∈B-3\in B) leaves (−∞,−3).(-\infty,-3).
  • On the right, [5,∞)[5,\infty) lies totally outside BB because BB stops just before 5.5. Hence the entire closed interval [5,∞)[5,\infty) stays in the difference.

Thus

A−B=(−∞,−3)  ∪  [5,∞).A-B = (-\infty,-3)\;\cup\;[5,\infty).

But Option A omits the point 5,5, writing (5,∞)(5,\infty) instead of [5,∞).[5,\infty). Hence Option A is not true.

Option B: A∩B={−3}A\cap B=\{-3\}

The intersection of (−∞,−3](-\infty,-3] with [−3,5)[-3,5) gives just the single point −3,-3, and [5,∞)[5,\infty) has empty overlap with [−3,5).[-3,5). Hence Option B is true.

Option C: B−A=(−3,5)B-A=(-3,5)

Inside BB the point −3-3 is removed because −3∈A,-3\in A, and 55 is not in BB at all, so what remains is the open interval (−3,5).(-3,5). Thus Option C is true.

Option D: A∪B=RA\cup B=\mathbb{R}

The union (−∞,−3]∪[−3,5)∪[5,∞)(-\infty,-3]\cup[-3,5)\cup[5,\infty) clearly covers every real number, so Option D is also true.

We see that the only statement that fails is Option A.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Sets, subsets, power sets and set operations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicSets, subsets, power sets and set operations
TypeMultiple choice