RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2009TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2009 Mathematics question — Properties of determinants

Let a,b,ca, b, c be such that b(a+c)≠0b(a + c) \neq 0. If ∣aa+1a−1−bb+1b−1cc−1c+1∣+∣a+1b+1c−1a−1b−1c+1(−1)n+2a(−1)n+1b(−1)nc∣=0,\begin{vmatrix} a & a+1 & a-1 \\ -b & b+1 & b-1 \\ c & c-1 & c+1 \end{vmatrix} + \begin{vmatrix} a+1 & b+1 & c-1 \\ a-1 & b-1 & c+1 \\ (-1)^{n+2}a & (-1)^{n+1}b & (-1)^n c \end{vmatrix} = 0,$ then the value of 'nn' is

SOLUTION

Let the two determinants be

D1=∣aa+1a−1−bb+1b−1cc−1c+1∣,D2=∣a+1b+1c−1a−1b−1c+1(−1) n+2a(−1) n+1b(−1) nc∣.D_1=\begin{vmatrix} a & a+1 & a-1 \\ -b & b+1 & b-1 \\ c & c-1 & c+1 \end{vmatrix},\qquad D_2=\begin{vmatrix} a+1 & b+1 & c-1 \\ a-1 & b-1 & c+1 \\ (-1)^{\,n+2}a & (-1)^{\,n+1}b & (-1)^{\,n}c \end{vmatrix}.

The given condition is D1+D2=0D_1+D_2=0 with b(a+c)≠0.b(a+c)\neq 0. We evaluate each determinant separately.

Case 1: Evaluation of D1D_1

Apply the column transformations C2→C2−C1,  C3→C3−C1C_2\to C_2-C_1,\; C_3\to C_3-C_1 (determinant remains unchanged):

D1=∣a1−1−b2b+12b−1c−11∣.D_1=\begin{vmatrix} a & 1 & -1 \\ -b & 2b+1 & 2b-1 \\ c & -1 & 1 \end{vmatrix}.

Expanding along the first row,

D1=a((2b+1)(1)−(2b−1)(−1))−1((−b)(1)−(2b−1)c)+(−1)((−b)(−1)−(2b+1)c).\begin{aligned} D_1 & = a\bigl((2b+1)(1)-(2b-1)(-1)\bigr) \\ &\quad -1\bigl((-b)(1)-(2b-1)c\bigr) \\ &\quad +(-1)\bigl((-b)(-1)-(2b+1)c\bigr). \end{aligned}

Simplifying each term,

D1=4ab+(b+2bc−c)+(−b+2bc+c)=4ab+4bc.D_1 = 4ab + (b+2bc-c) + (-b+2bc+c)=4ab+4bc.

Thus

D1=4b(a+c).D_1 = 4b(a+c).

Case 2: Evaluation of D2D_2

Write (−1) n=s  (=±1).(-1)^{\,n}=s\;(=\pm1). Then (−1) n+1=−s,  (−1) n+2=s.(-1)^{\,n+1}=-s,\; (-1)^{\,n+2}=s. So

D2=∣a+1b+1c−1a−1b−1c+1sa−sbsc∣=s ∣a+1b+1c−1a−1b−1c+1a−bc∣.D_2=\begin{vmatrix} a+1 & b+1 & c-1 \\ a-1 & b-1 & c+1 \\ sa & -sb & sc \end{vmatrix}=s\, \begin{vmatrix} a+1 & b+1 & c-1 \\ a-1 & b-1 & c+1 \\ a & -b & c \end{vmatrix}. Call the second determinant D2′.D'_2.

Compute D2′D'_2 by the row operation R1→R1−R2R_1\to R_1-R_2:

D2′=∣22−2a−1b−1c+1a−bc∣=2∣11−1a−1b−1c+1a−bc∣.D'_2=\begin{vmatrix} 2 & 2 & -2 \\ a-1 & b-1 & c+1 \\ a & -b & c \end{vmatrix} =2\begin{vmatrix} 1 & 1 & -1 \\ a-1 & b-1 & c+1 \\ a & -b & c \end{vmatrix}.

Expanding along the first row:

D2′=2[(1)((b−1)c−(c+1)(−b))−(1)((a−1)c−(c+1)a)+(−1)((a−1)(−b)−(b−1)a)].\begin{aligned} D'_2 &= 2\Bigl[(1)\bigl((b-1)c-(c+1)(-b)\bigr) \\ &\qquad -(1)\bigl((a-1)c-(c+1)a\bigr) \\ &\qquad +(-1)\bigl((a-1)(-b)-(b-1)a\bigr)\Bigr]. \end{aligned}

Simplifying inside the brackets gives 2b(c+a).2b(c+a). Hence

D2′=2⋅2b(a+c)=4b(a+c).D'_2 = 2\cdot 2b(a+c)=4b(a+c).

Therefore

D2=s  D2′=(−1) n 4b(a+c).D_2 = s\;D'_2 = (-1)^{\,n}\,4b(a+c).

Case 3: Applying the given relation

D1+D2=0  ⟹  4b(a+c)+4b(a+c)(−1) n=0.D_1+D_2=0\;\Longrightarrow\;4b(a+c)+4b(a+c)(-1)^{\,n}=0.

Since b(a+c)≠0,b(a+c)\neq 0, divide both sides by 4b(a+c)4b(a+c) to get

1+(−1) n=0  ⟹  (−1) n=−1.1+(-1)^{\,n}=0\;\Longrightarrow\;(-1)^{\,n}=-1.

This happens exactly when nn is an odd integer.

Hence the required value of nn is any odd integer.

Option C which is: any odd integer

Tagged Properties of determinants. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicProperties of determinants
TypeMultiple choice