RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 08 APR S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Evaluation of determinants

Let the numbers 2, b, c be in an A.P. and A=(1112bc4b2c2)A = \begin{pmatrix} 1 & 1 & 1 \\ 2 & b & c \\ 4 & b^{2} & c^{2} \end{pmatrix}. If det⁡(A)∈[2,16]\det(A) \in [2, 16], then cc lies in the interval:

SOLUTION

We are told that the three real numbers 2, bb and cc are in an arithmetic progression. For any three numbers a1,a2,a3a_1 , a_2 , a_3 to be in an A.P. we must have the common difference equal, that is

a2−a1=a3−a2.a_2-a_1 = a_3-a_2.

Here a1=2,  a2=b,  a3=ca_1 = 2,\; a_2 = b,\; a_3 = c, so we write

b−2=c−b.b-2 = c-b.

Transposing and simplifying,

2b=2+c    ⇒    c=2b−22b = 2 + c \;\;\Rightarrow\;\; c = 2b-2 or b=2+c2.b = \dfrac{2+c}{2}.

Next we analyse the determinant of the given matrix A=(1112bc4b2c2).A=\begin{pmatrix}1 & 1 & 1 \\ 2 & b & c \\ 4 & b^{2} & c^{2}\end{pmatrix}. For a 3×33\times3 matrix (x11x12x13x21x22x23x31x32x33),\begin{pmatrix}x_{11}&x_{12}&x_{13}\\x_{21}&x_{22}&x_{23}\\x_{31}&x_{32}&x_{33}\end{pmatrix}, the determinant is obtained from the expansion along the first row:

det⁡=x11∣x22x23x32x33∣  −  x12∣x21x23x31x33∣  +  x13∣x21x22x31x32∣.\det = x_{11}\begin{vmatrix}x_{22}&x_{23}\\x_{32}&x_{33}\end{vmatrix}\; -\;x_{12}\begin{vmatrix}x_{21}&x_{23}\\x_{31}&x_{33}\end{vmatrix}\; +\;x_{13}\begin{vmatrix}x_{21}&x_{22}\\x_{31}&x_{32}\end{vmatrix}.

Applying this to our matrix we have

det⁡(A)=1∣bcb2c2∣−1∣2c4c2∣+1∣2b4b2∣.\det(A)= 1\begin{vmatrix}b & c\\ b^{2} & c^{2}\end{vmatrix} -1\begin{vmatrix}2 & c\\ 4 & c^{2}\end{vmatrix} +1\begin{vmatrix}2 & b\\ 4 & b^{2}\end{vmatrix}.

Evaluating each 2×22\times2 determinant,

det⁡(A)=1 (b c2−c b2)  −  1 (2 c2−4c)  +  1 (2 b2−4b)=bc2−cb2  −  2c2+4c  +  2b2−4b.\begin{aligned} \det(A) &= 1\,(b\,c^{2}-c\,b^{2}) \;-\; 1\,(2\,c^{2}-4c)\;+\;1\,(2\,b^{2}-4b)\\[4pt] &= bc^{2}-cb^{2}\;-\;2c^{2}+4c\;+\;2b^{2}-4b. \end{aligned}

Because bb and cc are linked through the A.P. relation b=2+c2,b=\dfrac{2+c}{2}, we now substitute this value everywhere it occurs.

First find some helpful expressions: c−b=c−2+c2=c−22,c-b = c-\dfrac{2+c}{2}= \dfrac{c-2}{2}, bc=c⋅2+c2=c(2+c)2,bc = c\cdot\dfrac{2+c}{2}= \dfrac{c(2+c)}{2}, and therefore bc(c−b)=c(2+c)2⋅c−22=c(c+2)(c−2)4=c(c2−4)4=c3−4c4.bc(c-b)=\dfrac{c(2+c)}{2}\cdot\dfrac{c-2}{2}= \dfrac{c(c+2)(c-2)}{4}= \dfrac{c(c^{2}-4)}{4}=\dfrac{c^{3}-4c}{4}.

