First we examine the numerator. For large n the sum of powers can be expanded by the Euler-Maclaurin (or simply the integral) approximation:
1a+2a+…+na=a+1na+1+2na+O(na−1)−(2)
Only the two leading terms are written because every later term will contain a lower power of n and will vanish after division by the denominator which will also be of order na+1.
Next we handle the bracketed sum in the denominator. The terms inside form an arithmetic progression whose first term is na+1 and last term is na+n with common difference 1. For an arithmetic progression of n terms, the sum equals half the number of terms multiplied by the sum of the extreme terms, therefore
(na+1)+(na+2)+…+(na+n)=2n[(na+1)+(na+n)]−(3)
Simplifying the bracket inside (3):
(na+1)+(na+n)=2na+n+1=n(2a+1)+1−(4)
Putting (4) into (3) we get
(na+1)+…+(na+n)=2n[n(2a+1)+1]
=2n2(2a+1)+2n−(5)
Now multiply this by the factor (n+1)a−1 appearing in the denominator of (1). Write (n+1)a−1 in powers of n by the binomial expansion for large n:
(n+1)a−1=na−1(1+n1)a−1=na−1[1+na−1+O(n21)]−(6)
Combining (5) and (6), the entire denominator becomes
[(n+1)a−1][(na+1)+…+(na+n)]
=na−1[1+na−1+O(n21)][2n2(2a+1)+2n]−(7)
In (7) factor out the highest power of n, namely na+1, and collect the numerical coefficient:
=na+122a+1[1+na−1+O(n1)][1+n(2a+1)1]
=na+122a+1[1+O(n1)]−(8)
Thus, to the leading order
[(n+1)a−1][(na+1)+…+(na+n)]=22a+1na+1+O(na)−(9)
Now we take the ratio appearing in (1). Using the leading terms from (2) and (9) we have
(n+1)a−1[(na+1)+…+(na+n)]1a+2a+…+na
=22a+1na+1+O(na)a+1na+1+O(na)−(10)
Divide the numerator and denominator of the right-hand side of (10) by na+1 to obtain the finite limit:
=22a+1+O(n1)a+11+O(n1)−(11)
As n→∞ all the O(n1) terms vanish, leaving
L=22a+1a+11=(a+1)(2a+1)2−(12)
The problem statement tells us that this limit equals 601, so equate (12) to that value:
(a+1)(2a+1)2=601−(13)
Cross-multiplying in (13):
2⋅60=(a+1)(2a+1)
120=(a+1)(2a+1)−(14)
Expand the product in (14):
(a+1)(2a+1)=2a2+a+2a+1=2a2+3a+1−(15)
Hence (14) becomes the quadratic equation
2a2+3a+1−120=0
2a2+3a−119=0−(16)
Use the quadratic formula for ax2+bx+c=0, where a=2, b=3, c=−119:
a=2a−b±b2−4ac=2⋅2−3±32−4⋅2⋅(−119)−(17)
The discriminant evaluates to
32−4⋅2⋅(−119)=9+952=961−(18)
Since 961=31, substitute back in (17):
a=4−3±31−(19)
This gives two possible values:
a=4−3+31=428=7ora=4−3−31=4−34=−8.5−(20)
The question specifies that a is a positive real number, therefore we discard the negative root and accept
a=7−(21)
Looking at the options, Option 3 corresponds to the value 7.
Hence, the correct answer is Option 3.
Tagged Definite integral as limit of a sum. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.