We have to decide the logical nature of the formula S=(p→(q→p))→(p→(p∨q)).
First, we recall the standard implication-disjunction equivalence:
a→b≡∼a∨b.
We apply this rule to the innermost implication q→p.
So, q→p≡∼q∨p.
Substituting this result back into the left part of S we get
p→(q→p)≡p→(∼q∨p).
Once again using the same rule a→b≡∼a∨b on the implication whose antecedent is p, we have
p→(∼q∨p)≡∼p∨(∼q∨p).
Now we re-arrange the disjunction because disjunction is associative and commutative:
∼p∨(∼q∨p)=(∼p∨p)∨∼q.
We know that the law of excluded middle tells us ∼p∨p≡True. Therefore,
(∼p∨p)∨∼q≡True∨∼q≡True.
Hence, the whole sub-formula p→(q→p) is always true; it is a tautology. We can now write
p→(q→p)≡True.
Next, we turn to the right part of S, namely p→(p∨q). Again we use a→b≡∼a∨b.
So,
p→(p∨q)≡∼p∨(p∨q).
Associating the disjunctions yields
∼p∨p∨q.
By the law of excluded middle, ∼p∨p≡True, hence
∼p∨p∨q≡True∨q≡True.
Therefore, the consequent (p→(p∨q)) is also a tautology. We can thus rewrite S purely in terms of truth values:
S≡(True)→(True).
Finally, we know that True→True≡True, because an implication with a true antecedent and a true consequent is true.
So the entire statement S is always true for every possible truth-value assignment of p and q. That is, S is a tautology.
Hence, the correct answer is Option 4.