RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 08 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Mathematics question — Adjoint and inverse of a matrix

Let AA be any 3×33 \times 3 invertible matrix. Then which one of the following is not always true?

SOLUTION

For an invertible square matrix we always begin with the basic relation

A  adj(A)=adj(A)  A=∣A∣ I,A \; adj(A)=adj(A)\;A=|A|\,I,

where ∣A∣|A| is the determinant of AA and II is the identity matrix of the same order. This identity is true for every non-singular matrix and will be used repeatedly.

Taking determinant on both sides of A adj(A)=∣A∣ IA\,adj(A)=|A|\,I we have

∣A adj(A)∣=∣∣A∣ I∣.|A\,adj(A)|=||A|\,I|.

The left-hand side gives ∣A∣ ∣adj(A)∣|A|\,|adj(A)| while the right-hand side equals ∣A∣n|A|^{n} because the determinant of ∣A∣I|A|I (an n×nn\times n scalar matrix) is ∣A∣n|A|^{n}. Hence

∣A∣ ∣adj(A)∣=∣A∣n    ⟹    ∣adj(A)∣=∣A∣ n−1.|A|\,|adj(A)|=|A|^{n}\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;|adj(A)|=|A|^{\,n-1}.

In the present problem n=3n=3, so

∣adj(A)∣=∣A∣ 2.(1)|adj(A)|=|A|^{\,2}.\qquad(1)

Next, from A adj(A)=∣A∣ IA\,adj(A)=|A|\,I we isolate adj(A)adj(A):

adj(A)=∣A∣ A−1.(2)adj(A)=|A|\,A^{-1}.\qquad(2)

Because AA is invertible, the matrix adj(A)adj(A) is also invertible, and its inverse is obtained directly from (2):

(adj(A))−1=(∣A∣ A−1)−1=1∣A∣ A.(3)(adj(A))^{-1}=\bigl(|A|\,A^{-1}\bigr)^{-1}=\dfrac{1}{|A|}\,A.\qquad(3)

Now we wish to express adj(adj(A))adj(adj(A)). For any non-singular matrix BB we have the key identity

B adj(B)=∣B∣ I.B\,adj(B)=|B|\,I.

We apply it with B=adj(A)B=adj(A):

adj(A)  adj ⁣(adj(A))=∣adj(A)∣ I.(4)adj(A)\;adj\!\bigl(adj(A)\bigr)=|adj(A)|\,I.\qquad(4)

Using (1) to replace ∣adj(A)∣|adj(A)| inside (4) gives

adj(A)  adj ⁣(adj(A))=∣A∣2 I.(5)adj(A)\;adj\!\bigl(adj(A)\bigr)=|A|^{2}\,I.\qquad(5)

Now we substitute adj(A)=∣A∣ A−1adj(A)=|A|\,A^{-1} from (2) into (5):

∣A∣ A−1  adj ⁣(adj(A))=∣A∣2 I.|A|\,A^{-1}\;adj\!\bigl(adj(A)\bigr)=|A|^{2}\,I.

Dividing by ∣A∣|A| on both sides, we obtain

A−1  adj ⁣(adj(A))=∣A∣ I.A^{-1}\;adj\!\bigl(adj(A)\bigr)=|A|\,I.

Multiplying on the left by AA gives the desired explicit expression:

adj ⁣(adj(A))=∣A∣ A.(6)adj\!\bigl(adj(A)\bigr)=|A|\,A.\qquad(6)

Equation (6) is crucial for comparing with the four given statements.

Let us examine every option one by one.

Option A: The right-hand side is

∣A∣2 (adj(A))−1=∣A∣2(1∣A∣A)=∣A∣ A,|A|^{2}\,(adj(A))^{-1}=|A|^{2}\left(\dfrac{1}{|A|}A\right)=|A|\,A,

which is exactly the left-hand side adj(adj(A))adj(adj(A)) from (6). So Option A is always true.

Option B: The right-hand side is

∣A∣ (adj(A))−1=∣A∣(1∣A∣A)=A,|A|\,(adj(A))^{-1}=|A|\left(\dfrac{1}{|A|}A\right)=A,

whereas (6) tells us that adj(adj(A))=∣A∣ Aadj(adj(A))=|A|\,A. These two matrices are equal only in the special case ∣A∣=1|A|=1; in general they are different. Hence Option B is not always true.

Option C: This is exactly equation (6). Therefore it is always true.

Option D: This is formula (2), a standard identity valid for every invertible matrix. Hence it is always true.

Only Option B fails to hold for an arbitrary invertible 3×33\times3 matrix.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Adjoint and inverse of a matrix. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicAdjoint and inverse of a matrix
TypeMultiple choice