We have the square matrix
A = [ e t e − t cos t e − t sin t e t − e − t cos t − e − t sin t − e − t sin t + e − t cos t e t 2 e − t sin t − 2 e − t cos t ] . A=\begin{bmatrix}
e^{t} & e^{-t}\cos t & e^{-t}\sin t\\[4pt]
e^{t} & -e^{-t}\cos t-e^{-t}\sin t & -e^{-t}\sin t+e^{-t}\cos t\\[4pt]
e^{t} & 2e^{-t}\sin t & -2e^{-t}\cos t
\end{bmatrix}. A = e t e t e t e − t cos t − e − t cos t − e − t sin t 2 e − t sin t e − t sin t − e − t sin t + e − t cos t − 2 e − t cos t .
A matrix is invertible exactly when its determinant is non-zero. Hence we compute det ( A ) . \det(A). det ( A ) .
First, in every column we take out the common exponential factor:
Column 1 has a common factor e t , e^{t}, e t ,
Column 2 has a common factor e − t , e^{-t}, e − t ,
Column 3 has a common factor e − t . e^{-t}. e − t .
The rule “pulling a scalar k k k out of a column multiplies the determinant by k k k ” gives
det ( A ) = e t e − t e − t det [ 1 cos t sin t 1 − cos t − sin t − sin t + cos t 1 2 sin t − 2 cos t ] . \det(A)=e^{t}\,e^{-t}\,e^{-t}\;\det\!\begin{bmatrix}
1 & \cos t & \sin t\\[4pt]
1 & -\cos t-\sin t & -\sin t+\cos t\\[4pt]
1 & 2\sin t & -2\cos t
\end{bmatrix}. det ( A ) = e t e − t e − t det 1 1 1 cos t − cos t − sin t 2 sin t sin t − sin t + cos t − 2 cos t .
Simplifying the scalar product, e t e − t e − t = e − t , e^{t}e^{-t}e^{-t}=e^{-t}, e t e − t e − t = e − t , so
det ( A ) = e − t det ( B ) , \det(A)=e^{-t}\,\det(B), det ( A ) = e − t det ( B ) ,
where
B = [ 1 cos t sin t 1 − cos t − sin t − sin t + cos t 1 2 sin t − 2 cos t ] . B=\begin{bmatrix}
1 & \cos t & \sin t\\[4pt]
1 & -\cos t-\sin t & -\sin t+\cos t\\[4pt]
1 & 2\sin t & -2\cos t
\end{bmatrix}. B = 1 1 1 cos t − cos t − sin t 2 sin t sin t − sin t + cos t − 2 cos t .
Because e − t ≠ 0 e^{-t}\neq 0 e − t = 0 for every real t , t, t , the sign of det ( A ) \det(A) det ( A ) is the same as that of det ( B ) . \det(B). det ( B ) . Now we find det ( B ) . \det(B). det ( B ) .
Subtracting the first row from the second and third (a row operation that does not change the determinant) gives
det ( B ) = det [ 1 cos t sin t 0 ( − cos t − sin t ) − cos t ( − sin t + cos t ) − sin t 0 2 sin t − cos t − 2 cos t − sin t ] . \det(B)=\det\!\begin{bmatrix}
1 & \cos t & \sin t\\[4pt]
0 & (-\cos t-\sin t)-\cos t & (-\sin t+\cos t)-\sin t\\[4pt]
0 & 2\sin t-\cos t & -2\cos t-\sin t
\end{bmatrix}. det ( B ) = det 1 0 0 cos t ( − cos t − sin t ) − cos t 2 sin t − cos t sin t ( − sin t + cos t ) − sin t − 2 cos t − sin t .
Thus
B = [ 1 cos t sin t 0 − 2 cos t − sin t cos t − 2 sin t 0 2 sin t − cos t − 2 cos t − sin t ] . B=\begin{bmatrix}
1 & \cos t & \sin t\\[4pt]
0 & -2\cos t-\sin t & \cos t-2\sin t\\[4pt]
0 & 2\sin t-\cos t & -2\cos t-\sin t
\end{bmatrix}. B = 1 0 0 cos t − 2 cos t − sin t 2 sin t − cos t sin t cos t − 2 sin t − 2 cos t − sin t .
