We have the function f(x)=x2 defined for every real number x.
For any subset A⊆R, we are told to define
g(A)={x∈R:f(x)∈A}.
This means g(A) is the set of all real numbers whose squares belong to the set A; in other words, g(A) is the pre-image of A under the squaring function.
Now let us fix the set S=[0,4]. We shall compute the four quantities that occur in the options one by one.
First we find f(S).
Every number in S satisfies 0≤x≤4. Squaring preserves order for non-negative numbers, so
02≤x2≤42⟹0≤x2≤16.
Hence
f(S)={x2:x∈[0,4]}=[0,16].
Next we find g(S).
By definition,
g(S)={x∈R:f(x)∈S}={x∈R:x2∈[0,4]}.
The condition x2∈[0,4] means
0≤x2≤4.
Taking square roots gives ∣x∣≤2, which is equivalent to
−2≤x≤2.
Therefore
g(S)=[−2,2].
Now we compute f(g(S)).
We already know g(S)=[−2,2]. Applying f(x)=x2 to every number in this interval, we obtain
f(g(S))={x2:x∈[−2,2]}.
The smallest value of x2 on [−2,2] is 02=0, and the largest value is 22=4. Hence
f(g(S))=[0,4].
Observe that [0,4]=S, so
f(g(S))=S.
Next we compute g(f(S)).
We already showed f(S)=[0,16]. By definition,
g(f(S))={x∈R:x2∈[0,16]}.
The condition x2≤16 is equivalent to ∣x∣≤4, that is
−4≤x≤4.
Hence
g(f(S))=[−4,4].
Finally we compare the sets obtained so far.
We have
S=[0,4],f(S)=[0,16],g(S)=[−2,2],f(g(S))=[0,4],g(f(S))=[−4,4].
Let us examine each option.
Option A states g(f(S))=S. Since g(f(S))=[−4,4] and S=[0,4], the two intervals differ (for example, −2∈[−4,4] but −2∈/[0,4]). Therefore the inequality is correct; Option A is a true statement.
Option B states f(g(S))=f(S). We found f(g(S))=[0,4] whereas f(S)=[0,16], so they are indeed unequal. Thus Option B is also true.
Option C asserts f(g(S))=S. We have already proved f(g(S))=[0,4]=S, so Option C is true.
Option D asserts g(f(S))=g(S). But g(f(S))=[−4,4] while g(S)=[−2,2]; these two sets are not equal because, for instance, 3∈[−4,4] but 3∈/[−2,2]. Hence Option D is false.
Because the question asks for the statement that is not true, we conclude that Option D is the required choice.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.