JEE Main 2018 Mathematics question — Geometric progression and infinite GP
If a, b, c are in A.P. and a2,b2,c2 are in G.P. such that a<b<c and a+b+c=43, then the value of a is:
SOLUTION
We are told that the real numbers a,b,c satisfy two simultaneous conditions.
First, they lie in an arithmetic progression, so by the very definition of an A.P. we have
b=2a+c.−(1)
Secondly, the squares a2,b2,c2 form a geometric progression.
For any three positive terms x,y,z to be in G.P. the middle term must be the geometric mean of the other two, that is
y2=xz.
Applying this property to a2,b2,c2 gives
(b2)2=a2c2⟹b4=a2c2.−(2)
We are also given the sum
a+b+c=43.−(3)
Because a<b<c we are certain that the common difference of the A.P. is positive. Let us employ equations (1), (2) and (3) one by one.
From (1) we may express c solely in terms of a and b:
c=2b−a.−(4)
Substituting (4) into the G.P. condition (2) yields
b4=a2(2b−a)2=a2(4b2−4ab+a2).
Re-arranging every term to the left we obtain the quartic relation
b4−4a2b2+4a3b−a4=0.−(5)
The sum (3) can now be simplified with the help of (4):
a+b+c=a+b+(2b−a)=3b=43⟹b=41.−(6)
Because b is known, equation (5) now becomes a pure equation in a.
Substituting b=41 we get
(41)4−4a2(41)2+4a3(41)−a4=0.
Evaluating the numerical powers of 41 step by step:
2561−4a2+a3−a4=0.
Multiplying every term by 256 clears the denominator:
1−64a2+256a3−256a4=0.
Multiplying by −1 (for convenience) gives the cleaner quartic
256a4−256a3+64a2−1=0.−(7)
At this stage a very helpful observation is to scale the variable.
Put x=4a (that is a=4x).
Replacing a with 4x in (7) and simplifying power by power:
The first three terms on the left-hand side can be recognised as the perfect square (x2−2x)2, because
(x2−2x)2=x4−4x3+4x2.
Using this fact, equation (8) factorises beautifully:
(x2−2x)2−1=0⟹(x2−2x)2=1.
Taking square roots we get two quadratic possibilities:
x2−2x=1orx2−2x=−1.
Solving each quadratic separately:
(i) For x2−2x=1:
x2−2x−1=0⟹x=22±4+4=1±2.
(ii) For x2−2x=−1:
x2−2x+1=0⟹(x−1)2=0⟹x=1 (a double root).
Collecting all values of x:
x=1,1+2,1−2.
Remembering that a=4x we translate each x back to a:
a1=41,a2=41+2,a3=41−2.
We must respect the original ordering a<b<c with b=41 already fixed.
Hence a must be strictly less than 41, ruling out a1 which equals b and a2 which is even larger.
The only admissible value is therefore
a=41−2=41−221.
This matches Option D.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Geometric progression and infinite GP. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.