RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Mathematics question — Implications, negation and quantifiers

Consider the following two statements:
PP: If 7 is an odd number, then 7 is divisible by 2.
QQ: If 7 is a prime number, then 7 is an odd number.
If V1V_1 is the truth value of the contrapositive of PP and V2V_2 is the truth value of contrapositive of QQ, then the ordered pair (V1,V2)(V_1, V_2) equals

SOLUTION

First, we recall the standard logical rule: for any implication of the form A→BA \rightarrow B the contrapositive is the statement ¬B→¬A\lnot B \rightarrow \lnot A and both have exactly the same truth value. We will apply this rule separately to the two given statements PP and QQ, and then determine the ordered pair of their truth values.

We have the statement PP:

P:P:\qquad If 77 is an odd number, then 77 is divisible by 2.2.

For PP the antecedent (the “if” part) is

A:  7 is an odd number,A:\;7\text{ is an odd number},

and the consequent (the “then” part) is

B:  7 is divisible by 2.B:\;7\text{ is divisible by }2.

Using the contrapositive rule, the contrapositive of PP is

¬B→¬A.\lnot B \rightarrow \lnot A.

Writing it out in words:

If 77 is \emph{not divisible by }2, then 77 is \emph{not an odd number}.

Now, we determine the truth value of this contrapositive:

• The statement “7 is not divisible by 2” is true because 7 divided by 2 does not give an integer quotient.
• The statement “7 is not an odd number” is false because 7 is indeed odd.

In a conditional X→Y,X \rightarrow Y, if the antecedent XX is true and the consequent YY is false, the whole conditional is false. Therefore, the contrapositive of PP is false. We denote this by

V1=F.V_1 = F.

Next, we analyze the statement QQ:

Q:Q:\qquad If 77 is a prime number, then 77 is an odd number ..

Here, the antecedent is

C:  7 is a prime number,C:\;7\text{ is a prime number},

and the consequent is

D:  7 is an odd number.D:\;7\text{ is an odd number}.

The contrapositive of QQ is

¬D→¬C,\lnot D \rightarrow \lnot C,

that is,

If 77 is \emph{not an odd number, then }7 is \emph{not a prime number}.

We check its truth value:

• The antecedent “7 is not an odd number” is false because 7 is odd.
• In material implication, whenever the antecedent is false, the entire conditional statement is automatically true, regardless of the consequent.

Hence the contrapositive of QQ is true, and we write

V2=T.V_2 = T.

Collecting the two truth values, we obtain the ordered pair

(V1,V2)=(F,T).(V_1, V_2) = (F, T).

This matches Option A.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Implications, negation and quantifiers. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicImplications, negation and quantifiers
TypeMultiple choice