RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Geometric progression and infinite GP

If aa, bb and cc be three distinct real numbers in G.P. and a+b+c=xba + b + c = xb, then xx cannot be:

SOLUTION

Let the three distinct real numbers aa, bb and cc be in geometric progression. For a G.P. we write every term in terms of the middle term and the common ratio. So, if the common ratio is r  (  r≠0  ),r\;(\;r\neq0\;), we have

a=br,b=b,c=br.a=\frac{b}{r},\qquad b=b,\qquad c=br.

The question gives the relation a+b+c=xba+b+c=xb. Substituting the expressions for aa and cc we obtain

br+b+br=xb.\frac{b}{r}+b+br = xb.

Since b≠0b\neq0 (otherwise the three numbers would all be zero and not distinct), we divide every term by bb:

1r+1+r=x.\frac{1}{r}+1+r = x.

So,

x=r+1r+1.x=r+\frac{1}{r}+1.

Now we must find the set of all real values taken by the expression r+1rr+\dfrac{1}{r} for r∈R,  r≠0r\in\mathbb{R},\;r\neq0.

Using the well-known inequality for real numbers, r+1r≥2r+\frac{1}{r}\ge 2 when r>0r>0 and r+1r≤−2r+\frac{1}{r}\le -2 when r<0r<0. (Proof: multiply by rr and bring all terms to one side to get the square of a real number.)

Hence,

r+1r∈(−∞,−2]  ∪  [2,∞).r+\frac{1}{r}\in(-\infty,-2] \;\cup\; [2,\infty).

Adding 11 throughout (because we have x=r+1r+1x=r+\dfrac{1}{r}+1) shifts the entire set by 11:

x∈(−∞,−1]  ∪  [3,∞).x\in(-\infty,-1] \;\cup\; [3,\infty).

Thus every real value of xx is possible except those lying strictly between −1-1 and 33.

The four given options are −3,  2,  4,  −2-3,\;2,\;4,\;-2. Among these, −3-3 is ≤−1-1, 44 is ≥33 and −2-2 is ≤−1-1, so all three can occur. However, 22 lies between −1-1 and 33, which is outside the attainable range of xx.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Geometric progression and infinite GP. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicGeometric progression and infinite GP
TypeMultiple choice