RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 27 JUL S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Mathematics question — Implications, negation and quantifiers

Which of the following is the negation of the statement "for all M>0M \gt 0, there exists x∈Sx \in S such that x≥Mx \geq M"?

SOLUTION

We start with the given statement:

(I)  :  ∀ M>0,  ∃ x∈S such that x≥M.\text{(I)}\;:\;\forall\,M \gt 0,\;\exists\,x\in S\text{ such that }x\ge M.

The words “for all” correspond to the universal quantifier ∀\forall and the words “there exists” correspond to the existential quantifier ∃\exists. To find the negation of a quantified statement, we use the standard logical rules:

1. The negation of ∀\forall (for all) is ∃\exists (there exists).
2. The negation of ∃\exists (there exists) is ∀\forall (for all).
3. Inside, we must also negate the inner predicate.

Applying rule 1 to statement (I) we replace the leading ∀\forall by ∃\exists. So we write:

¬(I):  ∃ M>0 [¬ (∃ x∈S such that x≥M)].\neg\text{(I)}:\;\exists\,M \gt 0\ \bigl[\neg\,(\exists\,x\in S\text{ such that }x\ge M)\bigr].

Now we focus on the inner part ∃ x∈S such that x≥M\exists\,x\in S\text{ such that }x\ge M and apply rule 2: its negation changes ∃\exists to ∀\forall and, according to rule 3, the condition x≥Mx\ge M switches to its opposite x<Mx\lt M. Thus,

¬(∃ x∈S such that x≥M)  =  ∀ x∈S,  x<M.\neg\bigl(\exists\,x\in S\text{ such that }x\ge M\bigr)\;=\;\forall\,x\in S,\;x\lt M.

Substituting this negation back, we get

¬(I):  ∃ M>0 such that ∀ x∈S,  x<M.\neg\text{(I)}:\;\exists\,M \gt 0\text{ such that }\forall\,x\in S,\;x\lt M.

Reading this sentence in plain words: “There exists a positive number MM such that every element xx of the set SS is strictly less than MM.”

Now we compare this with the options given:

A. There exists M>0M \gt 0 such that x<Mx \lt M for all x∈Sx \in S.
B. There exists M>0M \gt 0, there exists x∈Sx \in S such that x≥Mx \ge M.
C. There exists M>0M \gt 0, there exists x∈Sx \in S such that x<Mx \lt M.
D. There exists M>0M \gt 0 such that x≥Mx \ge M for all x∈Sx \in S.

Option A reproduces exactly the negated statement we have derived. The other options either keep both quantifiers as existential (B, C) or invert the inequality without changing both quantifiers appropriately (D). Therefore Option A is the only correct negation.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Implications, negation and quantifiers. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicImplications, negation and quantifiers
TypeMultiple choice