Consider the two statements:
is a tautology.
is a fallacy.
Then:
We have to examine two logical sentences.
First consider
Before simplifying, we recall the basic implication equivalence:
For any propositions and the implication is equivalent to
Applying this rule to each implication inside we get
So becomes
Using the associative and commutative laws of we may regroup and list all literals together:
Now, by the law of excluded middle, (always true).
Also,
Hence
Because the disjunction reduces to the constant true value the formula is true for every possible truth assignment of and Therefore is indeed a tautology.
Now we examine
For this conjunction to be true, both parts must be true simultaneously.
Start with the left conjunct For it to be true we must have
With these same truth values, evaluate the right conjunct Since we have and with we obtain
Thus, whenever the first conjunct is true, the second conjunct is forced to be false, making the whole conjunction false. No other truth assignment can make the first conjunct true, so there is no assignment that makes the entire expression true.
Therefore the statement is always false; it is a fallacy. Hence the meta-statement saying “this formula is a fallacy” is true.
We have established that is a tautology (true) and correctly asserts a fallacy (so is also true). Therefore, both statements are true.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Logical connectives, truth tables and tautologies. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.