RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2023 · 01 FEB S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2023 Mathematics question — Reflexive, symmetric and transitive relations

Let RR be a relation on R\mathbb{R}, given by R={a,b:3a−3b+7R = \{a, b : 3a - 3b + \sqrt{7} is an irrational number}\}. Then RR is

SOLUTION

Let R={(a,b):3a−3b+7R = \{(a, b) : 3a - 3b + \sqrt{7} is an irrational number}\}. We need to determine the properties of RR.

To begin,

For (a,a)(a, a): 3a−3a+7=73a - 3a + \sqrt{7} = \sqrt{7}, which is irrational. So (a,a)∈R(a, a) \in R for all a∈Ra \in \mathbb{R}. RR is reflexive.

Next,

If (a,b)∈R(a, b) \in R, then 3a−3b+73a - 3b + \sqrt{7} is irrational. For (b,a)(b, a): 3b−3a+7=−(3a−3b)+73b - 3a + \sqrt{7} = -(3a - 3b) + \sqrt{7}.

Take a=0,b=73a = 0, b = \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{3}: 3(0)−3⋅73+7=−7+7=03(0) - 3\cdot\dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{3} + \sqrt{7} = -\sqrt{7} + \sqrt{7} = 0, which is rational. So (0,73)∉R(0, \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{3}) \notin R.

Take a=73,b=0a = \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{3}, b = 0: 3⋅73−0+7=7+7=273\cdot\dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{3} - 0 + \sqrt{7} = \sqrt{7} + \sqrt{7} = 2\sqrt{7}, which is irrational. So (73,0)∈R(\dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{3}, 0) \in R.

But (0,73)∉R(0, \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{3}) \notin R. So RR is not symmetric.

From this,

Let a=73,b=0,c=−73a = \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{3}, b = 0, c = \dfrac{-\sqrt{7}}{3}.

(a,b)(a, b): 3⋅73−0+7=273 \cdot \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{3} - 0 + \sqrt{7} = 2\sqrt{7} (irrational) ✓\checkmark

(b,c)(b, c): 0−3⋅−73+7=7+7=270 - 3\cdot\dfrac{-\sqrt{7}}{3} + \sqrt{7} = \sqrt{7} + \sqrt{7} = 2\sqrt{7} (irrational) ✓\checkmark

(a,c)(a, c): 3⋅73−3⋅−73+7=7+7+7=373\cdot\dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{3} - 3\cdot\dfrac{-\sqrt{7}}{3} + \sqrt{7} = \sqrt{7} + \sqrt{7} + \sqrt{7} = 3\sqrt{7} (irrational) ✓\checkmark

This particular case works, but let's try another: a=273,b=73,c=0a = \dfrac{2\sqrt{7}}{3}, b = \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{3}, c = 0.

(a,b)(a, b): 27−7+7=272\sqrt{7} - \sqrt{7} + \sqrt{7} = 2\sqrt{7} (irrational) ✓\checkmark

(b,c)(b, c): 7−0+7=27\sqrt{7} - 0 + \sqrt{7} = 2\sqrt{7} (irrational) ✓\checkmark

(a,c)(a, c): 27−0+7=372\sqrt{7} - 0 + \sqrt{7} = 3\sqrt{7} (irrational) ✓\checkmark

Let me find a counterexample. Take b=76b = \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{6}, a=0a = 0, c=73c = \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{3}:

(a,b)(a,b): 0−72+7=720 - \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{2} + \sqrt{7} = \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{2} (irrational) ✓\checkmark

(b,c)(b,c): 72−7+7=72\dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{2} - \sqrt{7} + \sqrt{7} = \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{2} (irrational) ✓\checkmark

(a,c)(a,c): 0−7+7=00 - \sqrt{7} + \sqrt{7} = 0 (rational) ×\times

So RR is not transitive.

The correct answer is Option A: Reflexive but neither symmetric nor transitive.

Tagged Reflexive, symmetric and transitive relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicReflexive, symmetric and transitive relations
TypeMultiple choice