RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 26 AUG S2+4 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Mathematics question — Differentiability at a point

Let [t][t] denote the greatest integer less than or equal to tt. Let f(x)=x−[x]f(x) = x - [x], g(x)=1−x+[x]g(x) = 1 - x + [x], and h(x)=min⁡{f(x),g(x)}h(x) = \min\{f(x), g(x)\}, x∈[−2,2]x \in [-2, 2]. Then hh is:

SOLUTION

We begin with the three functions that have been defined:

f(x)=x−[x],g(x)=1−x+[x],h(x)=min⁡{f(x),g(x)},x∈[−2,2].f(x)=x-[x],\qquad g(x)=1-x+[x],\qquad h(x)=\min\{f(x),g(x)\},\qquad x\in[-2,2].

Here [t][t] denotes the greatest integer less than or equal to tt (the floor function). For every real number xx we can write x=[x]+{x},x=[x]+\{x\}, where {x}=x−[x]\{x\}=x-[x] is the fractional part of xx and satisfies 0≤{x}<1.0\le\{x\}\lt 1. Hence, for every x,x,

f(x)={x}andg(x)=1−{x}.f(x)=\{x\}\qquad\text{and}\qquad g(x)=1-\{x\}.

Because 0≤{x}<1,0\le\{x\}\lt 1, it follows that

0≤f(x)<1,0<g(x)≤1,f(x)+g(x)=1.0\le f(x)\lt 1,\qquad 0\lt g(x)\le1,\qquad f(x)+g(x)=1.

Let us examine the behaviour of f(x)f(x) and g(x)g(x) on a typical integral interval. Fix an integer nn; then for every xx in the half-open interval n≤x<n+1n\le x\lt n+1 we have [x]=n[x]=n and hence

f(x)=x−n,g(x)=1−(x−n)=1−f(x).f(x)=x-n,\qquad g(x)=1-(x-n)=1-f(x).

Inside this interval f(x)f(x) increases linearly from 00 up to 1−1^{-} while g(x)g(x) decreases linearly from 11 down to 0+.0^{+}. Now we find where the two graphs meet. We solve

f(x)=g(x)    ⟹    x−n=1−(x−n)    ⟹    2(x−n)=1    ⟹    x=n+12.f(x)=g(x)\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;x-n=1-(x-n)\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;2(x-n)=1\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;x=n+\tfrac12.

So the only point of intersection in the interval [n,n+1)[n,n+1) is at x=n+12,x=n+\dfrac12, where both ff and gg take the value 12.\dfrac12. Therefore, in that interval

{f(x)<g(x)for  n≤x<n+12,f(x)=g(x)for  x=n+12,f(x)>g(x)for  n+12<x<n+1.\begin{cases} f(x)\lt g(x)&\text{for}\;n\le x\lt n+\dfrac12,\\[4pt] f(x)=g(x)&\text{for}\;x=n+\dfrac12,\\[4pt] f(x)\gt g(x)&\text{for}\;n+\dfrac12\lt x\lt n+1. \end{cases}

Because h(x)=min⁡{f(x),g(x)},h(x)=\min\{f(x),g(x)\}, we deduce the explicit description

h(x)={f(x)=x−n,n≤x≤n+12,g(x)=1−x+n,n+12≤x<n+1.h(x)= \begin{cases} f(x)=x-n,& & n\le x\le n+\dfrac12,\\[6pt] g(x)=1-x+n,& & n+\dfrac12\le x\lt n+1. \end{cases}

Thus, on each integral interval [n,n+1)[n,n+1) the graph of hh is a “V”-shaped line: it rises with slope +1+1 from 00 up to 12\dfrac12 and then falls with slope −1-1 back to 0.0. Next we study continuity.

Continuity at interior points of an interval (n,n+1)(n,n+1). Inside (n,n+1)(n,n+1) the formula for hh is linear, so hh is continuous there.

Continuity at the midpoint n+12n+\tfrac12. The left-hand limit equals the common value 12,\dfrac12, the right-hand limit also equals 12,\dfrac12, and h(n+12)=12.h(n+\tfrac12)=\dfrac12. Hence the function is continuous at the midpoint.

Continuity at an integer nn.

Approaching nn from the left we are in the interval (n−12,n)(n-\tfrac12,n) where h(x)=g(x)=1−(x−n)=n+1−x.h(x)=g(x)=1-(x-n)=n+1-x. Taking the limit as x→n−x\to n^- gives lim⁡x→n−h(x)=1−(n−n)=0.\displaystyle\lim_{x\to n^-}h(x)=1-(n-n)=0.

Approaching nn from the right we are in the interval (n,n+12)(n,n+\tfrac12) where h(x)=f(x)=x−n.h(x)=f(x)=x-n. Taking the limit as x→n+x\to n^+ gives lim⁡x→n+h(x)=n−n=0.\displaystyle\lim_{x\to n^+}h(x)=n-n=0.

The value of the function at the integer itself is h(n)=min⁡{f(n)=0,  g(n)=1}=0.h(n)=\min\bigl\{f(n)=0,\;g(n)=1\bigr\}=0. Since the left-hand limit, the right-hand limit and the value are all equal, hh is continuous at every integer.

Because the above discussion covers every point in the domain, we conclude that h(x)h(x) is continuous on the whole closed interval [−2,2].[-2,2].

Now we analyse differentiability. We first compute the derivative in the open sub-intervals where the formula is linear.

For n<x<n+12,h(x)=x−n  ⟹  h′(x)=1.n\lt x\lt n+\dfrac12,\qquad h(x)=x-n\;\Longrightarrow\;h'(x)=1. For n+12<x<n+1,h(x)=1−x+n  ⟹  h′(x)=−1.n+\dfrac12\lt x\lt n+1,\qquad h(x)=1-x+n\;\Longrightarrow\;h'(x)=-1.

Thus, inside each linear segment the derivative exists and equals ±1.\pm1. Possible points of non-differentiability are therefore the junction points, namely

• all midpoints x=n+12,x=n+\dfrac12, • all integers x=n.x=n. Let us check each of these.

At a midpoint n+12n+\tfrac12. Left-hand derivative h−′=1,h'_- = 1, right-hand derivative h+′=−1.h'_+ = -1. Since the one-sided derivatives are unequal, hh is not differentiable here.

At an integer nn. Left-hand derivative (coming from the segment with slope −1-1) equals −1,-1, right-hand derivative (coming from the segment with slope +1+1) equals +1.+1. Again the derivatives are unequal, so hh is not differentiable here either.

Within the open interval (−2,2)(-2,2) the integers that occur are −1, 0, 1-1,\,0,\,1 (three points). The midpoints that occur are

−1.5,  −0.5,  0.5,  1.5-1.5,\;-0.5,\;0.5,\;1.5

(four points). Hence, inside (−2,2)(-2,2) the total number of non-differentiable points is

3+4=7,3+4=7,

which is certainly “more than four.”

Combining the two conclusions we have:

• hh is continuous on [−2,2].[-2,2]. • hh fails to be differentiable at seven points of (−2,2).(-2,2).

This description matches exactly Option A, which states “continuous in [−2,2][-2,2] but not differentiable at more than four points in (−2,2).(-2,2).”

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Differentiability at a point. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicDifferentiability at a point
TypeMultiple choice