RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 16 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Mathematics question — Heights and distances

A man on the top of a vertical tower observes a car moving at a uniform speed towards the tower on a horizontal road. If it takes 18 min for the angle of depression of the car to change from 30∘^\circ to 45∘^\circ, then the time taken (in min) by the car to reach the foot of the tower is:

SOLUTION

Let us assume that the tower is perfectly vertical and its height is hh metres. The car is moving on a horizontal road which we shall regard as level ground. From the top of the tower a man looks down at the car; therefore the angle of depression seen by the man is numerically equal to the angle of elevation that the car would see if it looked up at the top of the tower (alternate angles made by a transversal with two parallel horizontal lines).

At an initial instant the angle of depression is 30∘30^\circ. Let the horizontal distance of the car from the foot of the tower at that moment be x1x_1 metres. By simple right-triangle trigonometry in the vertical plane that contains the tower and the car we have the tangent relation:

tan⁡30∘  =  opposite sideadjacent side  =  hx1.\tan 30^\circ \;=\;\frac{\text{opposite side}}{\text{adjacent side}}\;=\;\frac{h}{x_1}.

The numerical value of tan⁡30∘\tan 30^\circ is 13\frac{1}{\sqrt3}, so

13  =  hx1.\frac{1}{\sqrt3} \;=\;\frac{h}{x_1}.

Cross-multiplying gives

x1  =  3 h.x_1 \;=\;\sqrt3\,h.

After the car has moved nearer, the angle of depression becomes 45∘45^\circ. Let the new horizontal distance be x2x_2 metres. Using the same tangent formula, now with 45∘45^\circ, we write

tan⁡45∘  =  hx2.\tan 45^\circ \;=\;\frac{h}{x_2}.

Since tan⁡45∘=1\tan 45^\circ = 1, we have immediately

1  =  hx2⟹x2  =  h.1 \;=\;\frac{h}{x_2}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad x_2 \;=\;h.

Thus the car travels the horizontal distance

x1−x2  =  3 h−h  =  h(3−1)x_1 - x_2 \;=\;\sqrt3\,h - h \;=\;h(\sqrt3 - 1)

while the angle of depression changes from 30∘30^\circ to 45∘45^\circ. According to the statement of the problem this travel takes 1818 minutes. If the uniform speed of the car be vv metres per minute, then

v  =  distancetime  =  h(3−1)18.v \;=\;\frac{\text{distance}}{\text{time}}\;=\;\frac{h(\sqrt3 - 1)}{18}.

After this instant the car still has to cover the remaining horizontal distance x2x_2 (which equals hh) to reach the foot of the tower. The time tt required for that final leg is found from

t  =  distance still to gosame uniform speed  =  hv.t \;=\;\frac{\text{distance still to go}}{\text{same uniform speed}} \;=\;\frac{h}{v}.

Substituting the expression for vv just obtained, we get

t  =  hh(3−1)18.t \;=\;\frac{h}{\dfrac{h(\sqrt3 - 1)}{18}}.

We may cancel the common factor hh in numerator and denominator, giving

t  =  18 13−1.t \;=\;18\,\frac{1}{\sqrt3 - 1}.

To rationalise the denominator we multiply the numerator and the denominator by the conjugate (3+1):(\sqrt3 + 1):

t  =  18 3+1(3−1)(3+1).t \;=\;18\,\frac{\sqrt3 + 1}{(\sqrt3 - 1)(\sqrt3 + 1)}.

The product in the denominator is a difference of squares:

(3−1)(3+1)  =  (3)2−12  =  3−1  =  2.(\sqrt3 - 1)(\sqrt3 + 1) \;=\;(\sqrt3)^2 - 1^2 \;=\;3 - 1 \;=\;2.

Therefore

t  =  18 3+12  =  9(3+1).t \;=\;18\,\frac{\sqrt3 + 1}{2} \;=\;9(\sqrt3 + 1).

Since all quantities were in minutes, the required time for the car to reach the foot of the tower is 9(1+3)9(1 + \sqrt3) minutes.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Heights and distances. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicHeights and distances
TypeMultiple choice