We have to examine the statement ∼(p↔∼q) and decide which description among the four alternatives fits it.
First, recall the standard logical equivalence formula for a biconditional. We state it explicitly:
p↔r≡(p∧r)∨(∼p∧∼r).
The symbol “≡” means “is logically equivalent to.” In our problem the role of r is played by ∼q, so we substitute r=∼q:
p↔∼q≡(p∧∼q)∨(∼p∧∼(∼q)).
Because a double negation cancels, ∼(∼q)=q. Substituting this, we simplify the right-hand side:
p↔∼q≡(p∧∼q)∨(∼p∧q).
Now our original expression contains the negation of this whole biconditional, so we negate what we have just obtained:
∼(p↔∼q)≡∼[(p∧∼q)∨(∼p∧q)].
Next we invoke De Morgan’s law, which states
∼(A∨B)≡(∼A)∧(∼B).
Identifying A=(p∧∼q) and B=(∼p∧q), we apply the law:
∼(p↔∼q)≡(∼(p∧∼q))∧(∼(∼p∧q)).
Each of the two negations inside the brackets can again be opened with De Morgan’s law, this time in its conjunctive form
∼(X∧Y)≡(∼X)∨(∼Y).
For the first bracket we have X=p and Y=∼q, giving
∼(p∧∼q)≡(∼p)∨(∼(∼q)).
The double negation ∼(∼q) collapses to q, so the first bracket becomes
∼(p∧∼q)≡(∼p)∨q.
For the second bracket we have X=∼p and Y=q, yielding
∼(∼p∧q)≡(∼(∼p))∨(∼q).
Again the double negation ∼(∼p) reduces to p, giving
∼(∼p∧q)≡p∨(∼q).
Collecting both results, we have transformed the original statement into
∼(p↔∼q)≡((∼p)∨q)∧(p∨(∼q)).
Thus
∼(p↔∼q)≡(∼p∨q)∧(p∨∼q)
We now show that the right-hand side is exactly p↔q. To see this, we once more recall the biconditional formula, this time with r=q:
p↔q≡(p∧q)∨(∼p∧∼q).
One way to verify equivalence of two compound statements is to check that their truth tables match. Below are the four possible truth-value assignments for p and q, and the resulting truth values of (∼p∨q)∧(p∨∼q):
pTTFFqTFTF∼p∨qTFTTp∨∼qTTFTConjunctionTFFT
The last column reads T, F, F, T—precisely the truth pattern of p↔q. Hence
(∼p∨q)∧(p∨∼q)≡p↔q.
Combining this with the boxed equivalence obtained earlier, we finally deduce
∼(p↔∼q)≡p↔q
This matches Option C in the given list. It is therefore neither a tautology nor a fallacy in isolation; it is simply equivalent to another specific biconditional.
Hence, the correct answer is Option C.