RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2012TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2012 Mathematics question — Addition theorem and algebra of events

Let XX and YY are two events such that P(X∪Y)=P(X∩Y)P(X \cup Y) = P(X \cap Y). Statement 1: P(X∩Y′)=P(X′∩Y)=0P(X \cap Y') = P(X' \cap Y) = 0 Statement 2: P(X)+P(Y)=2P(X∩Y)P(X) + P(Y) = 2 P(X \cap Y)

SOLUTION

For any two events XX and YY in the same sample space, the addition theorem of probability says

P(X∪Y)=P(X)+P(Y)−P(X∩Y)−(1)P(X \cup Y)=P(X)+P(Y)-P(X \cap Y) \qquad -(1)

The question states that P(X∪Y)=P(X∩Y)P(X \cup Y)=P(X \cap Y). Substituting this into −(1)-(1) gives

P(X∩Y)=P(X)+P(Y)−P(X∩Y)P(X \cap Y)=P(X)+P(Y)-P(X \cap Y)
⟹\Longrightarrow P(X)+P(Y)=2 P(X∩Y)−(2)P(X)+P(Y)=2\,P(X \cap Y) \qquad -(2)

Equation −(2)-(2) is exactly Statement 2, so Statement 2 is true.

Next, compare the sets X∪YX \cup Y and X∩YX \cap Y. Since X∩Y⊆X∪YX \cap Y \subseteq X \cup Y, we always have P(X∩Y)≤P(X∪Y)P(X \cap Y)\le P(X \cup Y). The given equality tells us that no probability lies in the parts of XX and YY that are outside their intersection.

The parts outside the intersection are
  • X∩Y′X \cap Y' (elements in XX but not in YY) and
  • X′∩YX' \cap Y (elements in YY but not in XX).

Hence

P(X∩Y′)=0,P(X′∩Y)=0−(3)P(X \cap Y')=0, \qquad P(X' \cap Y)=0 \qquad -(3)

which is exactly Statement 1, so Statement 1 is also true.

Does Statement 2 explain Statement 1? Statement 2 is a consequence of the given equality via the addition theorem, whereas Statement 1 is obtained by comparing the regions of a Venn diagram (or by writing P(X∪Y)=P(X∩Y)+P(X∩Y′)+P(X′∩Y)P(X\cup Y)=P(X\cap Y)+P(X\cap Y')+P(X'\cap Y) and using the equality). Thus Statement 2 does not logically lead to Statement 1; both are independent consequences of the same given condition.

Therefore, the correct choice is:
Option B - Statement 1 is true, Statement 2 is true, but Statement 2 is not a correct explanation of Statement 1.

Tagged Addition theorem and algebra of events. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicAddition theorem and algebra of events
TypeMultiple choice