If q is false and is true, then which one of the following statements is a tautology?
We are told that the statement is false and at the same time the biconditional is true. Let us first interpret this information.
By definition, the conjunction is true only when both and are true. Because we already know that is false, the value of the entire conjunction is immediately fixed:
Next, we look at the biconditional. Remember the rule for a biconditional:
For any two statements and , the statement is true precisely when either
(i) both and are true, or
(ii) both and are false.
In our problem and . We have discovered that is false. For the biconditional to be true, case (ii) must hold; therefore must also be false. Concretely,
At this point we have
is still free (it can be True or False).
We now inspect each option to see which statement is necessarily true—i.e. a tautology—under these fixed truth values.
Option A:
Because we simplify step by step:
Thus Option A becomes The truth rule for implication says is false exactly when is true and is false. Here, whenever is true the implication is false. Hence Option A is not always true.
Option B:
Again using we get
The whole statement reduces to An implication whose antecedent is false is always true, irrespective of the consequent. Therefore Option B is always true for both possibilities of and is thus a tautology.
Option C: This is always false, so it certainly is not a tautology.
Option D: The truth of this statement depends on whether itself is true or false, so it is not guaranteed to be true in all cases.
Only Option B satisfies the requirement of being always true under the given conditions.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Logical connectives, truth tables and tautologies. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.