RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 08 APR S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Systems of linear equations

The greatest value of c∈Rc \in R for which the system of linear equations x−cy−cz=0x - cy - cz = 0, cx−y+cz=0cx - y + cz = 0, cx+cy−z=0cx + cy - z = 0 has a non-trivial solution, is:

SOLUTION

We are given the homogeneous linear system

x−cy−cz=0,cx−y+cz=0,cx+cy−z=0.\begin{aligned} x - cy - cz &= 0,\\ cx - y + cz &= 0,\\ cx + cy - z &= 0. \end{aligned}

For a homogeneous system to possess a non-trivial (i.e., not all zero) solution, the determinant of its coefficient matrix must be zero. We first write the coefficient matrix:

A=[1−c−cc−1  cc  c−1].A=\begin{bmatrix} 1 & -c & -c\\ c & -1 & \;c\\ c & \;c & -1 \end{bmatrix}.

Now we compute its determinant ∣A∣.|A|. Using expansion along the first row (the pattern of signs is + − ++\, -\, +) we have

∣A∣=1  ∣−1cc−1∣−  (−c)  ∣ccc−1∣+  (−c)  ∣c−1cc∣.\begin{aligned} |A| &= 1\;\Bigl|\begin{matrix}-1 & c\\[2pt] c & -1\end{matrix}\Bigr| -\;(-c)\;\Bigl|\begin{matrix}c & c\\[2pt] c & -1\end{matrix}\Bigr| +\;(-c)\;\Bigl|\begin{matrix}c & -1\\[2pt] c & c\end{matrix}\Bigr|. \end{aligned}

We evaluate each 2 × 2 determinant step by step.

First minor:

∣−1cc−1∣=(−1)(−1)−c⋅c=1−c2.\Bigl|\begin{matrix}-1 & c\\ c & -1\end{matrix}\Bigr| =(-1)(-1)-c\cdot c =1-c^{2}.

Second minor:

∣ccc−1∣=c(−1)−c⋅c=−c−c2.\Bigl|\begin{matrix}c & c\\ c & -1\end{matrix}\Bigr| =c(-1)-c\cdot c =-c-c^{2}.

Third minor:

∣c−1cc∣=c⋅c−(−1) c=c2+c.\Bigl|\begin{matrix}c & -1\\ c & c\end{matrix}\Bigr| =c\cdot c-(-1)\,c =c^{2}+c.

Substituting these values in the expansion, we obtain

∣A∣=1 (1−c2)−  (−c) (−c−c2)+  (−c) (c2+c)=(1−c2)+  c(−c−c2)−  c(c2+c).\begin{aligned} |A| &= 1\,(1-c^{2}) -\;(-c)\,(-c-c^{2}) +\;(-c)\,(c^{2}+c)\\[4pt] &= (1-c^{2}) +\;c(-c-c^{2}) -\;c(c^{2}+c). \end{aligned}

Now we carry out each multiplication carefully:

c(−c−c2)=−c2−c3,−c(c2+c)=−c3−c2.\begin{aligned} c(-c-c^{2}) &= -c^{2}-c^{3},\\ -c(c^{2}+c) &= -c^{3}-c^{2}. \end{aligned}

Add all the terms:

∣A∣=1−c2−c2−c3−c3−c2=1−3c2−2c3.\begin{aligned} |A| &= 1-c^{2} - c^{2}-c^{3} - c^{3}-c^{2}\\[4pt] &= 1 - 3c^{2} - 2c^{3}. \end{aligned}

So we have

∣A∣=−2c3−3c2+1.|A| = -2c^{3} - 3c^{2} + 1.

For a non-trivial solution we set this determinant equal to zero:

−2c3−3c2+1=0.-2c^{3}-3c^{2}+1 = 0.

Multiplying throughout by −1-1 (which does not change the roots) makes the numbers slightly simpler:

2c3+3c2−1=0.2c^{3}+3c^{2}-1 = 0.

We now solve this cubic equation. The Rational Root Theorem tells us that any rational root must divide the constant term −1-1, so the only candidates are ±1,±12.\pm1, \pm\frac12. We test them one by one.

For c=1c=1:

2(1)3+3(1)2−1=2+3−1=4≠0.2(1)^{3}+3(1)^{2}-1 = 2+3-1 = 4 \neq 0.

For c=−1c=-1:

2(−1)3+3(−1)2−1=−2+3−1=0,2(-1)^{3}+3(-1)^{2}-1 = -2+3-1 = 0,

so c=−1c=-1 is indeed a root.

We now perform polynomial division by c+1c+1 to factor out this root. Dividing 2c3+3c2+0c−12c^{3}+3c^{2}+0c-1 by c+1c+1 (synthetic division) gives

2c3+3c2−1=(c+1)(2c2+c−1).2c^{3}+3c^{2}-1=(c+1)(2c^{2}+c-1).

Next we factor the quadratic 2c2+c−12c^{2}+c-1. Setting it equal to zero, we compute its discriminant:

Δ=b2−4ac=12−4(2)(−1)=1+8=9.\Delta = b^{2}-4ac = 1^{2}-4(2)(-1) = 1+8 = 9.

Hence the roots are

c=−1±92⋅2=−1±34.c=\frac{-1\pm\sqrt9}{2\cdot2} =\frac{-1\pm3}{4}.

This yields two more values:

c=−1+34=12,c=−1−34=−1.c=\frac{-1+3}{4}=\frac12,\qquad c=\frac{-1-3}{4}=-1.

So the complete factorisation is

2c3+3c2−1=(c+1)2 (2c−1).2c^{3}+3c^{2}-1=(c+1)^{2}\,(2c-1).

Therefore the determinant is zero for exactly three real values:

c=−1(double root),c=12.c=-1 \quad(\text{double root}),\qquad c=\frac12.

The question asks for the greatest real value of cc that produces a non-trivial solution. Among −1-1 and 12\dfrac12, the larger is 12\dfrac12.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Systems of linear equations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicSystems of linear equations
TypeMultiple choice