RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 15 APR S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Mathematics question — Sums of natural numbers, squares and cubes

Let An=(34)−(34)2+(34)3−…+(−1)n−1(34)nA_n = \left(\frac{3}{4}\right) - \left(\frac{3}{4}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{3}{4}\right)^3 - \ldots + (-1)^{n-1}\left(\frac{3}{4}\right)^n and Bn=1−AnB_n = 1 - A_n. Then, the least odd natural number p, so that Bn>AnB_n > A_n, for all n≥pn \geq p is:

SOLUTION

We have the finite alternating geometric sum

An=(34)−(34)2+(34)3−…+(−1) n−1(34)n.A_n=\left(\frac34\right)-\left(\frac34\right)^2+\left(\frac34\right)^3-\ldots+(-1)^{\,n-1}\left(\frac34\right)^n.

The first term is a=34a=\dfrac34 and the common ratio is r=−34.r=-\dfrac34.

For any geometric progression the sum of the first nn terms is given by the well-known formula

Sn=a (1−r n)1−r.S_n=\dfrac{a\,(1-r^{\,n})}{1-r}.

Substituting a=34a=\dfrac34 and r=−34r=-\dfrac34, we get

An=34(1−(−34) n)1−(−34)=34(1−(−34) n)1+34=34(1−(−34) n)74=34⋅47(1−(−34) n).A_n=\dfrac{\dfrac34\bigl(1-(-\dfrac34)^{\,n}\bigr)}{1-(-\dfrac34)} =\dfrac{\dfrac34\bigl(1-(-\dfrac34)^{\,n}\bigr)}{1+\dfrac34} =\dfrac{\dfrac34\bigl(1-(-\dfrac34)^{\,n}\bigr)}{\dfrac74} =\dfrac34\cdot\dfrac47\bigl(1-(-\tfrac34)^{\,n}\bigr).

Simplifying the product 34⋅47\dfrac34\cdot\dfrac47 we obtain

An=37(1−(−34) n).A_n=\dfrac37\bigl(1-(-\tfrac34)^{\,n}\bigr).

Now, by definition,

Bn=1−An=1−37(1−(−34) n)=1−37+37(−34) n=47+37(−34) n.B_n=1-A_n =1-\dfrac37\bigl(1-(-\tfrac34)^{\,n}\bigr) =1-\dfrac37+\dfrac37(-\tfrac34)^{\,n} =\dfrac47+\dfrac37\bigl(-\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n}.

We want Bn>An.B_n>A_n. Substituting the above expressions gives

47+37(−34) n  >  37(1−(−34) n).\dfrac47+\dfrac37\bigl(-\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n}\;>\;\dfrac37\bigl(1-(-\tfrac34)^{\,n}\bigr).

Multiplying every term by 7 to clear denominators,

4+3(−34) n  >  3[1−(−34) n].4+3\bigl(-\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n}\;>\;3\Bigl[1-(-\tfrac34)^{\,n}\Bigr].

Expanding the right-hand side,

4+3(−34) n  >  3−3(−34) n.4+3\bigl(-\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n}\;>\;3-3\bigl(-\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n}.

Bringing every term to the left,

4+3(−34) n−3+3(−34) n  >  0,4+3\bigl(-\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n}-3+3\bigl(-\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n}\;>\;0,

which simplifies to

1+6(−34) n  >  0.1+6\bigl(-\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n}\;>\;0.

So the inequality Bn>AnB_n>A_n is equivalent to

1+6(−34) n>0.1+6(-\tfrac34)^{\,n}>0.

Notice that (−34) n(-\tfrac34)^{\,n} alternates its sign:

  • If nn is even, (−34) n=(34) n>0(-\tfrac34)^{\,n}=(\tfrac34)^{\,n}>0, hence 1+6(positive)>01+6(\text{positive})>0 is always true.
  • If nn is odd, (−34) n=−(34) n(-\tfrac34)^{\,n}=-(\tfrac34)^{\,n}, and the condition becomes
    1−6(34) n>0⟹(34) n<16.1-6\bigl(\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n}>0 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \bigl(\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n}<\dfrac16.

Because (34) n\bigl(\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n} decreases as nn increases, once it falls below 16\dfrac16 it will stay below that value for all larger nn. We therefore search for the smallest odd natural number nn satisfying

(34) n<16.\bigl(\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n}<\dfrac16.

Checking odd values one by one:

For n=1n=1, (34)1=34=0.75>0.1667\bigl(\tfrac34\bigr)^1=\tfrac34=0.75>0.1667 (fails).

For n=3n=3, (34)3=2764≈0.4219>0.1667\bigl(\tfrac34\bigr)^3=\dfrac{27}{64}\approx0.4219>0.1667 (fails).

For n=5n=5, (34)5=2431024≈0.2373>0.1667\bigl(\tfrac34\bigr)^5=\dfrac{243}{1024}\approx0.2373>0.1667 (fails).

For n=7n=7, (34)7=218716384≈0.1335<0.1667\bigl(\tfrac34\bigr)^7=\dfrac{2187}{16384}\approx0.1335<0.1667 (success).

Thus n=7n=7 is the first (least) odd natural number for which (34) n<16\bigl(\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n}<\dfrac16 and consequently Bn>AnB_n>A_n. For every odd n≥7n\ge7, the power (34) n\bigl(\tfrac34\bigr)^{\,n} is even smaller, so the inequality continues to hold, and we already observed it always holds for even nn.

Therefore the least odd natural number pp such that Bn>AnB_n>A_n for all n≥pn\ge p is

p=7.p=7.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Sums of natural numbers, squares and cubes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicSums of natural numbers, squares and cubes
TypeMultiple choice