RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 05 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Mathematics question — Systems of linear equations

Let λ∈R\lambda \in \mathbb{R}. The system of linear equations
2x1−4x2+λx3=12x_1 - 4x_2 + \lambda x_3 = 1
x1−6x2+x3=2x_{1} - 6x_{2} + x_{3} = 2
λx1−10x2+4x3=3\lambda x_1 - 10x_2 + 4x_3 = 3
is inconsistent for:

SOLUTION

We have the three linear equations

2x1−4x2+λx3=1,x1−6x2+x3=2,λx1−10x2+4x3=3.\begin{aligned} 2x_1-4x_2+\lambda x_3 &= 1,\\[2pt] x_1-6x_2+x_3 &= 2,\\[2pt] \lambda x_1-10x_2+4x_3 &= 3. \end{aligned}$

The coefficient matrix is

A=[2−4λ1−61λ−104],and the augmented column is  b=[123].A=\begin{bmatrix} 2 & -4 & \lambda\\ 1 & -6 & 1\\ \lambda & -10 & 4 \end{bmatrix},\qquad \text{and the augmented column is }\, \mathbf b=\begin{bmatrix}1\\2\\3\end{bmatrix}.$

A system of linear equations is inconsistent exactly when rank⁡(A)<rank⁡([A  ∣  b]).\operatorname{rank}(A)\lt \operatorname{rank}\bigl([A\;|\;\mathbf b]\bigr).$ Whenever the determinant det⁡A≠0\det A\neq0 the rank of AA is 3, the augmented matrix also has rank 3, and the system is therefore consistent. Hence we first look for the values of λ\lambda that make det⁡A=0.\det A=0.

Using the first row expansion formula det⁡A=2 ⁣∣−61−104∣−(−4) ⁣∣11λ4∣+λ ⁣∣1−6λ−10∣,\det A =2\!\begin{vmatrix}-6&1\\-10&4\end{vmatrix} -(-4)\!\begin{vmatrix}1&1\\\lambda&4\end{vmatrix} +\lambda\!\begin{vmatrix}1&-6\\\lambda&-10\end{vmatrix},$ we compute each minor one by one:

∣−61−104∣=(−6)(4)−1(−10)=−24+10=−14,∣11λ4∣=(1)(4)−(1)(λ)=4−λ,∣1−6λ−10∣=(1)(−10)−(−6)(λ)=−10+6λ=6λ−10.\begin{aligned} \begin{vmatrix}-6&1\\-10&4\end{vmatrix} &=(-6)(4)-1(-10)=-24+10=-14,\\[6pt] \begin{vmatrix}1&1\\\lambda&4\end{vmatrix} &=(1)(4)-(1)(\lambda)=4-\lambda,\\[6pt] \begin{vmatrix}1&-6\\\lambda&-10\end{vmatrix} &=(1)(-10)-(-6)(\lambda)=-10+6\lambda=6\lambda-10. \end{aligned}$

Substituting these values gives

det⁡A=2(−14)+4(4−λ)+λ(6λ−10)=−28+16−4λ+6λ2−10λ=6λ2−14λ−12.\det A =2(-14)+4(4-\lambda)+\lambda(6\lambda-10) =-28+16-4\lambda+6\lambda^2-10\lambda =6\lambda^2-14\lambda-12.$

Taking out a common factor 2,

det⁡A=2(3λ2−7λ−6).\det A=2\bigl(3\lambda^2-7\lambda-6\bigr).

We now solve 3λ2−7λ−6=0.3\lambda^2-7\lambda-6=0. The discriminant is

Δ=(−7)2−4(3)(−6)=49+72=121=112,\Delta=(-7)^2-4(3)(-6)=49+72=121=11^2,$ so

λ=7±112⋅3=186  or  −46,\lambda=\frac{7\pm11}{2\cdot3}=\frac{18}{6}\;\text{or}\;\frac{-4}{6}, that is,

λ=3orλ=−23.\lambda=3\quad\text{or}\quad\lambda=-\dfrac23.

Thus det⁡A=0\det A=0 only for these two values. For every other real λ\lambda the system is consistent with a unique solution. We must now examine λ=3\lambda=3 and λ=−23\lambda=-\dfrac23 separately to see whether the system becomes inconsistent.

