JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Combinations and selections with conditions
If nC4, nC5 and nC6 are in A.P., then n can be
SOLUTION
We have been told that the three binomial coefficients nC4,nC5,nC6 form an arithmetic progression. In an arithmetic progression the middle term is the average of its neighbours, so the defining condition is
2nC5=nC4+nC6.
First recall the factorial form of a binomial coefficient:
nCr=r!(n−r)!n!.
There is also a very convenient ratio formula derived straight from the factorial definition:
nCr+1=r+1n−rnCr.
This will allow us to rewrite every term in the above equation in terms of the single quantity nC5.
To express nC4 in terms of nC5 we set r=4 in the ratio formula and obtain
nC5=5n−4nC4⟹nC4=nC5n−45.
Next, to express nC6 in terms of nC5 we set r=5 in the same ratio formula and get
nC6=6n−5nC5.
Now substitute these two expressions into the arithmetic-progression condition:
2nC5=nC5n−45+nC56n−5.
Because nC5 is a common, non-zero factor, we may divide both sides by it:
2=n−45+6n−5.
To clear the denominators multiply every term by 6(n−4):
2×6(n−4)=5×6+(n−5)(n−4).
Simplifying the left-hand side:
12(n−4).
Simplifying the right-hand side step by step gives
30+(n−5)(n−4).
Expanding the product (n−5)(n−4):
n2−4n−5n+20=n2−9n+20.
So the equation becomes
12(n−4)=30+n2−9n+20.
Combine the constants on the right:
12(n−4)=n2−9n+50.
Expand the left-hand side:
12n−48=n2−9n+50.
Now bring every term to the right to obtain a standard quadratic equation:
0=n2−9n+50−12n+48,
which simplifies to
n2−21n+98=0.
We solve this quadratic by the discriminant method.
The discriminant is
Δ=(−21)2−4×1×98=441−392=49.
Since Δ=7, the roots are
n=221±7.
This gives the two numerical values
n1=221+7=228=14,n2=221−7=214=7.
Both numbers are indeed > 6, so both satisfy the algebraic condition. However, among the options offered (9, 14, 12, 11) only 14 appears. Consequently the permissible value of n from the given list is 14.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Combinations and selections with conditions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.