The three linear equations can be written in matrix form as A x = b A\mathbf{x}= \mathbf{b} A x = b where
A = [ − k 3 − 14 − 15 4 − k − 4 1 3 ] , x = [ x y z ] , b = [ 25 3 4 ] . A=\begin{bmatrix}-k & 3 & -14\\ -15 & 4 & -k\\ -4 & 1 & 3\end{bmatrix},\;
\mathbf{x}=\begin{bmatrix}x\\y\\z\end{bmatrix},\;
\mathbf{b}=\begin{bmatrix}25\\3\\4\end{bmatrix}. A = − k − 15 − 4 3 4 1 − 14 − k 3 , x = x y z , b = 25 3 4 .
A system of linear equations is
• always consistent when det ( A ) ≠ 0 \det(A)\neq 0 det ( A ) = 0 (unique solution),
• possibly inconsistent when det ( A ) = 0 \det(A)=0 det ( A ) = 0 (then we must compare the ranks of A A A and the augmented matrix [ A ∣ b ] [A\,|\,\mathbf{b}] [ A ∣ b ] ).
First compute the determinant of A A A .
Using the first row for cofactor expansion,
det ( A ) = ( − k ) ∣ 4 − k 1 3 ∣ − 3 ∣ − 15 − k − 4 3 ∣ − 14 ∣ − 15 4 − 4 1 ∣ . \det(A)=(-k)\begin{vmatrix}4 & -k\\1 & 3\end{vmatrix}-3\begin{vmatrix}-15 & -k\\-4 & 3\end{vmatrix}-14\begin{vmatrix}-15 & 4\\-4 & 1\end{vmatrix}. det ( A ) = ( − k ) 4 1 − k 3 − 3 − 15 − 4 − k 3 − 14 − 15 − 4 4 1 .
Evaluate the three 2 × 2 2\times 2 2 × 2 minors:
∣ 4 − k 1 3 ∣ = 4 ⋅ 3 − ( − k ) ⋅ 1 = 12 + k , ∣ − 15 − k − 4 3 ∣ = ( − 15 ) ( 3 ) − ( − k ) ( − 4 ) = − 45 − 4 k , ∣ − 15 4 − 4 1 ∣ = ( − 15 ) ( 1 ) − 4 ( − 4 ) = − 15 + 16 = 1. \begin{aligned}
\begin{vmatrix}4 & -k\\1 & 3\end{vmatrix}&=4\cdot 3-(-k)\cdot 1=12+k,\\[4pt]
\begin{vmatrix}-15 & -k\\-4 & 3\end{vmatrix}&=(-15)(3)-(-k)(-4)=-45-4k,\\[4pt]
\begin{vmatrix}-15 & 4\\-4 & 1\end{vmatrix}&=(-15)(1)-4(-4)=-15+16=1.
\end{aligned} 4 1 − k 3 − 15 − 4 − k 3 − 15 − 4 4 1 = 4 ⋅ 3 − ( − k ) ⋅ 1 = 12 + k , = ( − 15 ) ( 3 ) − ( − k ) ( − 4 ) = − 45 − 4 k , = ( − 15 ) ( 1 ) − 4 ( − 4 ) = − 15 + 16 = 1.
Substituting,
det ( A ) = ( − k ) ( 12 + k ) − 3 ( − 45 − 4 k ) − 14 ( 1 ) \det(A)=(-k)(12+k)-3(-45-4k)-14(1) det ( A ) = ( − k ) ( 12 + k ) − 3 ( − 45 − 4 k ) − 14 ( 1 )
= − k 2 − 12 k + 135 + 12 k − 14 =-k^2-12k+135+12k-14 = − k 2 − 12 k + 135 + 12 k − 14
= 121 − k 2 =121-k^2 = 121 − k 2
= − ( k 2 − 121 ) . =-(k^2-121). = − ( k 2 − 121 ) .
Therefore
det ( A ) = 0 ⟺ k 2 − 121 = 0 ⟺ k = ± 11. \det(A)=0 \Longleftrightarrow k^2-121=0 \Longleftrightarrow k=\pm 11. det ( A ) = 0 ⟺ k 2 − 121 = 0 ⟺ k = ± 11.
Case 1: k ≠ ± 11 k\neq\pm 11 k = ± 11 .
Then det ( A ) ≠ 0 \det(A)\neq 0 det ( A ) = 0 , so A A A is invertible and the system has a unique (hence consistent) solution.