Case λ=3\lambda=3: Substituting λ=3\lambda=3 gives

2x1−4x2+3x3=1,x1−6x2+x3=2,3x1−10x2+4x3=3.\begin{aligned} 2x_1-4x_2+3x_3 &= 1,\\ x_1-6x_2+x_3 &= 2,\\ 3x_1-10x_2+4x_3 &= 3. \end{aligned}$

From the second equation we get x1=2+6x2−x3.x_1=2+6x_2-x_3. Putting this in the first equation:

2(2+6x2−x3)−4x2+3x3=1    ⟹    4+12x2−2x3−4x2+3x3=1,2(2+6x_2-x_3)-4x_2+3x_3=1 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;4+12x_2-2x_3-4x_2+3x_3=1,$

which simplifies to

8x2+x3=−3⟹x3=−3−8x2.8x_2+x_3=-3\quad\Longrightarrow\quad x_3=-3-8x_2. Inserting both expressions for x1x_1 and x3x_3 into the third equation:

3(2+6x2−x3)−10x2+4x3=3,3(2+6x_2-x_3)-10x_2+4x_3=3,

we get exactly 8x2+x3=−3,8x_2+x_3=-3, an identity that is already satisfied. Hence the third equation adds no new information, and there are infinitely many solutions. The system is consistent at λ=3\lambda=3.

Case λ=−23\lambda=-\dfrac23: Substituting λ=−23\lambda=-\dfrac23 gives

2x1−4x2−23x3=1,x1−6x2+x3=2,−23x1−10x2+4x3=3.\begin{aligned} 2x_1-4x_2-\dfrac23x_3 &= 1,\\ x_1-6x_2+x_3 &= 2,\\ -\dfrac23x_1-10x_2+4x_3 &= 3. \end{aligned}$

To clear fractions, multiply the first and third equations by 3:

6x1−12x2−2x3=3,x1−6x2+x3=2,−2x1−30x2+12x3=9.\begin{aligned} 6x_1-12x_2-2x_3 &= 3,\\ x_1-6x_2+x_3 &= 2,\\ -2x_1-30x_2+12x_3 &= 9. \end{aligned}$

From the middle equation we again have x1=2+6x2−x3.x_1=2+6x_2-x_3. Substituting into the first:

6(2+6x2−x3)−12x2−2x3=3    ⟹    12+36x2−6x3−12x2−2x3=3,6(2+6x_2-x_3)-12x_2-2x_3=3 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; 12+36x_2-6x_3-12x_2-2x_3=3,$

which reduces to

24x2−8x3=−9⟹−3x2+x3=98.24x_2-8x_3=-9 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad -3x_2+x_3=\frac{9}{8}.$ Next, substitute x1=2+6x2−x3x_1=2+6x_2-x_3 into the third equation:

−2(2+6x2−x3)−30x2+12x3=9,-2(2+6x_2-x_3)-30x_2+12x_3=9,

giving

−4−12x2+2x3−30x2+12x3=9    ⟹    −42x2+14x3=13    ⟹    −3x2+x3=1314.-4-12x_2+2x_3-30x_2+12x_3=9 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; -42x_2+14x_3=13 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; -3x_2+x_3=\frac{13}{14}.$

We now see that the same combination −3x2+x3-3x_2+x_3 is forced to equal two different numbers:

−3x2+x3=98and−3x2+x3=1314.-3x_2+x_3=\frac{9}{8}\quad\text{and}\quad -3x_2+x_3=\frac{13}{14}.

Since 98≠1314,\dfrac{9}{8}\neq\dfrac{13}{14}, no pair (x2,x3)(x_2,x_3) can satisfy both conditions simultaneously. Therefore the augmented matrix has rank 3 while the coefficient matrix has rank 2, and the system is inconsistent for λ=−23.\lambda=-\dfrac23.

We have found exactly one value of λ\lambda, namely the negative value −23-\dfrac23, that makes the system inconsistent. No positive value produces inconsistency, and there are not two such values.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Systems of linear equations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicSystems of linear equations
TypeMultiple choice