RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Mathematics question — AM, GM, HM and the AM-GM inequality

If A>0A > 0, B>0B > 0 and A+B=π6A + B = \frac{\pi}{6}, then the minimum positive value of (tan⁡A+tan⁡B)(\tan A + \tan B) is:

SOLUTION

We have A>0,  B>0A > 0,\; B > 0 and the fixed sum A+B=π6  .A + B = \dfrac{\pi}{6}\;. Our task is to find the minimum positive value of tan⁡A+tan⁡B\tan A + \tan B under this condition.

We begin with the standard trigonometric identity

tan⁡X+tan⁡Y  =  sin⁡Xcos⁡X+sin⁡Ycos⁡Y=sin⁡Xcos⁡Y+sin⁡Ycos⁡Xcos⁡Xcos⁡Y=sin⁡ (X+Y)cos⁡Xcos⁡Y  .\tan X + \tan Y \;=\; \dfrac{\sin X}{\cos X} + \dfrac{\sin Y}{\cos Y} = \dfrac{\sin X \cos Y + \sin Y \cos X}{\cos X \cos Y} = \dfrac{\sin\,(X + Y)}{\cos X \cos Y}\;.

Applying this formula to the angles AA and B,B, we obtain

tan⁡A+tan⁡B=sin⁡ (A+B)cos⁡Acos⁡B  .\tan A + \tan B = \dfrac{\sin\,(A + B)}{\cos A \cos B}\;.

The numerator is easy to simplify because A+B=π6,A + B = \dfrac{\pi}{6}, so

sin⁡ (A+B)  =  sin⁡ ⁣(π6)=12  .\sin\,(A + B) \;=\; \sin\!\left(\dfrac{\pi}{6}\right) = \dfrac12\;.

Thus

tan⁡A+tan⁡B=12cos⁡Acos⁡B=12 cos⁡Acos⁡B  .\tan A + \tan B = \dfrac{\dfrac12}{\cos A \cos B} = \dfrac{1}{2\,\cos A \cos B}\;.

Since the factor 12\dfrac12 in the numerator is a constant, minimizing tan⁡A+tan⁡B\tan A + \tan B is equivalent to maximizing the product cos⁡Acos⁡B.\cos A \cos B.

Because B=π6−A,B = \dfrac{\pi}{6} - A, we can view the product solely as a function of AA:

f(A)  =  cos⁡A  cos⁡ ⁣(π6−A),f(A) \;=\; \cos A \;\cos\!\Bigl(\dfrac{\pi}{6} - A\Bigr),, (0<A<π6).(0 < A < \dfrac{\pi}{6}).

To locate the maximum of f(A)f(A) we differentiate and set the derivative to zero. First compute the derivative:

f′(A)=−sin⁡A  cos⁡ ⁣(π6−A)  +  cos⁡A  sin⁡ ⁣(π6−A)  .\begin{aligned} f'(A) &= -\sin A \;\cos\!\Bigl(\dfrac{\pi}{6} - A\Bigr) \;+\; \cos A \;\sin\!\Bigl(\dfrac{\pi}{6} - A\Bigr)\;. \end{aligned}

Setting f′(A)=0f'(A)=0 gives

cos⁡A  sin⁡ ⁣(π6−A)=sin⁡A  cos⁡ ⁣(π6−A).\cos A \;\sin\!\Bigl(\dfrac{\pi}{6} - A\Bigr) = \sin A \;\cos\!\Bigl(\dfrac{\pi}{6} - A\Bigr).

Dividing both sides by cos⁡A  cos⁡ ⁣(π6−A)\cos A\;\cos\!\bigl(\dfrac{\pi}{6} - A\bigr) (which is positive in the interval) yields

tan⁡ ⁣(π6−A)  =  tan⁡A  .\tan\!\Bigl(\dfrac{\pi}{6} - A\Bigr) \;=\; \tan A\;.

The equality of the tangents forces their arguments to be equal (modulo π\pi, but only the principal value lies inside our interval), so

π6−A  =  A\dfrac{\pi}{6} - A \;=\; A ⟹\Longrightarrow 2A  =  π62A \;=\; \dfrac{\pi}{6} ⟹\Longrightarrow A  =  B  =  π12  .A \;=\; B \;=\; \dfrac{\pi}{12}\;.

Thus the product cos⁡Acos⁡B\cos A \cos B attains its maximum when both angles are equal to π12.\dfrac{\pi}{12}. Let us now evaluate that product explicitly:

cos⁡Acos⁡B=cos⁡2 ⁣(π12).\cos A \cos B = \cos^2\!\Bigl(\dfrac{\pi}{12}\Bigr).

Recall the exact value of cos⁡π12\cos\dfrac{\pi}{12} (which is cos⁡15∘\cos15^\circ):

cos⁡π12=cos⁡15∘=6+24=2+32  .\cos\dfrac{\pi}{12} = \cos 15^\circ = \dfrac{\sqrt6 + \sqrt2}{4} = \dfrac{\sqrt{2 + \sqrt3}}{2}\;.

Either form may be used; squaring the simpler radical form gives

cos⁡2 ⁣(π12)=(2+32)2= 2+3 4  .\cos^2\!\Bigl(\dfrac{\pi}{12}\Bigr) = \left(\dfrac{\sqrt{2 + \sqrt3}}{2}\right)^2 = \dfrac{\,2 + \sqrt3\,}{4}\;.

Now substitute this maximum product into the earlier expression for tan⁡A+tan⁡B\tan A + \tan B:

tan⁡A+tan⁡B∣min⁡=12 cos⁡Acos⁡B=12  2+3 4=1 2+3 2=2 2+3  .\tan A + \tan B\Bigl|_{\min} = \dfrac{1}{2 \,\cos A \cos B} = \dfrac{1}{2 \,\dfrac{\,2 + \sqrt3\,}{4}} = \dfrac{1}{\dfrac{\,2 + \sqrt3\,}{2}} = \dfrac{2}{\,2 + \sqrt3}\;.

Finally, rationalise the denominator:

2 2+3  ⋅   2−3  2−3 =2(2−3)(2+3)(2−3)= 4−23  4−3 =4−23  .\dfrac{2}{\,2 + \sqrt3}\; \cdot\; \dfrac{\,2 - \sqrt3\,}{\,2 - \sqrt3\,} = \dfrac{2(2 - \sqrt3)}{(2 + \sqrt3)(2 - \sqrt3)} = \dfrac{\,4 - 2\sqrt3\,}{\,4 - 3\,} = 4 - 2\sqrt3\;.

Therefore the minimum positive value of (tan⁡A+tan⁡B)(\tan A + \tan B) is 4−23,4 - 2\sqrt3, which matches Option B.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged AM, GM, HM and the AM-GM inequality. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicAM, GM, HM and the AM-GM inequality
TypeMultiple choice