Let be the real line. Consider the following subsets of the plane : . Which one of the following is true?
An equivalence relation on must be reflexive, symmetric and transitive. We test these three properties for both and .
Case 1:
• Reflexive test: a relation is reflexive if .
For an ordered pair to belong to we need , which is impossible.
Therefore for every real , so is not reflexive.
Since reflexivity already fails, cannot be an equivalence relation (no need to test symmetry and transitivity further).
Case 2:
• Reflexive: For every , and is an integer. Hence for all ; so is reflexive.
• Symmetric: Suppose . Then is an integer. Its negative is also an integer, so . Hence is symmetric.
• Transitive: Suppose and . Then and for some integers . Adding, , an integer. Thus , so is transitive.
Since satisfies all three properties, it is an equivalence relation on .
Combining the two cases: is not an equivalence relation, while is. Hence the correct statement is:
Option D which is: is an equivalence relation on but is not.
Tagged Equivalence relations and equivalence classes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.