We have the rectangular hyperbola in standard form
x 2 9 − y 2 4 = 1 \frac{x^{2}}{9}-\frac{y^{2}}{4}=1 9 x 2 − 4 y 2 = 1
whose semi-transverse axis is a = 3 a=3 a = 3 and semi-conjugate axis is b = 2 b=2 b = 2 .
For this curve the standard parametric equations are
x = a sec α , y = b tan α . x=a\sec\alpha,\qquad y=b\tan\alpha. x = a sec α , y = b tan α .
Hence the points
P ( 3 sec θ , 2 tan θ ) , Q ( 3 sec ϕ , 2 tan ϕ ) P\;(3\sec\theta,\,2\tan\theta),\qquad
Q\;(3\sec\phi,\,2\tan\phi) P ( 3 sec θ , 2 tan θ ) , Q ( 3 sec ϕ , 2 tan ϕ )
indeed lie on the hyperbola. It is given that
θ + ϕ = π 2 . \theta+\phi=\frac{\pi}{2}. θ + ϕ = 2 π .
To find the intersection of the normals at these two points, we first write the
slope of the normal at a general point.
The hyperbola is represented by
F ( x , y ) = x 2 9 − y 2 4 − 1 = 0. F(x,y)=\frac{x^{2}}{9}-\frac{y^{2}}{4}-1=0. F ( x , y ) = 9 x 2 − 4 y 2 − 1 = 0.
Differentiating implicitly with respect to x x x ,
2 x 9 − 2 y 4 d y d x = 0 ⟹ d y d x = 4 x 9 y . \frac{2x}{9}-\frac{2y}{4}\,\frac{dy}{dx}=0
\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;\frac{dy}{dx}=\frac{4x}{9y}. 9 2 x − 4 2 y d x d y = 0 ⟹ d x d y = 9 y 4 x .
Thus the slope of the tangent at ( x , y ) (x,y) ( x , y ) is m t = 4 x 9 y m_t=\dfrac{4x}{9y} m t = 9 y 4 x ,
and the slope of the normal is the negative reciprocal:
m n = − 1 m t = − 9 y 4 x . m_n=-\frac{1}{m_t}=-\frac{9y}{4x}. m n = − m t 1 = − 4 x 9 y .
Applying this to the two parametric points:
For P ( 3 sec θ , 2 tan θ ) : P(3\sec\theta,2\tan\theta): P ( 3 sec θ , 2 tan θ ) :
m P = − 9 ( 2 tan θ ) 4 ( 3 sec θ ) = − 18 tan θ 12 sec θ = − 3 tan θ 2 sec θ = − 3 sin θ 2 . m_P=-\frac{9(2\tan\theta)}{4(3\sec\theta)}
=-\frac{18\tan\theta}{12\sec\theta}
=-\frac{3\tan\theta}{2\sec\theta}
=-\frac{3\sin\theta}{2}. m P = − 4 ( 3 s e c θ ) 9 ( 2 t a n θ ) = − 12 s e c θ 18 t a n θ = − 2 s e c θ 3 t a n θ = − 2 3 s i n θ .
For Q ( 3 sec ϕ , 2 tan ϕ ) : Q(3\sec\phi,2\tan\phi): Q ( 3 sec ϕ , 2 tan ϕ ) :
m Q = − 9 ( 2 tan ϕ ) 4 ( 3 sec ϕ ) = − 3 tan ϕ 2 sec ϕ = − 3 sin ϕ 2 . m_Q=-\frac{9(2\tan\phi)}{4(3\sec\phi)}
=-\frac{3\tan\phi}{2\sec\phi}
=-\frac{3\sin\phi}{2}. m Q = − 4 ( 3 s e c ϕ ) 9 ( 2 t a n ϕ ) = − 2 s e c ϕ 3 t a n ϕ = − 2 3 s i n ϕ .
Now we write the equations of the two normals.
Through P ( 3 sec θ , 2 tan θ ) : P(3\sec\theta,2\tan\theta): P ( 3 sec θ , 2 tan θ ) :
y − 2 tan θ = m P ( x − 3 sec θ ) . y-2\tan\theta=m_P\bigl(x-3\sec\theta\bigr). y − 2 tan θ = m P ( x − 3 sec θ ) .
Through Q ( 3 sec ϕ , 2 tan ϕ ) : Q(3\sec\phi,2\tan\phi): Q ( 3 sec ϕ , 2 tan ϕ ) :
y − 2 tan ϕ = m Q ( x − 3 sec ϕ ) . y-2\tan\phi=m_Q\bigl(x-3\sec\phi\bigr). y − 2 tan ϕ = m Q ( x − 3 sec ϕ ) .
