JEE Main 2018 Mathematics question — Implications, negation and quantifiers
Consider the following two statements. Statement p: The value of sin120∘ can be divided by taking θ=240∘ in the equation 2sin2θ=1+sinθ−1−sinθ. Statement q: The angles A, B, C and D of any quadrilateral ABCD satisfy the equation cos(21(A+C))+cos(21(B+D))=0. Then the truth values of p and q are respectively:
SOLUTION
First we examine Statement p. The equation given is
2sin2θ=1+sinθ−1−sinθ.
We are told to put θ=240∘. Let us evaluate every term one by one.
We have sin240∘=sin(180∘+60∘)=−sin60∘=−23.
Now compute the left-hand side (L.H.S.) of the equation:
2sin2θ=2sin(2240∘)=2sin120∘.
Using sin120∘=sin(60∘)=23, we get
2sin120∘=2⋅23=3.
So the L.H.S. equals 3(≈1.732).
Next we evaluate the right-hand side (R.H.S.):
1+sinθ−1−sinθ.
Substituting sinθ=−23, we obtain
1−23−1+23.
Convert the 1 to a fraction with denominator 2:
1=22, so
22−3−22+3.
The first square root is approximately 0.134≈0.366, and the second is approximately 1.866≈1.366. Therefore the R.H.S. is roughly
0.366−1.366≈−1.000.
We now compare:
L.H.S.=3(≈1.732),R.H.S.≈−1.000.
The two sides are not equal, so the equation does not hold for θ=240∘. Hence Statement p is false.
Now we investigate Statement q. In any quadrilateral ABCD the interior angles satisfy
A+B+C+D=360∘.
We are to test the identity
cos(21(A+C))+cos(21(B+D))=0.
Let us denote
X=21(A+C).
Because the sum of all four angles is 360∘, we have
B+D=360∘−(A+C).
Dividing by 2 gives
21(B+D)=21[360∘−(A+C)]=180∘−21(A+C)=180∘−X.
Now write the left side of the proposed identity in terms of X:
cosX+cos(180∘−X).
We recall the trigonometric fact: cos(180∘−θ)=−cosθ. Stating the formula plainly, “cosine changes sign in the second quadrant.” Using this formula with θ=X gives
cos(180∘−X)=−cosX.
Substituting, we get
cosX+(−cosX)=0.
The expression indeed equals zero for every choice of angles A, B, C and D that add to 360∘. Thus Statement q is true.
We have found:
Statement p: False, Statement q: True.
The ordered pair of truth values is (F, T), which corresponds to Option A.
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.
Tagged Implications, negation and quantifiers. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.