JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Differentiability at a point
Let S be the set of all points in (−π,π) at which the function, f(x)=min{sinx,cosx} is not differentiable. Then S is a subset of which of the following?
SOLUTION
We have the function f(x)=min{sinx,cosx} defined for all x∈(−π,π). For a function that is the minimum of two differentiable functions, the only possible points of non-differentiability are
1. the points where the two component functions themselves fail to be differentiable, and
2. the points where the two component functions are equal, because at such points the “smaller” branch may switch from one function to the other, creating a corner.
First, both sinx and cosx are differentiable everywhere on (−π,π), so case 1 gives no new points.
Hence we focus on case 2: points where sinx=cosx.
We solve sinx=cosx:
Divide both sides by cosx (which is non-zero except at isolated points where the equality is already false):
cosxsinx=1⟹tanx=1.
The general solution of tanx=1 is
x=4π+nπ,n∈Z.
We restrict to (−π,π), so we list all integral values of n that keep x in this interval:
For n=0:x=4π(≈0.785) is inside the interval.
For n=−1:x=4π−π=−43π(≈−2.356) is also inside the interval.
For n=1:x=4π+π=45π(≈3.927) exceeds π, so it is excluded.
For n=−2:x=4π−2π=−47π(≈−5.498) is less than −π, so it is also excluded.
Thus the only candidates are
x=−43πandx=4π.
We must now check that the derivative really fails to exist at these points.
To do so we examine the “active” branch of the minimum on either side of each point.
Choose a test point just to the left of 4π, say x=4π−ε with ε>0 very small:
sin(4π−ε)<cos(4π−ε)
(because near the origin sinx<cosx and the inequality persists up to the equality point).
Hence for x<4π we have f(x)=sinx, whose derivative is f′(x)=cosx.
Now pick a point just to the right, x=4π+ε:
sin(4π+ε)>cos(4π+ε)
so for x>4π we have f(x)=cosx, whose derivative is f′(x)=−sinx.
Compute the one-sided derivatives at x=4π:
Left derivative:
limε→0+cos(4π−ε)=cos(4π)=22.
Right derivative:
limε→0+−sin(4π+ε)=−sin(4π)=−22.
These two limits are not equal, so f(x) is not differentiable at x=4π.
An identical calculation around x=−43π shows:
Left derivative at x=−43π:22,
Right derivative at x=−43π:−22,
again unequal, confirming non-differentiability there as well.
No other points in (−π,π) make sinx=cosx, and since both component functions are differentiable everywhere, these two points are the entire set:
S={−43π,4π}.
Now we compare this set with the options given. Option B lists
{−43π,−4π,43π,4π},
which certainly contains both −43π and 4π.
None of the other options contain both of these numbers simultaneously.
Therefore S is a subset of the set in Option B.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Differentiability at a point. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.