RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 11 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Limits of trigonometric functions

Let [x][x] denote the greatest integer less than or equal to x. Then: lim⁡x→0tan⁡(πsin⁡2x)+(∣x∣−sin⁡(x[x]))2x2\lim_{x \to 0} \frac{\tan(\pi \sin^2 x) + (|x| - \sin(x[x]))^2}{x^2}

SOLUTION

We have to find the value of

L=lim⁡x→0tan⁡ ⁣(πsin⁡2x)  +  (∣x∣−sin⁡(x[x]))2x2.L=\lim_{x\to 0}\frac{\tan\!\bigl(\pi\sin^{2}x\bigr)\;+\;\bigl(|x|-\sin(x[x])\bigr)^{2}}{x^{2}}.

The limit can exist only if the left-hand limit (LHL) and the right-hand limit (RHL) are equal. Because the greatest-integer function [x][x] behaves differently on (−1,0)(-1,0) and on (0,1)(0,1), we examine the two sides separately.

1. Preliminary expansions valid for both sides

The standard Maclaurin expansions are

sin⁡t=t−t36+O(t5),tan⁡y=y+y33+O(y5).\sin t=t-\dfrac{t^{3}}{6}+O(t^{5}),\qquad \tan y=y+\dfrac{y^{3}}{3}+O(y^{5}).

For small xx we first expand sin⁡2x\sin^{2}x:

sin⁡2x=(x−x36+O(x5))2=x2−x43+O(x6).\sin^{2}x=(x-\tfrac{x^{3}}{6}+O(x^{5}))^{2}=x^{2}-\dfrac{x^{4}}{3}+O(x^{6}).

Hence

πsin⁡2x=πx2−πx43+O(x6).\pi\sin^{2}x=\pi x^{2}-\dfrac{\pi x^{4}}{3}+O(x^{6}).

Putting this into the expansion of tan⁡\tan we obtain

tan⁡(πsin⁡2x)=(πx2−πx43+O(x6))+13(πx2)3+O(x8)=πx2+O(x4).\tan(\pi\sin^{2}x)=\Bigl(\pi x^{2}-\dfrac{\pi x^{4}}{3}+O(x^{6})\Bigr) +\dfrac{1}{3}\Bigl(\pi x^{2}\Bigr)^{3}+O(x^{8}) =\pi x^{2}+O(x^{4}).

Thus up to the order required for division by x2x^{2},

tan⁡(πsin⁡2x)=πx2+o(x2).−(1)\tan(\pi\sin^{2}x)=\pi x^{2}+o(x^{2}). \quad -(1)

2. Right-hand limit (x→0+x\to 0^{+})

When 0<x<10\lt x\lt 1 we have [x]=0.[x]=0. Therefore

sin⁡(x[x])=sin⁡(x⋅0)=sin⁡0=0,\sin(x[x])=\sin(x\cdot 0)=\sin 0=0,

and, since x>0x\gt 0, ∣x∣=x.|x|=x. So the second part of the numerator becomes

(∣x∣−sin⁡(x[x]))2=(x−0)2=x2.−(2)\bigl(|x|-\sin(x[x])\bigr)^{2}=(x-0)^{2}=x^{2}. \quad -(2)

Adding (1) and (2) we get the entire numerator:

tan⁡(πsin⁡2x)+(∣x∣−sin⁡(x[x]))2=(πx2+o(x2))+x2=(π+1)x2+o(x2).\tan(\pi\sin^{2}x)+\bigl(|x|-\sin(x[x])\bigr)^{2} =\bigl(\pi x^{2}+o(x^{2})\bigr)+x^{2} =(\pi+1)x^{2}+o(x^{2}).

Dividing by x2x^{2} gives the right-hand limit

RHL=π+1.\text{RHL}=\pi+1.

3. Left-hand limit (x→0−x\to 0^{-})

For −1<x<0-1\lt x\lt 0 we have [x]=−1.[x]=-1. Because xx is negative, ∣x∣=−x.|x|=-x. Also,

sin⁡(x[x])=sin⁡(x⋅(−1))=sin⁡(−x)=−sin⁡x.\sin(x[x])=\sin\bigl(x\cdot(-1)\bigr)=\sin(-x)=-\sin x.

Hence

∣x∣−sin⁡(x[x])=−x−(−sin⁡x)=−x+sin⁡x.−(3)|x|-\sin(x[x])=-x-(-\sin x)=-x+\sin x. \quad -(3)

Using sin⁡x=x−x36+O(x5)\sin x=x-\dfrac{x^{3}}{6}+O(x^{5}) we obtain

−x+sin⁡x=−x+(x−x36+O(x5))=−x36+O(x5).-x+\sin x=-x+\Bigl(x-\dfrac{x^{3}}{6}+O(x^{5})\Bigr) =-\dfrac{x^{3}}{6}+O(x^{5}).

Squaring,

(∣x∣−sin⁡(x[x]))2=(−x36+O(x5))2=x636+O(x8).−(4)\bigl(|x|-\sin(x[x])\bigr)^{2}=\Bigl(-\dfrac{x^{3}}{6}+O(x^{5})\Bigr)^{2} =\dfrac{x^{6}}{36}+O(x^{8}). \quad -(4)

This is of order x6x^{6} and hence negligible compared with the x2x^{2} term we shall divide by.

From (1) and (4) the whole numerator on the left side is

tan⁡(πsin⁡2x)+(∣x∣−sin⁡(x[x]))2=πx2+o(x2).\tan(\pi\sin^{2}x)+\bigl(|x|-\sin(x[x])\bigr)^{2} =\pi x^{2}+o(x^{2}).

Therefore the left-hand limit is

LHL=π.\text{LHL}=\pi.

4. Comparison of the two sides

RHL=π+1,LHL=π.\text{RHL}=\pi+1,\qquad \text{LHL}=\pi.

Since RHL≠LHL,\text{RHL}\neq\text{LHL}, the limit as x→0x\to 0 does not exist.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Limits of trigonometric functions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

ChapterLimits
TopicLimits of trigonometric functions
TypeMultiple choice