Expanding the determinant down the first column (using the formula “minor times cofactor,” and noting that the sign is + + + because the element is in position (1,1)):
det ( B ) = 1 ⋅ det [ − 2 cos t − sin t cos t − 2 sin t 2 sin t − cos t − 2 cos t − sin t ] . \det(B)=1\cdot
\det\!\begin{bmatrix}
-2\cos t-\sin t & \cos t-2\sin t\\[4pt]
2\sin t-\cos t & -2\cos t-\sin t
\end{bmatrix}. det ( B ) = 1 ⋅ det [ − 2 cos t − sin t 2 sin t − cos t cos t − 2 sin t − 2 cos t − sin t ] .
For the 2 × 2 determinant we use det [ p q r s ] = p s − q r : \det\!\begin{bmatrix}p&q\\r&s\end{bmatrix}=ps-qr: det [ p r q s ] = p s − q r :
det ( B ) = ( − 2 cos t − sin t ) ( − 2 cos t − sin t ) − ( cos t − 2 sin t ) ( 2 sin t − cos t ) . \det(B)=(-2\cos t-\sin t)(-2\cos t-\sin t)\,-
(\cos t-2\sin t)(2\sin t-\cos t). det ( B ) = ( − 2 cos t − sin t ) ( − 2 cos t − sin t ) − ( cos t − 2 sin t ) ( 2 sin t − cos t ) .
Introduce the abbreviations
a = − 2 cos t − sin t , b = cos t − 2 sin t . a=-2\cos t-\sin t,\qquad
b=\cos t-2\sin t. a = − 2 cos t − sin t , b = cos t − 2 sin t .
Notice that 2 sin t − cos t = − b . 2\sin t-\cos t=-b. 2 sin t − cos t = − b . Therefore
det ( B ) = a 2 − b ( − b ) = a 2 + b 2 . \det(B)=a^{2}-b(-b)=a^{2}+b^{2}. det ( B ) = a 2 − b ( − b ) = a 2 + b 2 .
The expression a 2 + b 2 a^{2}+b^{2} a 2 + b 2 is a sum of two squares, which is never negative, and it equals zero only if both a = 0 a=0 a = 0 and b=0.$</p>
<p>Setting a=0g i v e s gives g i v es -2\cos t-\sin t=0\;\Longrightarrow\;\tan t=-2.S e t t i n g Setting S e tt in g b=0g i v e s gives g i v es \cos t-2\sin t=0\;\Longrightarrow\;\tan t=\dfrac12.< / p > < p > B e c a u s e </p>
<p>Because < / p >< p > B ec a u se \tan tc a n n o t b e s i m u l t a n e o u s l y cannot be simultaneously c ann o t b es im u l t an eo u s l y -2a n d and an d \dfrac12,t h e p a i r o f e q u a t i o n s h a s < e m > n o < / e m > c o m m o n s o l u t i o n . H e n c e the pair of equations has <em>no</em> common solution. Hence t h e p ai r o f e q u a t i o n s ha s < e m > n o < / e m > co mm o n so l u t i o n . H e n ce a^{2}+b^{2}>0f o r a l l r e a l for all real f or a l l r e a l t,s o < / p > < p > so</p>
<p> so < / p >< p >
\det(B)\;>\;0\quad\text{for every real }t.
< / p > < p > F i n a l l y , s i n c e </p>
<p>Finally, since < / p >< p > F ina l l y , s in ce \det(A)=e^{-t}\det(B)a n d n e i t h e r f a c t o r i s e v e r z e r o , w e h a v e < / p > < p > and neither factor is ever zero, we have</p>
<p> an d n e i t h er f a c t or i se v er z er o , w e ha v e < / p >< p >
\det(A)\neq 0\quad\text{for every real }t.
< / p > < p > T h u s t h e m a t r i x </p>
<p>Thus the matrix < / p >< p > T h u s t h e ma t r i x Ai s i n v e r t i b l e f o r < e m > a l l < / e m > r e a l v a l u e s o f is invertible for <em>all</em> real values of i s in v er t ib l e f or < e m > a l l < / e m > r e a l v a l u eso f t.$$
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.