RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 08 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Mathematics question — Points of non-differentiability

Let S={t∈R:f(x)=∣x−π∣⋅(e∣x∣−1)sin⁡∣x∣S = \{t \in R : f(x) = |x - \pi| \cdot (e^{|x|} - 1)\sin|x| is not differentiable at t}t\}. Then the set S is equal to:

SOLUTION

We have the real-valued function

f(x)=∣x−π∣  (e∣x∣−1)  sin⁡∣x∣.f(x)=|x-\pi|\;\bigl(e^{|x|}-1\bigr)\;\sin|x|.

Non-differentiability can come only from the two absolute-value expressions ∣x−π∣ and ∣x∣.|x-\pi| \text{ and } |x|. Hence the only candidate points are x=0andx=π.x=0 \quad\text{and}\quad x=\pi. At every other point each factor is either smooth or the product of smooth factors, so the function must be differentiable there.

Checking differentiability at x=0x=0

For x>0x>0 we have ∣x∣=x,  ∣x−π∣=π−x|x|=x,\;|x-\pi|=\pi-x and sin⁡∣x∣=sin⁡x.\sin|x|=\sin x. Therefore

f(x)=(π−x) (ex−1) sin⁡x.f(x)=\bigl(\pi-x\bigr)\,(e^{x}-1)\,\sin x. Using the standard Maclaurin expansions ex−1=x+x22+O(x3),sin⁡x=x−x36+O(x5),e^{x}-1 = x+\dfrac{x^{2}}{2}+O(x^{3}),\qquad \sin x = x-\dfrac{x^{3}}{6}+O(x^{5}), we obtain

f(x)=(π−x)  (x+x22+O(x3))  (x+O(x3))=(π−x)  (x2+O(x3))=πx2+O(x3).f(x)=\bigl(\pi-x\bigr)\;\bigl(x+\dfrac{x^{2}}{2}+O(x^{3})\bigr)\; \bigl(x+O(x^{3})\bigr) =\bigl(\pi-x\bigr)\;(x^{2}+O(x^{3}))\\ =\pi x^{2}+O(x^{3}).

Hence for x>0x>0

f(x)−f(0)x−0=πx2+O(x3)x=πx+O(x2)→x→0+0.\dfrac{f(x)-f(0)}{x-0} =\dfrac{\pi x^{2}+O(x^{3})}{x} =\pi x+O(x^{2})\xrightarrow[x\to0^{+}]{}0.

For x<0x<0 we have ∣x∣=−x,  ∣x−π∣=π−x|x|=-x,\;|x-\pi|=\pi-x and sin⁡∣x∣=sin⁡(−x)=−sin⁡x.\sin|x|=\sin(-x)=-\sin x. Thus

f(x)=(π−x) (e−x−1) (−sin⁡x).f(x)=\bigl(\pi-x\bigr)\,\bigl(e^{-x}-1\bigr)\,\bigl(-\sin x\bigr). Again expanding, e−x−1=−x+x22+O(x3),−sin⁡x=−(x−x36+O(x5))=−x+O(x3),e^{-x}-1 = -x+\dfrac{x^{2}}{2}+O(x^{3}),\qquad -\sin x = -\bigl(x-\dfrac{x^{3}}{6}+O(x^{5})\bigr)= -x+O(x^{3}), we get

f(x)=(π−x)  (x2+O(x3))=πx2+O(x3).f(x)=\bigl(\pi-x\bigr)\;(x^{2}+O(x^{3})) =\pi x^{2}+O(x^{3}).

Therefore for x<0x<0

f(x)−f(0)x=πx2+O(x3)x=πx+O(x2)→x→0−0.\dfrac{f(x)-f(0)}{x} =\dfrac{\pi x^{2}+O(x^{3})}{x} =\pi x+O(x^{2})\xrightarrow[x\to0^{-}]{}0.

Both the right-hand and left-hand derivatives at x=0x=0 exist and are equal to 0,0, so ff is differentiable at x=0.$</p> <p><strong>Checking differentiability atx=\pi</strong></p><p>Put</strong></p> <p>Putx=\pi+hwithwithh\to0.ThenThen|x-\pi|=|h|,\;|x|=|\,\pi+h\,|=\pi+h(because(because\pi+h>0forsmallfor smallh),and), and\sin|x|=\sin(\pi+h)=-\sin h.Thus</p><p>Thus</p> <p>f(\pi+h)=|h|\;\bigl(e^{\pi+h}-1\bigr)\;(-\sin h) =-|h|\;\sin h\;\bigl(e^{\pi+h}-1\bigr).</p><p>Write</p> <p>WriteK=e^{\pi}-1\;(\text{a positive constant}).ForsmallFor smallh,</p><p></p> <p>e^{\pi+h}-1 = K + h\,e^{\pi}+O(h^{2}),\qquad \sin h = h + O(h^{3}).Therefore</p><p>Therefore</p> <p>f(\pi+h)= -|h|\;h\;\bigl(K+O(h)\bigr) = -K\,h\,|h| + O(h^{3}).</p><p>Nowexaminethederivative.For</p> <p>Now examine the derivative. Forh>0(i.e.(i.e.x\to\pi^{+})</p><p>)</p> <p>\dfrac{f(\pi+h)-f(\pi)}{h} =\dfrac{-K\,h^{2}+O(h^{3})}{h} =-K\,h+O(h^{2})\xrightarrow[h\to0^{+}]{}0.</p><p>For</p> <p>Forh<0(i.e.(i.e.x\to\pi^{-})</p><p>)</p> <p>\dfrac{f(\pi+h)-f(\pi)}{h} =\dfrac{-K\,h\,|h|+O(h^{3})}{h} =\dfrac{-K\,h\,(-h)+O(h^{3})}{h} =K\,h+O(h^{2})\xrightarrow[h\to0^{-}]{}0.</p><p>Thetwoone−sidedlimitsareequal;hence</p> <p>The two one-sided limits are equal; hencefisdifferentiableatis differentiable atx=\piaswell.</p><p>Sinceas well.</p> <p>Sincefisdifferentiableatbothpossibletroublepointsandisobviouslydifferentiableeverywhereelse,thereis<em>no</em>pointatwhichdifferentiabilityfails.Therefore</p><p>is differentiable at both possible trouble points and is obviously differentiable everywhere else, there is <em>no</em> point at which differentiability fails. Therefore</p> <p>S=\varnothing.$$

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Points of non-differentiability. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicPoints of non-differentiability
TypeMultiple choice