Re-writing each term of det⁡(A)\det(A) with the substitutions,

det⁡(A)=c3−4c4  −  2c2+4c  +  2 ⁣(2+c2)2−4 ⁣(2+c2)=c3−4c4  −  2c2+4c  +  (c+2)22−2(2+c).\begin{aligned} \det(A) &= \dfrac{c^{3}-4c}{4}\;-\;2c^{2}+4c\;+\;2\!\left(\dfrac{2+c}{2}\right)^{2}-4\!\left(\dfrac{2+c}{2}\right)\\[6pt] &= \dfrac{c^{3}-4c}{4}\;-\;2c^{2}+4c\;+\;\dfrac{(c+2)^{2}}{2}-2(2+c). \end{aligned}

Expand and combine like terms step by step:

c3−4c4=14c3−c,\dfrac{c^{3}-4c}{4}= \dfrac{1}{4}c^{3}-c, (c+2)22=c2+4c+42=12c2+2c+2,\dfrac{(c+2)^{2}}{2}= \dfrac{c^{2}+4c+4}{2}= \dfrac{1}{2}c^{2}+2c+2, −2(2+c)=−4−2c.-2(2+c)= -4-2c.

Adding everything:

det⁡(A)=(14c3−c)+(−2c2)+4c+(12c2+2c+2)+(−4−2c)=14c3  +  (−2c2+12c2)  +  (−c+4c+2c−2c)  +  (2−4)=14c3−32c2+3c−2.\begin{aligned} \det(A) &= \Bigl(\dfrac{1}{4}c^{3}-c\Bigr) + (-2c^{2}) + 4c + \Bigl(\dfrac{1}{2}c^{2}+2c+2\Bigr) + (-4-2c)\\[4pt] &= \dfrac{1}{4}c^{3} \;+\; \Bigl(-2c^{2}+\dfrac{1}{2}c^{2}\Bigr)\;+\;\bigl(-c+4c+2c-2c\bigr)\;+\;(2-4)\\[4pt] &= \dfrac{1}{4}c^{3}-\dfrac{3}{2}c^{2}+3c-2. \end{aligned}

To clear the fractional coefficients, multiply the entire expression by 4:

4det⁡(A)=c3−6c2+12c−8.4\det(A)=c^{3}-6c^{2}+12c-8.

Notice that the right-hand side is a perfect cube expansion, namely

c3−6c2+12c−8  =  (c−2)3.c^{3}-6c^{2}+12c-8 \;=\; (c-2)^{3}.

Hence we may write the determinant in the compact form

det⁡(A)=(c−2)34.\det(A)=\dfrac{(c-2)^{3}}{4}.

The problem statement now supplies the bound

2 ≤ det⁡(A) ≤ 16.2 \,\le\,\det(A)\,\le\,16.

Substituting the expression just found,

2  ≤  (c−2)34  ≤  16.2 \;\le\; \dfrac{(c-2)^{3}}{4}\;\le\;16.

Multiply every part of the inequality by 4 (which is positive, so the inequality direction does not change):

8  ≤  (c−2)3  ≤  64.8 \;\le\; (c-2)^{3} \;\le\; 64.

The cube function is strictly increasing for all real numbers, so we can safely take the real cube roots term by term:

83  ≤  c−2  ≤  643.\sqrt[3]{8}\; \le\; c-2 \;\le\; \sqrt[3]{64}.

Since 83=2\sqrt[3]{8}=2 and 643=4,\sqrt[3]{64}=4, this becomes

2≤c−2≤4.2 \le c-2 \le 4.

Finally add 2 throughout:

4≤c≤6.4 \le c \le 6.

Thus cc must lie in the closed interval [4,6][4,6].

Comparing with the given options, we see that this corresponds exactly to Option B.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Evaluation of determinants. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicEvaluation of determinants
TypeMultiple choice