Case 2: k = 11 k=11 k = 11 .
Substitute k = 11 k=11 k = 11 in the first two equations:
− 11 x + 3 y − 14 z = 25 − ( 1 ) − 15 x + 4 y − 11 z = 3 − ( 2 ) \begin{aligned}
-11x+3y-14z&=25\; -(1)\\
-15x+4y-11z&=3\; -(2)
\end{aligned} − 11 x + 3 y − 14 z − 15 x + 4 y − 11 z = 25 − ( 1 ) = 3 − ( 2 )
Multiply ( 1 ) (1) ( 1 ) by 4 4 4 and ( 2 ) (2) ( 2 ) by 3 3 3 to eliminate y y y :
− 44 x + 12 y − 56 z = 100 , − 45 x + 12 y − 33 z = 9. \begin{aligned}
-44x+12y-56z&=100,\\
-45x+12y-33z&=9.
\end{aligned} − 44 x + 12 y − 56 z − 45 x + 12 y − 33 z = 100 , = 9.
Subtract the second equation from the first:
x − 23 z = 91 ⟹ x = 91 + 23 z . x-23z=91\Longrightarrow x=91+23z. x − 23 z = 91 ⟹ x = 91 + 23 z .
Back in ( 1 ) : − 11 ( 91 + 23 z ) + 3 y − 14 z = 25 (1):\; -11(91+23z)+3y-14z=25 ( 1 ) : − 11 ( 91 + 23 z ) + 3 y − 14 z = 25 gives
y = 342 + 89 z . y=342+89z. y = 342 + 89 z .
Insert x , y x,y x , y in the third original equation − 4 x + y + 3 z = 4 -4x+y+3z=4 − 4 x + y + 3 z = 4 :
− 4 ( 91 + 23 z ) + ( 342 + 89 z ) + 3 z = 4 ⟹ − 22 = 4 , -4(91+23z)+(342+89z)+3z=4
\Longrightarrow -22=4, − 4 ( 91 + 23 z ) + ( 342 + 89 z ) + 3 z = 4 ⟹ − 22 = 4 ,
a contradiction. Hence no solution; the system is inconsistent when k = 11 k=11 k = 11 .
Case 3: k = − 11 k=-11 k = − 11 .
The equations become
11 x + 3 y − 14 z = 25 − ( 3 ) − 15 x + 4 y + 11 z = 3 − ( 4 ) \begin{aligned}
11x+3y-14z&=25\; -(3)\\
-15x+4y+11z&=3\; -(4)
\end{aligned} 11 x + 3 y − 14 z − 15 x + 4 y + 11 z = 25 − ( 3 ) = 3 − ( 4 )
Eliminate y y y by multiplying ( 3 ) (3) ( 3 ) by 4 4 4 and ( 4 ) (4) ( 4 ) by 3 3 3 :
44 x + 12 y − 56 z = 100 , − 45 x + 12 y + 33 z = 9. \begin{aligned}
44x+12y-56z&=100,\\
-45x+12y+33z&=9.
\end{aligned} 44 x + 12 y − 56 z − 45 x + 12 y + 33 z = 100 , = 9.
Subtract:
89 x − 89 z = 91 ⟹ x = z + 91 89 . 89x-89z=91\Longrightarrow x=z+\frac{91}{89}. 89 x − 89 z = 91 ⟹ x = z + 89 91 .
Substituting in ( 3 ) (3) ( 3 ) gives y = z + 408 89 . y=z+\frac{408}{89}. y = z + 89 408 .
Use these in the third original equation − 4 x + y + 3 z = 4 -4x+y+3z=4 − 4 x + y + 3 z = 4 :
− 4 ( z + 91 89 ) + ( z + 408 89 ) + 3 z = 44 89 ≠ 4 , -4\!\left(z+\frac{91}{89}\right)+\left(z+\frac{408}{89}\right)+3z
=\frac{44}{89}\neq 4, − 4 ( z + 89 91 ) + ( z + 89 408 ) + 3 z = 89 44 = 4 ,
again a contradiction. Hence no solution; the system is inconsistent when k = − 11 k=-11 k = − 11 .
Combining all cases, the system is consistent for every real k k k except k = 11 k=11 k = 11 and k = − 11 k=-11 k = − 11 .
Therefore the required set is R − { − 11 , 11 } \mathbb{R}-\{-11,11\} R − { − 11 , 11 } , which corresponds to Option D .