RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 25 JUL S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Mathematics question — Tangents to an ellipse

If a tangent to the ellipse x2+4y2=4x^2 + 4y^2 = 4 meets the tangents at the extremities of its major axis at BB and CC, then the circle with BCBC as diameter passes through the point.

SOLUTION

We begin with the ellipse

x2+4y2=4.x^{2}+4y^{2}=4.

It can be rewritten as x24+y21=1,\dfrac{x^{2}}{4}+\dfrac{y^{2}}{1}=1, so we have

a2=4,b2=1,a=2,b=1.a^{2}=4,\qquad b^{2}=1,\qquad a=2,\qquad b=1.

Because a>b,a\gt b, the major axis is the xx-axis and its extremities are the end points

A1(2,0)andA2(−2,0).A_{1}(2,0)\quad\text{and}\quad A_{2}(-2,0).

For an ellipse x2a2+y2b2=1,\dfrac{x^{2}}{a^{2}}+\dfrac{y^{2}}{b^{2}}=1, the tangent at a point (x1,y1)(x_{1},y_{1}) is

xx1a2+yy1b2=1.\dfrac{xx_{1}}{a^{2}}+\dfrac{yy_{1}}{b^{2}}=1.

At (2,0)(2,0) this gives x⋅24=1  ⟹  x=2,\dfrac{x\cdot2}{4}=1\;\Longrightarrow\;x=2, and at (−2,0)(-2,0) it gives x(−2)4=1  ⟹  x=−2.\dfrac{x(-2)}{4}=1\;\Longrightarrow\;x=-2.

Thus the tangents at the extremities of the major axis are the two vertical lines

x=2andx=−2.x=2\qquad\text{and}\qquad x=-2.

Now let us draw an arbitrary tangent to the ellipse that has slope mm. For the ellipse in slope form the tangent is

y=mx±a2m2+b2,y=mx\pm\sqrt{a^{2}m^{2}+b^{2}},

and with a2=4,  b2=1a^{2}=4,\;b^{2}=1 this becomes

y=mx±4m2+1.y=mx\pm\sqrt{4m^{2}+1}.

Denote the quantity D=4m2+1,D>0.D=\sqrt{4m^{2}+1},\qquad D\gt 0.

Choosing the ‘++’ sign (the ‘−-’ sign gives the same straight line shifted in yy by an overall minus and therefore the same pair of points B,CB,C), the tangent is

y=mx+D.y=mx+D.

We next find its intersections with the two fixed vertical lines.

Intersection with x=2x=2 :

Substitute x=2x=2 in y=mx+Dy=mx+D to obtain

yB=m⋅2+D=2m+D.y_{B}=m\cdot2+D=2m+D.

Hence B(2,  2m+D).B(2,\;2m+D).

Intersection with x=−2x=-2 :

Substitute x=−2x=-2 to get

yC=m(−2)+D=−2m+D.y_{C}=m(-2)+D=-2m+D.

Hence C(−2,  −2m+D).C(-2,\;-2m+D).

Thus the endpoints of segment BCBC are

B(2,  2m+D),C(−2,  −2m+D).B(2,\;2m+D),\qquad C(-2,\;-2m+D).

We must study the circle having BCBC as its diameter. A very useful fact is the following:

For a segment with endpoints (x1,y1)(x_{1},y_{1}) and (x2,y2)(x_{2},y_{2}), a point (x,y)(x,y) lies on the circle with that segment as diameter if and only if

(x−x1)(x−x2)+(y−y1)(y−y2)=0.(x-x_{1})(x-x_{2})+(y-y_{1})(y-y_{2})=0.

This is simply the algebraic translation of “∠BPC\angle BPC is a right angle” (the dot‐product of the vectors PB→\overrightarrow{PB} and PC→\overrightarrow{PC} must be zero).

