RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 15 APR S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Mathematics question — Implications, negation and quantifiers

Consider the following two statements.
Statement p: The value of sin⁡120∘\sin 120^\circ can be divided by taking θ=240∘\theta = 240^\circ in the equation 2sin⁡θ2=1+sin⁡θ−1−sin⁡θ2\sin\frac{\theta}{2} = \sqrt{1 + \sin\theta} - \sqrt{1 - \sin\theta}.
Statement q: The angles A, B, C and D of any quadrilateral ABCD satisfy the equation cos⁡(12(A+C))+cos⁡(12(B+D))=0\cos\left(\frac{1}{2}(A+C)\right) + \cos\left(\frac{1}{2}(B+D)\right) = 0.
Then the truth values of p and q are respectively:

SOLUTION

First we examine Statement p. The equation given is

2sin⁡θ2= 1+sin⁡θ − 1−sin⁡θ .2\sin\frac{\theta}{2}= \sqrt{\,1+\sin\theta\,}-\sqrt{\,1-\sin\theta\,}.

We are told to put θ=240∘.\theta =240^\circ. Let us evaluate every term one by one.

We have sin⁡240∘=sin⁡(180∘+60∘)=−sin⁡60∘=−32.\sin 240^\circ=\sin\left(180^\circ+60^\circ\right)=-\sin60^\circ=-\frac{\sqrt3}{2}.

Now compute the left-hand side (L.H.S.) of the equation:

2sin⁡θ2=2sin⁡(240∘2)=2sin⁡120∘.2\sin\frac{\theta}{2}=2\sin\left(\frac{240^\circ}{2}\right)=2\sin120^\circ.

Using sin⁡120∘=sin⁡(60∘)=32,\sin120^\circ=\sin(60^\circ)=\frac{\sqrt3}{2}, we get

2sin⁡120∘=2⋅32=3.2\sin120^\circ=2\cdot\frac{\sqrt3}{2}=\sqrt3.

So the L.H.S. equals 3  (≈1.732).\sqrt3\;(\approx1.732).

Next we evaluate the right-hand side (R.H.S.):

 1+sin⁡θ − 1−sin⁡θ .\sqrt{\,1+\sin\theta\,}-\sqrt{\,1-\sin\theta\,}.

Substituting sin⁡θ=−32,\sin\theta=-\frac{\sqrt3}{2}, we obtain

 1−32 − 1+32 .\sqrt{\,1-\frac{\sqrt3}{2}\,}-\sqrt{\,1+\frac{\sqrt3}{2}\,}.

Convert the 1 to a fraction with denominator 2:

1=22,1=\frac{2}{2}, so

2−32−2+32.\sqrt{\frac{2-\sqrt3}{2}}-\sqrt{\frac{2+\sqrt3}{2}}.

The first square root is approximately 0.134≈0.366,\sqrt{0.134}\approx0.366, and the second is approximately 1.866≈1.366.\sqrt{1.866}\approx1.366. Therefore the R.H.S. is roughly

0.366−1.366≈−1.000.0.366-1.366\approx-1.000.

We now compare:

L.H.S.=3  (≈1.732),R.H.S.≈−1.000.\text{L.H.S.}=\sqrt3\;(\approx1.732),\qquad\text{R.H.S.}\approx-1.000.

The two sides are not equal, so the equation does not hold for θ=240∘.\theta=240^\circ. Hence Statement p is false.

Now we investigate Statement q. In any quadrilateral ABCD the interior angles satisfy

A+B+C+D=360∘.A+B+C+D=360^\circ.

We are to test the identity

cos⁡ ⁣(12(A+C))+cos⁡ ⁣(12(B+D))=0.\cos\!\left(\tfrac12(A+C)\right)+\cos\!\left(\tfrac12(B+D)\right)=0.

Let us denote

X=12(A+C).X=\tfrac12(A+C).

Because the sum of all four angles is 360∘,360^\circ, we have

B+D=360∘−(A+C).B+D=360^\circ-(A+C).

Dividing by 2 gives

12(B+D)=12 ⁣[ 360∘−(A+C)]=180∘−12(A+C)=180∘−X.\tfrac12(B+D)=\tfrac12\!\left[\,360^\circ-(A+C)\right]=180^\circ-\tfrac12(A+C)=180^\circ-X.

Now write the left side of the proposed identity in terms of X:X:

cos⁡X+cos⁡(180∘−X).\cos X+\cos(180^\circ-X).

We recall the trigonometric fact: cos⁡(180∘−θ)=−cos⁡θ.\cos(180^\circ-\theta)=-\cos\theta. Stating the formula plainly, “cosine changes sign in the second quadrant.” Using this formula with θ=X\theta=X gives

cos⁡(180∘−X)=−cos⁡X.\cos(180^\circ-X)=-\cos X.

Substituting, we get

cos⁡X+(−cos⁡X)=0.\cos X+\bigl(-\cos X\bigr)=0.

The expression indeed equals zero for every choice of angles A, B, C and D that add to 360∘.360^\circ. Thus Statement q is true.

We have found:

Statement p: False,   Statement q: True.

The ordered pair of truth values is (F, T), which corresponds to Option A.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Implications, negation and quantifiers. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicImplications, negation and quantifiers
TypeMultiple choice