We have to evaluate the following limit as x x x tends to 0 0 0
L = lim x → 0 ( x 1 − sin x 8 − 1 + sin x 8 ) . − ( 1 ) \displaystyle L=\lim_{x\rightarrow 0}\left(\frac{x}{\sqrt[8]{1-\sin x}-\sqrt[8]{1+\sin x}}\right)\;.-(1) L = x → 0 lim ( 8 1 − sin x − 8 1 + sin x x ) . − ( 1 )
Because x → 0 x\rightarrow 0 x → 0 , the quantity sin x \sin x sin x is also very small.
For any small number u u u we may employ the binomial (or Taylor) expansion of ( 1 + u ) α (1+u)^{\alpha} ( 1 + u ) α :
( 1 + u ) α = 1 + α u + α ( α − 1 ) 2 u 2 + O ( u 3 ) . − ( 2 ) \displaystyle (1+u)^{\alpha}=1+\alpha\,u+\frac{\alpha(\alpha-1)}{2}\,u^{2}+O(u^{3}).-(2) ( 1 + u ) α = 1 + α u + 2 α ( α − 1 ) u 2 + O ( u 3 ) . − ( 2 )
Here α = 1 8 \alpha=\dfrac18 α = 8 1 .
Let us set
u 1 = − sin x , u 2 = + sin x . u_{1}=-\sin x,\qquad u_{2}=+\sin x. u 1 = − sin x , u 2 = + sin x . (3)
Applying (2) individually to the two eighth-root expressions gives
1 − sin x 8 = ( 1 + u 1 ) 1 / 8 = 1 + 1 8 u 1 + 1 8 ( 1 8 − 1 ) 2 u 1 2 + O ( u 1 3 ) , − ( 4 ) \sqrt[8]{1-\sin x}=(1+u_{1})^{1/8}=1+\frac18\,u_{1}+\frac{\dfrac18\!\left(\dfrac18-1\right)}2\,u_{1}^{2}+O(u_{1}^{3}),-(4) 8 1 − sin x = ( 1 + u 1 ) 1/8 = 1 + 8 1 u 1 + 2 8 1 ( 8 1 − 1 ) u 1 2 + O ( u 1 3 ) , − ( 4 )
1 + sin x 8 = ( 1 + u 2 ) 1 / 8 = 1 + 1 8 u 2 + 1 8 ( 1 8 − 1 ) 2 u 2 2 + O ( u 2 3 ) . − ( 5 ) \sqrt[8]{1+\sin x}=(1+u_{2})^{1/8}=1+\frac18\,u_{2}+\frac{\dfrac18\!\left(\dfrac18-1\right)}2\,u_{2}^{2}+O(u_{2}^{3}).-(5) 8 1 + sin x = ( 1 + u 2 ) 1/8 = 1 + 8 1 u 2 + 2 8 1 ( 8 1 − 1 ) u 2 2 + O ( u 2 3 ) . − ( 5 )
Because u 1 = − sin x u_{1}=-\sin x u 1 = − sin x and u 2 = + sin x u_{2}=+\sin x u 2 = + sin x , their second powers u 1 2 u_{1}^{2} u 1 2 and u 2 2 u_{2}^{2} u 2 2 are identical; hence those quadratic terms will cancel when we subtract (5) from (4).
Subtracting (5) from (4) we obtain
1 − sin x 8 − 1 + sin x 8 = [ 1 + 1 8 ( − sin x ) ] − [ 1 + 1 8 ( sin x ) ] + O ( ( sin x ) 3 ) . − ( 6 ) \sqrt[8]{1-\sin x}-\sqrt[8]{1+\sin x}=\left[1+\frac18(-\sin x)\right]-\left[1+\frac18(\sin x)\right]+O\!\left((\sin x)^{3}\right).-(6) 8 1 − sin x − 8 1 + sin x = [ 1 + 8 1 ( − sin x ) ] − [ 1 + 8 1 ( sin x ) ] + O ( ( sin x ) 3 ) . − ( 6 )
Simplifying (6):
1 − sin x 8 − 1 + sin x 8 = − 1 8 sin x − 1 8 sin x + O ( ( sin x ) 3 ) = − 1 4 sin x + O ( ( sin x ) 3 ) . − ( 7 ) \sqrt[8]{1-\sin x}-\sqrt[8]{1+\sin x}=-\frac18\sin x-\frac18\sin x+O\!\left((\sin x)^{3}\right)= -\frac14\,\sin x+O\!\left((\sin x)^{3}\right).-(7) 8 1 − sin x − 8 1 + sin x = − 8 1 sin x − 8 1 sin x + O ( ( sin x ) 3 ) = − 4 1 sin x + O ( ( sin x ) 3 ) . − ( 7 )
Near x = 0 x=0 x = 0 the dominant part of the denominator is therefore − 1 4 sin x -\dfrac14\sin x − 4 1 sin x .
Insert (7) into the original fraction (1):
x 1 − sin x 8 − 1 + sin x 8 = x − 1 4 sin x + O ( ( sin x ) 3 ) . − ( 8 ) \frac{x}{\sqrt[8]{1-\sin x}-\sqrt[8]{1+\sin x}}=\frac{x}{-\dfrac14\sin x+O\!\left((\sin x)^{3}\right)}. -(8) 8 1 − s i n x − 8 1 + s i n x x = − 4 1 s i n x + O ( ( s i n x ) 3 ) x . − ( 8 )
For very small x x x we may divide numerator and denominator by x x x , recalling that lim x → 0 sin x x = 1 \displaystyle\lim_{x\rightarrow 0}\frac{\sin x}{x}=1 x → 0 lim x sin x = 1 :
x − 1 4 sin x + O ( ( sin x ) 3 ) = x − 1 4 sin x [ 1 + O ( ( sin x ) 2 ) ] . − ( 9 ) \frac{x}{-\dfrac14\sin x+O\!\left((\sin x)^{3}\right)}=\frac{x}{-\dfrac14\sin x}\left[1+O\!\left((\sin x)^{2}\right)\right].-(9) − 4 1 s i n x + O ( ( s i n x ) 3 ) x = − 4 1 s i n x x [ 1 + O ( ( sin x ) 2 ) ] . − ( 9 )
The factor inside the square brackets in (9) approaches 1 1 1 as x → 0 x\rightarrow 0 x → 0 , so the limit becomes
L = lim x → 0 [ x − 1 4 sin x ] = lim x → 0 [ − 4 ⋅ x sin x ] = − 4 ⋅ 1 = − 4. ( 10 ) L=\lim_{x\rightarrow 0}\left[\frac{x}{-\dfrac14\sin x}\right]=\lim_{x\rightarrow 0}\left[-4\cdot\frac{x}{\sin x}\right]= -4\cdot 1 = -4.\;(10) L = lim x → 0 − 4 1 s i n x x = lim x → 0 [ − 4 ⋅ s i n x x ] = − 4 ⋅ 1 = − 4. ( 10 )
Hence, the correct answer is Option 3.