RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 02 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Mathematics question — Systems of linear equations

If SS is the set of distinct values of bb for which the following system of linear equations
x+y+z=1x + y + z = 1
x+ay+z=1x + ay + z = 1
ax+by+z=0ax + by + z = 0
has no solution, then SS is:

SOLUTION

We have the three simultaneous linear equations

x+y+z=1(1)x+ay+z=1(2)ax+by+z=0(3)\begin{aligned} x+y+z &= 1 \qquad\qquad (1)\\ x+ay+z &= 1 \qquad\qquad (2)\\ ax+by+z &= 0 \qquad\qquad (3) \end{aligned}

Our task is to locate all real numbers bb for which this system has no solution.

To see when inconsistency arises, we first compare the first two equations. Subtracting equation (2)(2) from equation (1)(1) gives

(x−x)  +  (y−ay)  +  (z−z)  =  1−1,(x-x)\;+\;(y-ay)\;+\;(z-z)\;=\;1-1,

so

(1−a) y=0.−(4)(1-a)\,y = 0. \quad -(4)

This single relation already produces two mutually exclusive situations. We study each of them separately.

Case I : a≠1a\neq1

Because 1−a≠01-a\neq0, equation (4)(4) forces

y=0.−(5)y=0. \quad -(5)

Substituting y=0y=0 into equation (1)(1) we obtain

x+0+z=1    ⟹    x+z=1.−(6)x+0+z = 1 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; x+z = 1. \quad -(6)

Next we substitute y=0y=0 into equation (3)(3). The term byby vanishes, leaving

ax+z=0.−(7)ax+z = 0. \quad -(7)

Now we have the two linear equations in the two unknowns xx and zz:

{x+z=1,ax+z=0.\begin{cases} x+z = 1,\\[2pt] ax+z = 0. \end{cases}

Subtracting the second from the first eliminates zz and yields

(1−a) x=1.−(8)(1-a)\,x = 1. \quad -(8)

Because a≠1a\neq1, the coefficient 1−a1-a is non-zero, so equation (8)(8) gives the unique value

x=11−a.−(9)x = \dfrac{1}{1-a}. \quad -(9)

Putting this value back into equation (6)(6), we get

11−a+z=1    ⟹    z=1−11−a=−a1−a=aa−1.−(10)\frac{1}{1-a}+z = 1 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; z = 1-\frac{1}{1-a} = \frac{-a}{1-a} = \frac{a}{a-1}. \quad -(10)

Thus for every real number bb (no restriction at all), when a≠1a\neq1 the system produces the explicit solution

(x,y,z)=(11−a,  0,  aa−1),(x,y,z) = \left(\frac{1}{1-a},\;0,\;\frac{a}{a-1}\right),

so the system is perfectly consistent. Hence, whenever a≠1a\neq1 no value of bb can destroy solvability.

Case II : a=1a=1

Setting a=1a=1 in the original system, equations (1)(1) and (2)(2) become identical:

x+y+z=1.−(11)x+y+z = 1. \quad -(11)

Equation (3)(3), after inserting a=1a=1, turns into

x+by+z=0.−(12)x+by+z = 0. \quad -(12)

Thus the system effectively reduces to the pair of equations (11)(11) and (12)(12). To compare these, subtract equation (12)(12) from equation (11)(11):

(x−x)  +  (y−by)  +  (z−z)  =  1−0,(x-x)\;+\;(y-by)\;+\;(z-z)\;=\;1-0,

which simplifies to

(1−b) y=1.−(13)(1-b)\,y = 1. \quad -(13)

Now again two possibilities appear:

• If b≠1b\neq1, equation (13)(13) delivers the single value

y=11−b,−(14)y = \dfrac{1}{1-b}, \quad -(14)

and we can solve for x+zx+z from either equation (11)(11) or (12)(12). Indeed using (11)(11) we get x+z=1−yx+z=1-y, while using (12)(12) we get x+z=−byx+z=-by, and with yy from (14)(14) the two expressions coincide, so solutions exist. Therefore no inconsistency occurs when b≠1b\neq1.

• If b=1b=1, equation (13)(13) reads 0⋅y=10\cdot y = 1, an impossibility. Thus the two equations (11)(11) and (12)(12) demand the same left-hand side but force it to equal two different right-hand sides (1 and 0). This is a direct contradiction, so the system has no solution when a=1a=1 and b=1b=1.

Collecting the conclusions

• For every a≠1a\neq1 the system is solvable for all real bb.

• For a=1a=1 the system is solvable for every b≠1b\neq1 but becomes inconsistent precisely at b=1b=1.

Hence the lone real number capable of destroying solvability is

b=1.b = 1.

Therefore the set SS of such bb is the singleton {1}\{1\}, containing exactly one element.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Systems of linear equations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicSystems of linear equations
TypeMultiple choice