Consider :
Statement - I : is a fallacy.
Statement - II : is a tautology.
First we recall some basic logical equivalences that we shall use again and again.
Implication : Biconditional : Associative and commutative laws allow us to rearrange and regroup the symbols and freely.
Now we examine Statement I :
We have Because the conjunction is associative, the brackets may be dropped one at a time:
Next, with the commutative law we collect like symbols together:
Inside the expression we clearly see and also . Each of these pairs is always false because a statement and its negation can never be true simultaneously. Hence
So the whole conjunction becomes
The result does not depend on the particular truth-values of or ; it is always false. A statement that is always false is called a fallacy. Therefore Statement I is true.
Next we analyse Statement II :
We start with the given biconditional
Using the implication formula quoted at the beginning, we transform each part separately.
First,
Second, we handle the contrapositive implication carefully. Applying with and we obtain
Notice that the disjunction is identical to because is commutative. Hence we can write
So both sides of the biconditional are in fact the same formula:
Therefore the whole statement becomes
A biconditional of any statement with itself, i.e. is always true, because both possible parts in the definition are automatically satisfied. Hence the biconditional above is always true; that is, it is a tautology. So Statement II is also true.
We must still decide whether Statement II provides a correct explanation for Statement I. Statement II merely tells us that an implication is equivalent to its contrapositive; it does not explain why the particular conjunction in Statement I is always false. Thus, while both statements are true, Statement II is not the reason for Statement I.
The situation matches Option D.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Logical connectives, truth tables and tautologies. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.