RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2011TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2011 Mathematics question — Transpose, symmetric and skew-symmetric matrices

Let AA and BB be two symmetric matrices of order 3. This question has Statement-1 and Statement-2. Of the four choices given after the statements, choose the one that best describes the two statements. Statement-1: A(BA)A(BA) and (AB)A(AB)A are symmetric matrices. Statement-2: ABAB is symmetric matrix if matrix multiplication of AA and BB is commutative.

SOLUTION

Let AA and BB be symmetric 3×33 \times 3 matrices, so AT=AA^{T}=A and BT=BB^{T}=B.

Case 1: Matrix A(BA)A(BA)

Write it in the compact form ABAABA (associativity of matrix multiplication).
Take the transpose:

(ABA)T=ATBTAT  \bigl(ABA\bigr)^{T}=A^{T}B^{T}A^{T}\; (because (XY)T=YTXT\left(XY\right)^{T}=Y^{T}X^{T}).

Since AT=AA^{T}=A and BT=BB^{T}=B, we get

(ABA)T=ABA.\bigl(ABA\bigr)^{T}=ABA.

Thus A(BA)=ABAA(BA)=ABA is symmetric.

Case 2: Matrix (AB)A(AB)A

Again, by associativity, (AB)A=ABA(AB)A=ABA, the same product as above.
Hence its transpose is identical to the previous case:

((AB)A)T=(ABA)T=ABA=(AB)A.\bigl((AB)A\bigr)^{T}=(ABA)^{T}=ABA=(AB)A.

Therefore (AB)A(AB)A is also symmetric.

Consequently, Statement-1 is true.

Verification of Statement-2: If the multiplication of AA and BB is commutative, i.e. AB=BAAB=BA, then

(AB)T=BTAT=BA.(AB)^{T}=B^{T}A^{T}=BA.

Using the given commutativity, BA=ABBA=AB, so

(AB)T=AB,(AB)^{T}=AB,

which shows that ABAB is symmetric whenever AB=BAAB=BA. Hence Statement-2 is also true.

Does Statement-2 explain Statement-1?
The symmetry of A(BA)A(BA) and (AB)A(AB)A was obtained solely from the facts that AA and BB are symmetric and from associativity; we never used the additional condition AB=BAAB=BA. Therefore Statement-2 is not the reasoning behind Statement-1.

Option A is correct: Statement-1 is true, Statement-2 is true, but Statement-2 is not a correct explanation of Statement-1.

Tagged Transpose, symmetric and skew-symmetric matrices. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicTranspose, symmetric and skew-symmetric matrices
TypeMultiple choice