RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 31 AUG S2+4 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Mathematics question — Systems of linear equations

If α+β+γ=2π\alpha + \beta + \gamma = 2\pi, then the system of equations
x+cos⁡γy+cos⁡βz=0x + \cos\gamma y + \cos\beta z = 0
cos⁡γx+y+cos⁡αz=0\cos\gamma x + y + \cos\alpha z = 0
cos⁡βx+cos⁡αy+z=0\cos\beta x + \cos\alpha y + z = 0
has:

SOLUTION

We are given the homogeneous linear system

x+cos⁡γ y+cos⁡β z=0,cos⁡γ x+y+cos⁡α z=0,cos⁡β x+cos⁡α y+z=0,\begin{aligned} x+\cos\gamma\,y+\cos\beta\,z &= 0,\\ \cos\gamma\,x+y+\cos\alpha\,z &= 0,\\ \cos\beta\,x+\cos\alpha\,y+z &= 0, \end{aligned}$

together with the relation α+β+γ=2π.\alpha+\beta+\gamma = 2\pi. For a homogeneous system, the number of non-trivial solutions is decided completely by the determinant of its coefficient matrix. If the determinant is non-zero, the only solution is the trivial one (x,y,z)=(0,0,0).(x,y,z)=(0,0,0). If the determinant is zero, the matrix is singular and we obtain infinitely many non-trivial solutions in addition to the trivial one.

We therefore form the coefficient matrix

A=[1cos⁡γcos⁡βcos⁡γ1cos⁡αcos⁡βcos⁡α1]A=\begin{bmatrix} 1 & \cos\gamma & \cos\beta\\ \cos\gamma & 1 & \cos\alpha\\ \cos\beta & \cos\alpha & 1 \end{bmatrix}$

and compute its determinant. Using the 3 × 3 determinant expansion formula

det⁡A=1(1⋅1−cos⁡2α)−cos⁡γ(cos⁡γ⋅1−cos⁡αcos⁡β)+cos⁡β(cos⁡γcos⁡α−1⋅cos⁡β),\det A = 1\bigl(1\cdot1-\cos^2\alpha\bigr) -\cos\gamma\bigl(\cos\gamma\cdot1-\cos\alpha\cos\beta\bigr) +\cos\beta\bigl(\cos\gamma\cos\alpha-1\cdot\cos\beta\bigr),$

we proceed step by step.

First term:

1(1⋅1−cos⁡2α)=1−cos⁡2α.1\bigl(1\cdot1-\cos^2\alpha\bigr)=1-\cos^2\alpha.

Second term:

−cos⁡γ(cos⁡γ−cos⁡αcos⁡β)=−cos⁡2γ+cos⁡αcos⁡βcos⁡γ.-\cos\gamma\bigl(\cos\gamma-\cos\alpha\cos\beta\bigr) =-\cos^2\gamma+\cos\alpha\cos\beta\cos\gamma.

Third term:

cos⁡β(cos⁡γcos⁡α−cos⁡β)=cos⁡αcos⁡βcos⁡γ−cos⁡2β.\cos\beta\bigl(\cos\gamma\cos\alpha-\cos\beta\bigr) =\cos\alpha\cos\beta\cos\gamma-\cos^2\beta.

Adding the three results we get

det⁡A=1−cos⁡2α−cos⁡2β−cos⁡2γ+2cos⁡αcos⁡βcos⁡γ.\det A = 1-\cos^2\alpha-\cos^2\beta-\cos^2\gamma +2\cos\alpha\cos\beta\cos\gamma.$

Thus

  det⁡A=1+2cos⁡αcos⁡βcos⁡γ−(cos⁡2α+cos⁡2β+cos⁡2γ)  .\boxed{\;\det A =1+2\cos\alpha\cos\beta\cos\gamma -\bigl(\cos^2\alpha+\cos^2\beta+\cos^2\gamma\bigr)\;}.$

To decide the sign of this expression we now use the given condition α+β+γ=2π.\alpha+\beta+\gamma=2\pi. Because cosine has period 2π2\pi, we can write

cos⁡α=cos⁡(2π−β−γ)=cos⁡(β+γ).\cos\alpha=\cos(2\pi-\beta-\gamma)=\cos(\beta+\gamma).

