RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 27 JUL S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Mathematics question — Functional equations

Let f:R→Rf : R \rightarrow R be defined as f(x+y)+f(x−y)=2f(x)f(y)f(x + y) + f(x - y) = 2f(x)f(y), f(12)=−1f\left(\frac{1}{2}\right) = -1. Then the value of ∑k=1201sin⁡(k)sin⁡(k+f(k))\sum_{k=1}^{20} \frac{1}{\sin(k)\sin(k + f(k))} is equal to:

SOLUTION

We begin with the functional equation

f(x+y)+f(x−y)=2f(x)f(y)(1)f(x+y)+f(x-y)=2f(x)f(y)\qquad\qquad (1)

This is exactly the same relation that the cosine function satisfies, because we know the standard identity

cos⁡(α+β)+cos⁡(α−β)=2cos⁡αcos⁡β.\cos(\alpha+\beta)+\cos(\alpha-\beta)=2\cos\alpha\cos\beta.

Motivated by this similarity, we try the trial form f(x)=cos⁡(ax)f(x)=\cos(ax) for some real constant aa. Substituting this trial form in (1) gives

cos⁡(a(x+y))+cos⁡(a(x−y))=2cos⁡(ax)cos⁡(ay),\cos\bigl(a(x+y)\bigr)+\cos\bigl(a(x-y)\bigr)=2\cos(ax)\cos(ay),

which is an identity that is always true for every real aa. Hence every function of the shape f(x)=cos⁡(ax)f(x)=\cos(ax) satisfies (1).

Because the domain and range are both the entire set of real numbers and we have the extra data f ⁣(12)=−1,f\!\left(\dfrac12\right)=-1, we impose this condition:

f ⁣(12)=cos⁡ ⁣(a⋅12)=cos⁡ ⁣(a2)=−1.f\!\left(\dfrac12\right)=\cos\!\left(a\cdot\dfrac12\right)=\cos\!\left(\dfrac a2\right)=-1.

The cosine of an angle equals −1-1 precisely when that angle equals an odd multiple of π\pi. Hence

a2=(2n+1)π⟹a=2(2n+1)π=(4n+2)π,n∈Z.\frac a2=(2n+1)\pi\quad\Longrightarrow\quad a=2(2n+1)\pi=(4n+2)\pi,\qquad n\in\mathbb Z.

Choosing the smallest positive value (take n=0n=0) gives a=2πa=2\pi, so from here on we work with

f(x)=cos⁡(2πx).f(x)=\cos(2\pi x).

Now we turn to the required sum

S=∑k=1201sin⁡(k) sin⁡(k+f(k)).S=\sum_{k=1}^{20}\frac1{\sin(k)\,\sin\bigl(k+f(k)\bigr)}.

For every integer kk we have f(k)=cos⁡(2πk)=1,f(k)=\cos(2\pi k)=1, because the cosine of any integral multiple of 2π2\pi is 11. Therefore

S=∑k=1201sin⁡k sin⁡(k+1).S=\sum_{k=1}^{20}\frac1{\sin k\,\sin(k+1)}.

To simplify each term we invoke the well-known cotangent difference identity. First we write the identity itself:

cot⁡A−cot⁡B=sin⁡(B−A)sin⁡A  sin⁡B.\cot A-\cot B=\frac{\sin(B-A)}{\sin A\;\sin B}.

Putting B=A+1B=A+1 (remember that our angles are measured in radians) we obtain

cot⁡A−cot⁡(A+1)=sin⁡ ⁣((A+1)−A)sin⁡A  sin⁡(A+1)=sin⁡1sin⁡A  sin⁡(A+1).\cot A-\cot(A+1)=\frac{\sin\!\bigl((A+1)-A\bigr)}{\sin A\;\sin(A+1)} =\frac{\sin 1}{\sin A\;\sin(A+1)}.

Solving this for the required reciprocal product gives

1sin⁡A  sin⁡(A+1)=cot⁡A−cot⁡(A+1)sin⁡1.\frac1{\sin A\;\sin(A+1)}=\frac{\cot A-\cot(A+1)}{\sin 1}.

Applying this to each term of SS with A=kA=k, we have

S=∑k=120cot⁡k−cot⁡(k+1)sin⁡1=1sin⁡1∑k=120(cot⁡k−cot⁡(k+1)).S=\sum_{k=1}^{20}\frac{\cot k-\cot(k+1)}{\sin 1} =\frac1{\sin 1}\sum_{k=1}^{20}\bigl(\cot k-\cot(k+1)\bigr).

Observe that the sum telescopes:

∑k=120(cot⁡k−cot⁡(k+1))=(cot⁡1−cot⁡2)+(cot⁡2−cot⁡3)+⋯+(cot⁡20−cot⁡21)=cot⁡1−cot⁡21.\sum_{k=1}^{20}\bigl(\cot k-\cot(k+1)\bigr) =(\cot1-\cot2)+(\cot2-\cot3)+\dots+(\cot20-\cot21)=\cot1-\cot21.

Thus

S=cot⁡1−cot⁡21sin⁡1.S=\frac{\cot1-\cot21}{\sin1}.

Next we rewrite the cotangents in terms of sines and cosines:

S=cos⁡1sin⁡1−cos⁡21sin⁡21sin⁡1=cos⁡1sin⁡21−cos⁡21sin⁡1 sin⁡21.S=\frac{\dfrac{\cos1}{\sin1}-\dfrac{\cos21}{\sin21}}{\sin1} =\frac{\cos1}{\sin^{2}1}-\frac{\cos21}{\sin1\,\sin21}.

To combine the two fractions we place them over the common denominator sin⁡21 sin⁡21\sin^{2}1\,\sin21:

S=cos⁡1 sin⁡21−cos⁡21 sin⁡1sin⁡21 sin⁡21.S=\frac{\cos1\,\sin21-\cos21\,\sin1}{\sin^{2}1\,\sin21}.

The numerator is exactly the sine of a difference, because

sin⁡(b−a)=sin⁡bcos⁡a−cos⁡bsin⁡a,\sin(b-a)=\sin b\cos a-\cos b\sin a,

so with b=21b=21 and a=1a=1 we have

cos⁡1 sin⁡21−cos⁡21 sin⁡1=sin⁡(21−1)=sin⁡20.\cos1\,\sin21-\cos21\,\sin1=\sin(21-1)=\sin20.

Hence the sum becomes

S=sin⁡20sin⁡21 sin⁡21.S=\frac{\sin20}{\sin^{2}1\,\sin21}.

Now we rewrite the denominator in cosecant notation. Remembering that cosec⁡θ=1sin⁡θ,\cosec\theta=\dfrac1{\sin\theta}, we have

1sin⁡21 sin⁡21=cosec⁡21  cosec⁡21.\frac1{\sin^{2}1\,\sin21}=\cosec^{2}1\;\cosec21.

Therefore

S=cosec⁡2(1)  cosec⁡(21)  sin⁡(20).S=\cosec^{2}(1)\;\cosec(21)\;\sin(20).

Looking at the given options, this matches exactly with Option C.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Functional equations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

ChapterFunctions
TopicFunctional equations
TypeMultiple choice