Re-arranging each into the slope-intercept form y = m x + c y=mx+c y = m x + c :
For P P P (putting m 1 = m P m_1=m_P m 1 = m P ):
y = m 1 x + ( 2 tan θ − 3 m 1 sec θ ) ⏟ c 1 . y=m_1x+\underbrace{\bigl(2\tan\theta-3m_1\sec\theta\bigr)}_{c_1}. y = m 1 x + c 1 ( 2 tan θ − 3 m 1 sec θ ) . $
For Q Q Q (putting m 2 = m Q m_2=m_Q m 2 = m Q ):
y = m 2 x + ( 2 tan ϕ − 3 m 2 sec ϕ ) ⏟ c 2 . y=m_2x+\underbrace{\bigl(2\tan\phi-3m_2\sec\phi\bigr)}_{c_2}. y = m 2 x + c 2 ( 2 tan ϕ − 3 m 2 sec ϕ ) . $
Let us evaluate the two intercepts explicitly.
Because m 1 = − 3 sin θ 2 m_1=-\dfrac{3\sin\theta}{2} m 1 = − 2 3 sin θ ,
c 1 = 2 tan θ − 3 m 1 sec θ = 2 sin θ cos θ − 3 ( − 3 sin θ 2 ) 1 cos θ = 4 sin θ cos θ + 9 sin θ 2 cos θ = 13 sin θ 2 cos θ = 13 2 tan θ . c_1=2\tan\theta-3m_1\sec\theta
=2\frac{\sin\theta}{\cos\theta}
-3\Bigl(-\frac{3\sin\theta}{2}\Bigr)\frac{1}{\cos\theta}
=\frac{4\sin\theta}{\cos\theta}+\frac{9\sin\theta}{2\cos\theta}
=\frac{13\sin\theta}{2\cos\theta}
=\frac{13}{2}\tan\theta. c 1 = 2 tan θ − 3 m 1 sec θ = 2 c o s θ s i n θ − 3 ( − 2 3 s i n θ ) c o s θ 1 = c o s θ 4 s i n θ + 2 c o s θ 9 s i n θ = 2 c o s θ 13 s i n θ = 2 13 tan θ . $
Similarly, with m 2 = − 3 sin ϕ 2 m_2=-\dfrac{3\sin\phi}{2} m 2 = − 2 3 sin ϕ ,
c 2 = 2 tan ϕ − 3 m 2 sec ϕ = 13 2 tan ϕ . c_2=2\tan\phi-3m_2\sec\phi
=\frac{13}{2}\tan\phi. c 2 = 2 tan ϕ − 3 m 2 sec ϕ = 2 13 tan ϕ . $
The intersection of the two straight lines
y = m 1 x + c 1 , y = m 2 x + c 2 y=m_1x+c_1,\qquad y=m_2x+c_2 y = m 1 x + c 1 , y = m 2 x + c 2
has ordinates obtained from the determinant formula
Y = m 1 c 2 − m 2 c 1 m 1 − m 2 . Y=\frac{m_1c_2-m_2c_1}{m_1-m_2}. Y = m 1 − m 2 m 1 c 2 − m 2 c 1 .
Substituting the explicit expressions,
Y = m 1 ( 13 2 tan ϕ ) − m 2 ( 13 2 tan θ ) m 1 − m 2 = 13 2 m 1 tan ϕ − m 2 tan θ m 1 − m 2 . Y=\frac{\displaystyle m_1\Bigl(\frac{13}{2}\tan\phi\Bigr)
-m_2\Bigl(\frac{13}{2}\tan\theta\Bigr)}
{m_1-m_2}
=\frac{13}{2}\;
\frac{m_1\tan\phi-m_2\tan\theta}{m_1-m_2}. Y = m 1 − m 2 m 1 ( 2 13 tan ϕ ) − m 2 ( 2 13 tan θ ) = 2 13 m 1 − m 2 m 1 t a n ϕ − m 2 t a n θ . $
Insert the values m 1 = − 3 sin θ 2 , m 2 = − 3 sin ϕ 2 m_1=-\dfrac{3\sin\theta}{2},\;
m_2=-\dfrac{3\sin\phi}{2} m 1 = − 2 3 sin θ , m 2 = − 2 3 sin ϕ :
m 1 tan ϕ = − 3 sin θ 2 sin ϕ cos ϕ = − 3 sin θ sin ϕ 2 cos ϕ , m_1\tan\phi=-\frac{3\sin\theta}{2}\,\frac{\sin\phi}{\cos\phi}
=-\frac{3\sin\theta\sin\phi}{2\cos\phi}, m 1 tan ϕ = − 2 3 s i n θ c o s ϕ s i n ϕ = − 2 c o s ϕ 3 s i n θ s i n ϕ , $
