RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2014 · 19 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2014 Mathematics question — Conditional probability and multiplication theorem

Let A and E be any two events with positive probabilities.
Statement I: P(E/A)≥P(A/E)P(E)P(E/A) \geq P(A/E)P(E).
Statement II: P(A/E)≥P(A∩E)P(A/E) \geq P(A \cap E).

SOLUTION

Let us solve the given problem step by step. We have two events, A and E, both with positive probabilities. We need to evaluate two statements.

First, recall the definition of conditional probability. The conditional probability of E given A is defined as:

P(E∣A)=P(A∩E)P(A)P(E|A) = \frac{P(A \cap E)}{P(A)}

provided that P(A)>0P(A) > 0. Similarly, the conditional probability of A given E is:

P(A∣E)=P(A∩E)P(E)P(A|E) = \frac{P(A \cap E)}{P(E)}

provided that P(E)>0P(E) > 0. Since both events have positive probabilities, these definitions are valid.

Now, let us analyze Statement I: P(E∣A)≥P(A∣E)P(E)P(E|A) \geq P(A|E)P(E).

Substitute the expressions for the conditional probabilities:

Left side: P(E∣A)=P(A∩E)P(A)P(E|A) = \frac{P(A \cap E)}{P(A)}

Right side: P(A∣E)P(E)=(P(A∩E)P(E))×P(E)=P(A∩E)P(A|E)P(E) = \left( \frac{P(A \cap E)}{P(E)} \right) \times P(E) = P(A \cap E)

So, Statement I becomes:

P(A∩E)P(A)≥P(A∩E)\frac{P(A \cap E)}{P(A)} \geq P(A \cap E)

Let x=P(A∩E)x = P(A \cap E) and a=P(A)a = P(A). Since probabilities are non-negative, x≥0x \geq 0, and given that P(A)>0P(A) > 0, a>0a > 0. Also, since P(A)≤1P(A) \leq 1, a≤1a \leq 1. The inequality is:

xa≥x\frac{x}{a} \geq x

We can rearrange this as:

xa−x≥0\frac{x}{a} - x \geq 0

x(1a−1)≥0x \left( \frac{1}{a} - 1 \right) \geq 0

Since a≤1a \leq 1, 1a≥1\frac{1}{a} \geq 1, so 1a−1≥0\frac{1}{a} - 1 \geq 0. Also, x≥0x \geq 0. Therefore, the product x(1a−1)x \left( \frac{1}{a} - 1 \right) is non-negative. This holds for all values of xx and aa:

  • If x=0x = 0, both sides are 0, so 0≥00 \geq 0 is true.
  • If x>0x > 0, since 1a−1≥0\frac{1}{a} - 1 \geq 0, the inequality holds.

Thus, Statement I is always true.

Now, consider Statement II: P(A∣E)≥P(A∩E)P(A|E) \geq P(A \cap E).

Substitute the expression for P(A∣E)P(A|E):

P(A∣E)=P(A∩E)P(E)P(A|E) = \frac{P(A \cap E)}{P(E)}

So, Statement II becomes:

P(A∩E)P(E)≥P(A∩E)\frac{P(A \cap E)}{P(E)} \geq P(A \cap E)

Let x=P(A∩E)x = P(A \cap E) and e=P(E)e = P(E). Since P(E)>0P(E) > 0, e>0e > 0, and P(E)≤1P(E) \leq 1, so e≤1e \leq 1. The inequality is:

xe≥x\frac{x}{e} \geq x

Rearrange this as:

xe−x≥0\frac{x}{e} - x \geq 0

x(1e−1)≥0x \left( \frac{1}{e} - 1 \right) \geq 0

Since e≤1e \leq 1, 1e≥1\frac{1}{e} \geq 1, so 1e−1≥0\frac{1}{e} - 1 \geq 0. Also, x≥0x \geq 0. Therefore, the product x(1e−1)x \left( \frac{1}{e} - 1 \right) is non-negative. This holds for all values of xx and ee:

  • If x=0x = 0, both sides are 0, so 0≥00 \geq 0 is true.
  • If x>0x > 0, since 1e−1≥0\frac{1}{e} - 1 \geq 0, the inequality holds.

Thus, Statement II is also always true.

Since both statements are true, the correct option is B.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Conditional probability and multiplication theorem. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicConditional probability and multiplication theorem
TypeMultiple choice