RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 APR S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Sums of natural numbers, squares and cubes

Some identical balls are arranged in rows to form an equilateral triangle. The first row consists of one ball, the second row consists of two balls and so on. If 99 more identical balls are added to the total number of balls used in forming the equilateral triangle, then all these balls can be arranged in a square, whose each side contains exactly 2 balls less than the number of balls each side of the triangle contains. Then the number of balls used to form the equilateral triangle is:

SOLUTION

We have balls first arranged in the shape of an equilateral triangle whose side has nn balls. In such an arrangement the rows contain 1,2,3,…,n1,2,3,\ldots ,n balls respectively. The total number of balls in an equilateral triangular arrangement of side nn is known to be the nthn^{\text{th}} triangular number. The formula for the sum of the first nn natural numbers is

Tn=n(n+1)2.T_n=\frac{n(n+1)}{2}.

So, the number of balls actually used in making the triangle is

(balls in triangle)=n(n+1)2.\text{(balls in triangle)}=\frac{n(n+1)}{2}.

According to the problem, if we now add exactly 9999 more identical balls to this collection, the enlarged collection can be perfectly rearranged into a square. Further, each side of this square has exactly 22 balls fewer than each side of the original triangle. Since each side of the triangle already contains nn balls, each side of the square must therefore contain n−2n-2 balls.

The number of balls needed to build such a square is the square of the number of balls along one side. Hence

(balls in square)=(n−2)2.\text{(balls in square)}=(n-2)^2.

The balls in the square come from all the balls of the triangle plus the additional 9999 balls. Therefore we can write the equality

n(n+1)2+99=(n−2)2.\frac{n(n+1)}{2}+99=(n-2)^2.

Now we solve this equation step by step. First multiply every term by 22 to clear the denominator:

n(n+1)+198=2(n−2)2.n(n+1)+198=2(n-2)^2.

Expand both sides. On the left:

n(n+1)=n2+n,n(n+1)=n^2+n,

so the left-hand side becomes n2+n+198.n^2+n+198. On the right, start with the binomial square:

(n−2)2=n2−4n+4,(n-2)^2=n^2-4n+4,

then double it:

2(n−2)2=2(n2−4n+4)=2n2−8n+8.2(n-2)^2=2(n^2-4n+4)=2n^2-8n+8.

Hence the equality is now

n2+n+198=2n2−8n+8.n^2+n+198=2n^2-8n+8.

Bring every term to one side to obtain zero on the other side. Subtract the entire left-hand side from both sides:

0=2n2−8n+8−(n2+n+198).0=2n^2-8n+8-(n^2+n+198).

Carry out the subtractions term by term:

0=2n2−n2−8n−n+8−198,0=2n^2-n^2-8n-n+8-198,

which simplifies to

0=n2−9n−190.0=n^2-9n-190.

So we must solve the quadratic equation

n2−9n−190=0.n^2-9n-190=0.

The quadratic formula for ax2+bx+c=0ax^2+bx+c=0 is x=−b±b2−4ac2a.x=\dfrac{-b\pm\sqrt{b^2-4ac}}{2a}. Here a=1,  b=−9,  c=−190a=1,\;b=-9,\;c=-190. First compute the discriminant:

Δ=b2−4ac=(−9)2−4(1)(−190)=81+760=841.\Delta=b^2-4ac=(-9)^2-4(1)(-190)=81+760=841.

Since 841=29,\sqrt{841}=29, we now have

n=−(−9)±292(1)=9±292.n=\frac{-(-9)\pm29}{2(1)}=\frac{9\pm29}{2}.

This gives two possible values:

n=9+292=19orn=9−292=−10.n=\frac{9+29}{2}=19\qquad\text{or}\qquad n=\frac{9-29}{2}=-10.

Because nn counts balls along a side, it must be positive, so we discard n=−10n=-10 and keep

n=19.n=19.

Now substitute back to find the actual number of balls in the original triangular arrangement:

Balls in triangle=T19=19(19+1)2=19⋅202=190.\text{Balls in triangle}=T_{19}=\frac{19(19+1)}{2}=\frac{19\cdot20}{2}=190.

So, the triangle was made of 190190 balls.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Sums of natural numbers, squares and cubes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicSums of natural numbers, squares and cubes
TypeMultiple choice