RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2010TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2010 Mathematics question — Probability using permutations and combinations

Four numbers are chosen at random (without replacement) from the set {1,2,3,…,20}\{1, 2, 3, \ldots, 20\}. Statement-1: The probability that the chosen numbers when arranged in some order will form an AP is 185\frac{1}{85}. Statement-2: If the four chosen numbers form an AP, then the set of all possible values of common difference is {±1,±2,±3,±4,±5}\{\pm 1, \pm 2, \pm 3, \pm 4, \pm 5\}.

SOLUTION

To test Statement-1 we must count how many unordered sets of four distinct numbers from {1,2,…,20}\{1,2,\dots ,20\} can be arranged to form an arithmetic progression (AP).

Write a four-term AP with first term xx and positive common difference dd as
x,  x+d,  x+2d,  x+3dx,\;x+d,\;x+2d,\;x+3d

Because every term must lie in {1,…,20}\{1,\dots ,20\} we need
1≤xandx+3d≤20  .1\le x \quad\text{and}\quad x+3d\le 20\;. Hence x≤20−3dx\le 20-3d, so for a fixed dd the admissible first term has the range
x=1,2,…,20−3d  .x=1,2,\dots ,20-3d\;. The number of APs corresponding to one positive dd is therefore 20−3d20-3d (provided the right side is positive).

Case 1: Counting for each positive dd

d=1:;;20−3(1)=17⟹  17 APsd=2:;;20−3(2)=14⟹  14 APsd=3:;;20−3(3)=11⟹  11 APsd=4:;;20−3(4)=8⟹  8 APsd=5:;;20−3(5)=5⟹  5 APsd=6:;;20−3(6)=2⟹  2 APsd≥7:;;20−3d≤0⟹  0 APs\begin{aligned} d=1&:;;20-3(1)=17\quad &\Longrightarrow&\;17\text{ APs}\\ d=2&:;;20-3(2)=14 &\Longrightarrow&\;14\text{ APs}\\ d=3&:;;20-3(3)=11 &\Longrightarrow&\;11\text{ APs}\\ d=4&:;;20-3(4)=8 &\Longrightarrow&\;8\text{ APs}\\ d=5&:;;20-3(5)=5 &\Longrightarrow&\;5\text{ APs}\\ d=6&:;;20-3(6)=2 &\Longrightarrow&\;2\text{ APs}\\ d\ge 7&:;;20-3d\le 0 &\Longrightarrow&\;0\text{ APs} \end{aligned}

The total number of distinct four-term APs is
17+14+11+8+5+2=57  .17+14+11+8+5+2=57\;. (Using negative dd would only reverse the same sets, so no new AP appears.)

Case 2: Computing the probability

The total number of unordered selections of four numbers from 20 is
(204)=4845  .\binom{20}{4}=4845\;.

Therefore the required probability is
574845=185  .\frac{57}{4845}=\frac{1}{85}\;.

Statement-1 is thus correct.

Case 3: Valid values of the common difference

From the list above, the possible positive differences are 1,2,3,4,5,61,2,3,4,5,6, so the complete set of allowable differences is
{±1,±2,±3,±4,±5,±6}  .\{\pm 1,\pm 2,\pm 3,\pm 4,\pm 5,\pm 6\}\;. Statement-2 claims the set {±1,±2,±3,±4,±5}\{\pm 1,\pm 2,\pm 3,\pm 4,\pm 5\}, omitting ±6\pm 6. Counter-examples such as {1,7,13,19}\{1,7,13,19\} (difference 66) and {2,8,14,20}\{2,8,14,20\} (difference 66) show that ∣d∣=6\lvert d\rvert=6 is indeed possible. Hence Statement-2 is false.

Statement-1 is true and Statement-2 is false.

Option B which is: Statement-1 is true, Statement-2 is false

Tagged Probability using permutations and combinations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicProbability using permutations and combinations
TypeMultiple choice