RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 08 APR S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Differentiability at a point

Let f:R→Rf: R \rightarrow R be a differentiable function satisfying f′(3)+f′(2)=0f'(3) + f'(2) = 0. Then lim⁡x→01+f(3+x)−f(3)1+f(2−x)−f(2)1x\lim_{x \to 0} \frac{1 + f(3 + x) - f(3)}{1 + f(2 - x) - f(2)}^{\frac{1}{x}} is equal to:

SOLUTION

We have a differentiable function f:  R→Rf:\; \mathbb R \to \mathbb R which satisfies f′(3)+f′(2)=0.f'(3)+f'(2)=0.

We are asked to evaluate

lim⁡x→0(1+f(3+x)−f(3)1+f(2−x)−f(2))1x.\displaystyle \lim_{x\to 0}\Bigg(\frac{1+f(3+x)-f(3)}{1+f(2-x)-f(2)}\Bigg)^{\frac1x}.

Because the limit concerns a quotient whose terms approach 11, it is natural to expand each term in the numerator and the denominator by the first-order Taylor formula.

Formula stated: For a differentiable function gg at a point aa,

g(a+h)=g(a)+g′(a) h+o(h)as h→0.g(a+h)=g(a)+g'(a)\,h+o(h)\quad\text{as }h\to 0.

Applying this to f(3+x)f(3+x) about x=0x=0, we get

f(3+x)=f(3)+f′(3) x+o(x).f(3+x)=f(3)+f'(3)\,x+o(x).

Substituting into the expression in the numerator,

1+f(3+x)−f(3)=1+(f(3)+f′(3)x+o(x))−f(3)=1+f′(3) x+o(x).1+f(3+x)-f(3)=1+\bigl(f(3)+f'(3)x+o(x)\bigr)-f(3)=1+f'(3)\,x+o(x).

Next, apply the same Taylor expansion to f(2−x)f(2-x) about x=0x=0:

f(2−x)=f(2)+f′(2) (−x)+o(x)=f(2)−f′(2) x+o(x).f(2-x)=f(2)+f'(2)\,(-x)+o(x)=f(2)-f'(2)\,x+o(x).

So the denominator becomes

1+f(2−x)−f(2)=1+(f(2)−f′(2)x+o(x))−f(2)=1−f′(2) x+o(x).1+f(2-x)-f(2)=1+\bigl(f(2)-f'(2)x+o(x)\bigr)-f(2)=1-f'(2)\,x+o(x).

Because the given information tells us f′(3)+f′(2)=0f'(3)+f'(2)=0, we can set

a=f′(3)=−f′(2).a=f'(3)=-f'(2).

Now rewrite both factors with this common constant aa:

Numerator: 1+f′(3) x+o(x)=1+a x+o(x).1+f'(3)\,x+o(x)=1+a\,x+o(x).

Denominator: 1−f′(2) x+o(x)=1+a x+o(x).1-f'(2)\,x+o(x)=1+a\,x+o(x).

Hence the entire fraction is

1+a x+o(x)1+a x+o(x).\frac{1+a\,x+o(x)}{1+a\,x+o(x)}.

To simplify, recall that for small uu,

11+u=1−u+o(u).\frac1{1+u}=1-u+o(u).

Using this,

1+a x+o(x)1+a x+o(x)=(1+a x+o(x))(1−a x+o(x))=1+o(x).\frac{1+a\,x+o(x)}{1+a\,x+o(x)}=(1+a\,x+o(x))\bigl(1-a\,x+o(x)\bigr)=1+o(x).

Thus we have shown that

1+f(3+x)−f(3)1+f(2−x)−f(2)=1+o(x)as x→0.\frac{1+f(3+x)-f(3)}{1+f(2-x)-f(2)}=1+o(x)\quad\text{as }x\to 0.

Let us call this quotient 1+ϕ(x)1+\phi(x), where ϕ(x)=o(x)\phi(x)=o(x), i.e. ϕ(x)x→0\dfrac{\phi(x)}{x}\to 0 when x→0x\to 0.

Our limit becomes

lim⁡x→0(1+ϕ(x))1x.\lim_{x\to 0}\bigl(1+\phi(x)\bigr)^{\frac1x}.

Take natural logarithms to convert the exponential form into a product:

ln⁡ ⁣[(1+ϕ(x))1x]=1x ln⁡(1+ϕ(x)).\ln\!\Bigl[\bigl(1+\phi(x)\bigr)^{\frac1x}\Bigr]=\frac1x\,\ln\bigl(1+\phi(x)\bigr).

Again, for small u,u, the logarithmic expansion is ln⁡(1+u)=u−u22+o(u2).\ln(1+u)=u-\dfrac{u^{2}}{2}+o(u^{2}). Setting u=ϕ(x),u=\phi(x), we have

ln⁡(1+ϕ(x))=ϕ(x)+o(ϕ(x)),\ln\bigl(1+\phi(x)\bigr)=\phi(x)+o(\phi(x)),

and therefore

1x ln⁡(1+ϕ(x))=ϕ(x)x+o ⁣(ϕ(x)x).\frac1x\,\ln\bigl(1+\phi(x)\bigr)=\frac{\phi(x)}{x}+o\!\Bigl(\frac{\phi(x)}{x}\Bigr).

But by construction ϕ(x)x→0,\dfrac{\phi(x)}{x}\to 0, so the entire right-hand side tends to 00.

Consequently,

lim⁡x→0ln⁡ ⁣[(1+ϕ(x))1x]=0,\lim_{x\to 0}\ln\!\Bigl[\bigl(1+\phi(x)\bigr)^{\frac1x}\Bigr]=0,

and exponentiating both sides gives

lim⁡x→0(1+ϕ(x))1x=e 0=1.\lim_{x\to 0}\Bigl(1+\phi(x)\Bigr)^{\frac1x}=e^{\,0}=1.

Since this limit is exactly the one required, we conclude that

lim⁡x→0(1+f(3+x)−f(3)1+f(2−x)−f(2))1x=1.\lim_{x\to 0}\Bigg(\frac{1+f(3+x)-f(3)}{1+f(2-x)-f(2)}\Bigg)^{\frac1x}=1.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Differentiability at a point. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicDifferentiability at a point
TypeMultiple choice