We start with the set N={1,2,3,…} of natural numbers and the relation
R={(x,y)∈N×N:x3−3x2y−xy2+3y3=0}.
First we rewrite the condition in a more workable form. For any ordered pair (x,y)∈N×N with y=0 (which is always true in N) let us put x=ty, i.e. let t=yx. Substituting x=ty into the polynomial we get
x3−3x2y−xy2+3y3=(ty)3−3(ty)2y−(ty)y2+3y3.$
Simplifying each term gives
(ty)3=t3y3,3(ty)2y=3t2y3,(ty)y2=ty3.$
Hence
x3−3x2y−xy2+3y3=t3y3−3t2y3−ty3+3y3=y3(t3−3t2−t+3).$
The factor y3 is never zero in N, so the whole expression is zero exactly when
t3−3t2−t+3=0.$
Now we factor this cubic. We test the obvious integer divisor t=1:
13−3(1)2−1+3=1−3−1+3=0,$
so t−1 is a factor. Performing polynomial division (or synthetic division) we get
t3−3t2−t+3=(t−1)(t2−2t−3).$
Next we factor the quadratic t2−2t−3:
t2−2t−3=(t−3)(t+1).$
Therefore
t3−3t2−t+3=(t−1)(t−3)(t+1)=0.$
For t∈Q (and especially for t∈N) the roots are t=1,t=3,t=−1. Since t=yx is positive in N, the admissible values are
t=1ort=3.$
That is,
yx=1⟹x=y,yx=3⟹x=3y.$
Hence the defining equation vanishes precisely for the two patterns
R={(x,y)∈N×N:x=y or x=3y}.$
With this explicit description we can check the three properties one by one.
Reflexive: For every a∈N we have a=a, so (a,a)∈R by the first alternative x=y. Thus R is reflexive.
Symmetric: Assume (x,y)∈R. Two sub-cases arise.
• If x=y, then (y,x)=(x,x) is again in R, so symmetry is fine in this sub-case.
• If x=3y, then y=3x. For (y,x) to belong to R we would need either y=x (impossible because x=3y=y) or y=3x (impossible because it would give x=0). Therefore (y,x)∈/R whenever x=3y with y≥1. A concrete instance is (3,1)∈R while (1,3)∈/R.
So the relation is not symmetric.
Transitive: We need to see whether (x,y)∈R and (y,z)∈R always force (x,z)∈R. Take the pairs
(x,y)=(9,3),(y,z)=(3,1).$
The first belongs to R because 9=3⋅3, the second because 3=3⋅1. However, (x,z)=(9,1) satisfies neither 9=1 nor 9=3⋅1, so (9,1)∈/R. Hence R fails transitivity.
Collecting the results, R is reflexive but neither symmetric nor transitive.
Hence, the correct answer is Option 2.