We first compute AB and BA.
AB=[α00β][0δγ0]=[0βδαγ0].
Similarly,
BA=[0δγ0][α00β]=[0αδβγ0].
Therefore,
AB−BA=[0δ(β−α)γ(α−β)0].
Equivalently,
AB−BA=(α−β)[0−δγ0].
To examine invertibility, compute the determinant:
det(AB−BA)=0⋅0−γ(α−β)δ(β−α).
Since β−α=−(α−β),
det(AB−BA)=γδ(α−β)2.
If α=β, then
AB−BA=[0000],
which is not invertible.
Hence Statement 1 is false.
Now consider Statement 2.
The identity matrix is
I=[1001].
But every matrix of the form
AB−BA=[0δ(β−α)γ(α−β)0]
has diagonal entries equal to 0.
Therefore AB−BA can never be equal to I, whose diagonal entries are 1.
Hence Statement 2 is true.
Therefore, Statement 1 is false and Statement 2 is true.