RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 04 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Mathematics question — Implicit and parametric differentiation

If (a+2bcos⁡x)(a−2bcos⁡y)=a2−b2\left(a + \sqrt{2b}\cos x\right)\left(a - \sqrt{2b}\cos y\right) = a^2 - b^2, where a>b>0a > b > 0, then dxdy\frac{dx}{dy} at (π4,π4)\left(\frac{\pi}{4}, \frac{\pi}{4}\right) is:

SOLUTION

We start from the implicit relation

(a+2bcos⁡x)(a−2bcos⁡y)=a2−b2,a>b>0.\left(a+\sqrt{2b}\cos x\right)\left(a-\sqrt{2b}\cos y\right)=a^{2}-b^{2},\qquad a>b>0.

Here both xx and yy are variables linked through the above equation, so we regard xx as a function of yy and differentiate with respect to yy.

The right-hand side is a constant, so its derivative is 00. For the left-hand side we first state the product rule:

ddy[UV]=UdVdy+VdUdy,\dfrac{d}{dy}[UV]=U\dfrac{dV}{dy}+V\dfrac{dU}{dy},

where U=a+2bcos⁡xU=a+\sqrt{2b}\cos x and V=a−2bcos⁡yV=a-\sqrt{2b}\cos y. Applying the rule, we obtain

(a−2bcos⁡y)ddy ⁣(a+2bcos⁡x)  +  (a+2bcos⁡x)ddy ⁣(a−2bcos⁡y)=0.\bigl(a-\sqrt{2b}\cos y\bigr)\dfrac{d}{dy}\!\bigl(a+\sqrt{2b}\cos x\bigr) \;+\;\bigl(a+\sqrt{2b}\cos x\bigr)\dfrac{d}{dy}\!\bigl(a-\sqrt{2b}\cos y\bigr)=0.

Now we differentiate each factor. Remember that aa and bb are constants, while xx depends on yy:

ddy ⁣(a+2bcos⁡x)=2b (−sin⁡x)dxdy,\dfrac{d}{dy}\!\bigl(a+\sqrt{2b}\cos x\bigr)=\sqrt{2b}\,(-\sin x)\dfrac{dx}{dy},

because ddycos⁡x=−sin⁡xdxdy.\dfrac{d}{dy}\cos x=-\sin x\dfrac{dx}{dy}.

ddy ⁣(a−2bcos⁡y)=−2b (−sin⁡y)=2bsin⁡y,\dfrac{d}{dy}\!\bigl(a-\sqrt{2b}\cos y\bigr)=-\sqrt{2b}\,(-\sin y)=\sqrt{2b}\sin y, because here yy is the differentiation variable itself.

Substituting these derivatives back gives

(a−2bcos⁡y) 2b(−sin⁡x)dxdy  +  (a+2bcos⁡x) 2bsin⁡y=0.\bigl(a-\sqrt{2b}\cos y\bigr)\,\sqrt{2b}(-\sin x)\dfrac{dx}{dy} \;+\;\bigl(a+\sqrt{2b}\cos x\bigr)\,\sqrt{2b}\sin y=0.

Each term contains a common factor 2b\sqrt{2b}; dividing by it simplifies the equation:

−(a−2bcos⁡y)sin⁡x dxdy  +  (a+2bcos⁡x)sin⁡y=0.-\bigl(a-\sqrt{2b}\cos y\bigr)\sin x\,\dfrac{dx}{dy} \;+\;\bigl(a+\sqrt{2b}\cos x\bigr)\sin y=0.

Rearranging, we isolate dxdy\dfrac{dx}{dy}:

dxdy=(a+2bcos⁡x)sin⁡y(a−2bcos⁡y)sin⁡x.\dfrac{dx}{dy}=\dfrac{\bigl(a+\sqrt{2b}\cos x\bigr)\sin y} {\bigl(a-\sqrt{2b}\cos y\bigr)\sin x}.

We must now evaluate this derivative at the point (x,y)=(π4,π4).\bigl(x,y\bigr)=\left(\dfrac{\pi}{4},\dfrac{\pi}{4}\right). First record the basic trigonometric values

cos⁡π4=22,sin⁡π4=22.\cos\dfrac{\pi}{4}=\dfrac{\sqrt2}{2},\qquad \sin\dfrac{\pi}{4}=\dfrac{\sqrt2}{2}.

Compute the auxiliary quantity

2bcos⁡π4=2b 22=b.\sqrt{2b}\cos\dfrac{\pi}{4}=\sqrt{2b}\,\dfrac{\sqrt2}{2}=\sqrt{b}.

Hence at x=y=π4x=y=\dfrac{\pi}{4} we have

a+2bcos⁡x=a+b,a−2bcos⁡y=a−b,a+\sqrt{2b}\cos x=a+\sqrt{b},\qquad a-\sqrt{2b}\cos y=a-\sqrt{b},

and also

sin⁡x=sin⁡y=22.\sin x=\sin y=\dfrac{\sqrt2}{2}.

Substituting all these values into the derivative formula gives

dxdy∣(π4,π4)=(a+b)(22)(a−b)(22)=a+ba−b.\left.\dfrac{dx}{dy}\right|_{\left(\frac{\pi}{4},\frac{\pi}{4}\right)} =\dfrac{(a+\sqrt{b})\left(\dfrac{\sqrt2}{2}\right)} {(a-\sqrt{b})\left(\dfrac{\sqrt2}{2}\right)} =\dfrac{a+\sqrt{b}}{a-\sqrt{b}}.

At first glance the answer still contains b\sqrt{b}, yet none of the options do. We therefore use the original relation to find an extra link between aa and bb at this specific point. Putting x=y=π4x=y=\dfrac{\pi}{4} into the given equation itself, we get

(a+b)(a−b)=a2−b2.\bigl(a+\sqrt{b}\bigr)\bigl(a-\sqrt{b}\bigr)=a^{2}-b^{2}.

The left side expands to a2−b,a^{2}-b, so

a2−b=a2−b2⟹b=b2  ⟹  b(1−b)=0.a^{2}-b=a^{2}-b^{2}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad b=b^{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; b(1-b)=0.

Because b>0b>0, the only admissible root is b=1.b=1. With this value, the derivative simplifies to

dxdy=a+1a−1=a+ba−b,\dfrac{dx}{dy}=\dfrac{a+1}{a-1} =\dfrac{a+b}{a-b},

since now b=1.b=1.

This matches option C. Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Implicit and parametric differentiation. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicImplicit and parametric differentiation
TypeMultiple choice