Let us solve the given problem step by step. We have two events, A and E, both with positive probabilities. We need to evaluate two statements.
First, recall the definition of conditional probability. The conditional probability of E given A is defined as:
P(E∣A)=P(A)P(A∩E)
provided that P(A)>0. Similarly, the conditional probability of A given E is:
P(A∣E)=P(E)P(A∩E)
provided that P(E)>0. Since both events have positive probabilities, these definitions are valid.
Now, let us analyze Statement I: P(E∣A)≥P(A∣E)P(E).
Substitute the expressions for the conditional probabilities:
Left side: P(E∣A)=P(A)P(A∩E)
Right side: P(A∣E)P(E)=(P(E)P(A∩E))×P(E)=P(A∩E)
So, Statement I becomes:
P(A)P(A∩E)≥P(A∩E)
Let x=P(A∩E) and a=P(A). Since probabilities are non-negative, x≥0, and given that P(A)>0, a>0. Also, since P(A)≤1, a≤1. The inequality is:
ax≥x
We can rearrange this as:
ax−x≥0
x(a1−1)≥0
Since a≤1, a1≥1, so a1−1≥0. Also, x≥0. Therefore, the product x(a1−1) is non-negative. This holds for all values of x and a:
- If x=0, both sides are 0, so 0≥0 is true.
- If x>0, since a1−1≥0, the inequality holds.
Thus, Statement I is always true.
Now, consider Statement II: P(A∣E)≥P(A∩E).
Substitute the expression for P(A∣E):
P(A∣E)=P(E)P(A∩E)
So, Statement II becomes:
P(E)P(A∩E)≥P(A∩E)
Let x=P(A∩E) and e=P(E). Since P(E)>0, e>0, and P(E)≤1, so e≤1. The inequality is:
ex≥x
Rearrange this as:
ex−x≥0
x(e1−1)≥0
Since e≤1, e1≥1, so e1−1≥0. Also, x≥0. Therefore, the product x(e1−1) is non-negative. This holds for all values of x and e:
- If x=0, both sides are 0, so 0≥0 is true.
- If x>0, since e1−1≥0, the inequality holds.
Thus, Statement II is also always true.
Since both statements are true, the correct option is B.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.