m 2 tan θ = − 3 sin ϕ 2 sin θ cos θ = − 3 sin ϕ sin θ 2 cos θ . m_2\tan\theta=-\frac{3\sin\phi}{2}\,\frac{\sin\theta}{\cos\theta}
=-\frac{3\sin\phi\sin\theta}{2\cos\theta}. m 2 tan θ = − 2 3 s i n ϕ c o s θ s i n θ = − 2 c o s θ 3 s i n ϕ s i n θ . $
Therefore
m 1 tan ϕ − m 2 tan θ = − 3 sin θ sin ϕ 2 ( 1 cos ϕ − 1 cos θ ) . m_1\tan\phi-m_2\tan\theta
=-\frac{3\sin\theta\sin\phi}{2}\Bigl(\frac{1}{\cos\phi}-\frac{1}{\cos\theta}\Bigr). m 1 tan ϕ − m 2 tan θ = − 2 3 s i n θ s i n ϕ ( c o s ϕ 1 − c o s θ 1 ) . $
And
m 1 − m 2 = − 3 sin θ 2 + 3 sin ϕ 2 = 3 2 ( sin ϕ − sin θ ) . m_1-m_2=-\frac{3\sin\theta}{2}+\frac{3\sin\phi}{2}
=\frac{3}{2}\bigl(\sin\phi-\sin\theta\bigr). m 1 − m 2 = − 2 3 s i n θ + 2 3 s i n ϕ = 2 3 ( sin ϕ − sin θ ) . $
Substituting back,
Y = 13 2 − 3 sin θ sin ϕ 2 ( 1 cos ϕ − 1 cos θ ) 3 2 ( sin ϕ − sin θ ) = − 13 2 sin θ sin ϕ ( 1 cos ϕ − 1 cos θ ) cos θ cos ϕ ( sin ϕ − sin θ cos θ cos ϕ ) = − 13 2 sin θ sin ϕ ( cos θ − cos ϕ ) cos θ cos ϕ ( sin ϕ − sin θ ) . Y=\frac{13}{2}\;
\frac{\displaystyle
-\dfrac{3\sin\theta\sin\phi}{2}
\Bigl(\dfrac{1}{\cos\phi}-\dfrac{1}{\cos\theta}\Bigr)}
{\displaystyle \dfrac{3}{2}\,(\sin\phi-\sin\theta)}
=-\frac{13}{2}\,
\frac{\sin\theta\sin\phi\;\bigl(\frac{1}{\cos\phi}-\frac{1}{\cos\theta}\bigr)}
{\cos\theta\cos\phi\;(\, \frac{\sin\phi-\sin\theta}{\cos\theta\cos\phi}\,)}
=-\frac{13}{2}\,
\frac{\sin\theta\sin\phi\;(\cos\theta-\cos\phi)}
{\cos\theta\cos\phi\;(\sin\phi-\sin\theta)}. Y = 2 13 2 3 ( sin ϕ − sin θ ) − 2 3 sin θ sin ϕ ( cos ϕ 1 − cos θ 1 ) = − 2 13 c o s θ c o s ϕ ( c o s θ c o s ϕ s i n ϕ − s i n θ ) s i n θ s i n ϕ ( c o s ϕ 1 − c o s θ 1 ) = − 2 13 c o s θ c o s ϕ ( s i n ϕ − s i n θ ) s i n θ s i n ϕ ( c o s θ − c o s ϕ ) . $
At this point we employ the crucial relation θ + ϕ = π 2 \theta+\phi=\dfrac{\pi}{2} θ + ϕ = 2 π , which implies
sin ϕ = cos θ , cos ϕ = sin θ . \sin\phi=\cos\theta,\qquad \cos\phi=\sin\theta. sin ϕ = cos θ , cos ϕ = sin θ .
Putting these into the last expression, every factor cancels:
Y = − 13 2 ( sin θ ) ( cos θ ) ( cos θ − sin θ ) ( cos θ ) ( sin θ ) ( cos θ − sin θ ) = − 13 2 . Y=-\frac{13}{2}\,
\frac{(\sin\theta)(\cos\theta)\;(\cos\theta-\sin\theta)}
{(\cos\theta)(\sin\theta)\;(\cos\theta-\sin\theta)}
=-\frac{13}{2}. Y = − 2 13 ( c o s θ ) ( s i n θ ) ( c o s θ − s i n θ ) ( s i n θ ) ( c o s θ ) ( c o s θ − s i n θ ) = − 2 13 . $
Thus the ordinate (the y y y -coordinate) of the point where the two normals meet is
Y = − 13 2 . Y=-\frac{13}{2}. Y = − 2 13 .
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.