Applying the compound-angle formula cos⁡(P+Q)=cos⁡P cos⁡Q−sin⁡P sin⁡Q,\cos(P+Q)=\cos P\,\cos Q-\sin P\,\sin Q, we find

cos⁡α=cos⁡βcos⁡γ−sin⁡βsin⁡γ.\cos\alpha=\cos\beta\cos\gamma-\sin\beta\sin\gamma. Denote cos⁡β=B,cos⁡γ=C,sin⁡β=S,sin⁡γ=T.\cos\beta=B,\qquad\cos\gamma=C,\qquad \sin\beta=S,\qquad\sin\gamma=T.$ Then cos⁡α=BC−ST.\cos\alpha=BC-ST.

We substitute these symbols into the determinant expression. The terms become

cos⁡α=BC−ST,cos⁡2α=(BC−ST)2,cos⁡β=B,cos⁡γ=C.\cos\alpha=BC-ST,\qquad \cos^2\alpha=(BC-ST)^2,\qquad \cos\beta=B,\qquad \cos\gamma=C.$

Hence

det⁡A=1+2(BC−ST)BC−[(BC−ST)2+B2+C2].\det A =1+2(BC-ST)BC-\bigl[(BC-ST)^2+B^2+C^2\bigr].$

Expanding step by step:

1. The mixed product term:

2(BC−ST)BC=2B2C2−2STBC.2(BC-ST)BC =2B^2C^2-2STBC.

2. The squared term:

(BC−ST)2=B2C2−2STBC+S2T2.(BC-ST)^2 =B^2C^2-2STBC+S^2T^2.

Putting everything together,

det⁡A=1+2B2C2−2STBC−[B2C2−2STBC+S2T2+B2+C2].\det A =1+2B^2C^2-2STBC -\bigl[B^2C^2-2STBC+S^2T^2+B^2+C^2\bigr].$

Now distribute the minus sign carefully:

det⁡A=1+2B2C2−2STBC−B2C2+2STBC−S2T2−B2−C2.\det A =1+2B^2C^2-2STBC -B^2C^2+2STBC-S^2T^2-B^2-C^2.$

The terms −2STBC-2STBC and +2STBC+2STBC cancel out. Combining like terms we obtain

det⁡A=1+B2C2−S2T2−B2−C2.\det A =1+B^2C^2-S^2T^2-B^2-C^2.

Next we bring in the Pythagorean identity sin⁡2θ=1−cos⁡2θ.\sin^2\theta=1-\cos^2\theta. Hence S2=1−B2,T2=1−C2,S^2=1-B^2,\qquad T^2=1-C^2, so that

S2T2=(1−B2)(1−C2)=1−B2−C2+B2C2.S^2T^2=(1-B^2)(1-C^2)=1-B^2-C^2+B^2C^2.$

Replace S2T2S^2T^2 in the determinant:

det⁡A=1+B2C2−[1−B2−C2+B2C2]−B2−C2.\det A =1+B^2C^2-\bigl[1-B^2-C^2+B^2C^2\bigr]-B^2-C^2.$ Distribute the minus sign once more:

det⁡A=1+B2C2−1+B2+C2−B2C2−B2−C2.\det A =1+B^2C^2-1+B^2+C^2-B^2C^2-B^2-C^2.$

Immediately every term cancels:

det⁡A=0.\det A=0.

Because det⁡A=0,\det A=0, the coefficient matrix is singular. A homogeneous linear system with a singular coefficient matrix always possesses infinitely many solutions (every scalar multiple of any non-trivial solution is also a solution, in addition to the trivial solution).

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Systems of linear equations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicSystems of linear equations
TypeMultiple choice