Applying the criterion with B(2,2m+D)B(2,2m+D) and C(−2,−2m+D)C(-2,-2m+D), we get that a point P(x,y)P(x,y) will be on the required circle iff

(x−2)(x+2)+(y−(2m+D))(y−(−2m+D))=0.\bigl(x-2\bigr)\bigl(x+2\bigr)+\bigl(y-(2m+D)\bigr)\bigl(y-(-2m+D)\bigr)=0.$

The first bracket simplifies immediately:

(x−2)(x+2)=x2−4.(x-2)(x+2)=x^{2}-4.

For the second product we write the two subtractions explicitly and use the identity (A−B)(A+B)=A2−B2(A-B)(A+B)=A^{2}-B^{2}:

(y−2m−D)(y+2m−D)=(y−D−2m)(y−D+2m)=(y−D)2−(2m)2=(y−D)2−4m2.\begin{aligned} (y-2m-D)(y+2m-D) &=(y-D-2m)(y-D+2m)\\ &=(y-D)^{2}-(2m)^{2}\\ &=(y-D)^{2}-4m^{2}. \end{aligned}$

Putting both parts together, the condition for P(x,y)P(x,y) becomes

x2−4+(y−D)2−4m2=0.−(★)x^{2}-4+\bigl(y-D\bigr)^{2}-4m^{2}=0. \quad -(★)

We now check each of the four option points one by one. Remember that D=4m2+1.D=\sqrt{4m^{2}+1}.

Option A (3,0)\bigl(\sqrt{3},0\bigr) :

Insert x=3,  y=0x=\sqrt{3},\;y=0 into (★).

First term: x2−4=(3)2−4=3−4=−1.x^{2}-4=(\sqrt{3})^{2}-4=3-4=-1.

Second term: (y−D)2=(0−D)2=D2=4m2+1.\bigl(y-D\bigr)^{2}=(0-D)^{2}=D^{2}=4m^{2}+1.

Hence the left side of (★) is

−1+(4m2+1)−4m2=0.-1+(4m^{2}+1)-4m^{2}=0.$

It is identically zero for every real value of the slope mm. Therefore the point (3,0)(\sqrt{3},0) always lies on the circle whose diameter is BCBC.

Option B (2,0)\bigl(\sqrt{2},0\bigr) :

Put x=2,  y=0x=\sqrt{2},\;y=0 in (★).

x2−4=2−4=−2x^{2}-4=2-4=-2.

Second term remains D2=4m2+1D^{2}=4m^{2}+1.

Total −2+(4m2+1)−4m2=−1≠0,-2+(4m^{2}+1)-4m^{2}=-1\neq0, so (2,0)(\sqrt{2},0) is not on the required circle.

Option C (1,1)(1,1) :

x2−4=1−4=−3.x^{2}-4=1-4=-3.

(y−D)2=(1−D)2=1−2D+D2=1−2D+4m2+1=2−2D+4m2.(y-D)^{2}=(1-D)^{2}=1-2D+D^{2}=1-2D+4m^{2}+1=2-2D+4m^{2}.

Total −3+(2−2D+4m2)−4m2=−1−2D≠0.-3+\bigl(2-2D+4m^{2}\bigr)-4m^{2}=-1-2D\neq0.

So (1,1)(1,1) is not on the circle.

Option D (−1,1)(-1,1) :

x2−4=1−4=−3.x^{2}-4=1-4=-3.

(y−D)2=(1−D)2(y-D)^{2}=(1-D)^{2} is the same as above, giving 2−2D+4m2.2-2D+4m^{2}.

Total −3+(2−2D+4m2)−4m2=−1−2D≠0.-3+\bigl(2-2D+4m^{2}\bigr)-4m^{2}=-1-2D\neq0.

Therefore (−1,1)(-1,1) is also excluded.

Only the first option satisfies the circle condition for every tangent, so the circle with BCBC as diameter always passes through the point (3,0)(\sqrt{3},0).

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Tangents to an ellipse. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

ChapterEllipse
TopicTangents to an ellipse
TypeMultiple choice